Star of the Seas vs Brilliance of the Seas

Star of the Seas

Star of the Seas, launched in 2025, is a colossal marvel, part of the Icon-class, boasting 20 decks and powered by liquefied natural gas (LNG). Its design centers on creating an unparalleled family resort experience at sea, featuring eight distinct neighborhoods. The vibe is decidedly modern, vibrant, and packed with high-energy activities, making it a destination in itself. It’s built for those who thrive on constant stimulation and desire a ship that offers seemingly endless options, pushing the boundaries of what a cruise ship can be for all ages.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas, a Radiance-class ship built in 2002 and last refurbished in 2018, offers a distinctly different, more classic cruise experience. With 12 decks, its design prioritizes stunning panoramic views, thanks to a nine-story glass atrium and numerous exterior-facing elevators. The atmosphere is generally more comfortable and easier to navigate than a mega-ship, appealing to guests who appreciate a relaxed pace and a ship that connects them more directly with the ocean scenery. It provides a solid, traditional cruise experience without being overwhelming.

Star of the Seas

With a passenger capacity of up to 7,600 guests, Star of the Seas generates a lively, bustling atmosphere reminiscent of a floating theme park and resort. The ship is designed to cater extensively to families, thrill-seekers, and first-time cruisers, meaning public spaces and activity zones are often vibrant and energetic. While there are dedicated adults-only areas like The Hideaway and Cloud 17, the overall ambiance is high-octane and dynamic, perfectly suited for those who enjoy a constant buzz and a diverse crowd seeking adventure.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas, accommodating 2,501 passengers with a crew of 848, fosters a more relaxed and social atmosphere. While it can be family-friendly during peak holiday seasons, it often attracts a demographic that appreciates a less frenetic pace. Public venues are generally uncongested, providing ample space for conversation and quiet enjoyment. The emphasis is on comfort and scenic appreciation, making it ideal for those who prefer a convivial environment where connecting with fellow travelers and enjoying the journey are paramount, rather than a non-stop party.

Star of the Seas

Star of the Seas offers an extensive culinary journey with 23 dining options, including both complimentary and specialty venues. Highlights include the Surfside Eatery for families, the new AquaDome Market food hall with five unique stands (Feta Mediterranean, Mac's, Toast and Garden, GNGR, Crème de la Crepe), and the elegant Lincoln Park Supper Club (extra charge). While complimentary options like Windjammer and Pearl Café are available, the review notes that quality can be varied, with the best experiences typically found in the extra-cost specialty restaurants such as Chops Grille and Hooked Seafood.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas provides a solid selection of dining options, offering good value for its size. The Minstrel Dining Room serves daily changing menus for three meals, and the Windjammer Marketplace offers a diverse international buffet, known for its themed stations and popular curries. Park Cafe is a convenient spot for made-to-order sandwiches and salads. Specialty venues like Chops Grille, Giovanni's Table, and Izumi offer elevated experiences for an additional charge, providing a refined culinary adventure. Room service is available for a fee, except for continental breakfast.

Star of the Seas

Entertainment on Star of the Seas is expansive and diverse, featuring grand productions like 'Back to the Future: The Musical' in the Royal Theater, captivating ice shows in Absolute Zero, and thrilling AquaTheater performances. Beyond shows, guests can tackle the Category 6 Waterpark with six slides, brave Crown's Edge, or enjoy mini-golf at Lost Dunes. Nightlife is lively, with options like Dueling Pianos, Lou’s Jazz 'n Blues, Music Hall, and The Attic comedy club, ensuring there's always something engaging, from family-friendly fun to adult-focused venues.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas offers a range of classic cruise entertainment and nightlife. The Pacifica Theatre hosts Broadway-inspired shows and live comedy, complemented by a nine-piece orchestra. Guests can test their skills at the Rock Climbing Wall or Mini-Golf Course, or try their luck at Casino Royale, which also offers complimentary gaming lessons. For evenings, the Schooner Bar provides live piano music and sing-alongs, while the Starquest Nightclub features a live DJ and hosted dance classes. The Viking Crown Lounge is a popular spot for panoramic views and late-night dancing, though the overall nightlife is described as less distinctive than on larger, newer ships.

Star of the Seas

Star of the Seas features 2,805 cabins across 28 distinct categories, with approximately 70% offering a balcony. Accommodations range from compact Interior rooms (156 sq. ft.) to the sprawling Ultimate Family Townhouse (1,772 sq. ft.). Suites are divided into Sea, Sky, and Star tiers, each offering escalating perks, including access to exclusive areas like Coastal Kitchen and The Grove Sun Deck. Families will appreciate options like the Surfside Family Suite and Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony, designed with kids in mind. Guests should note potential noise near the AquaDome or casino if seeking quiet.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas has 1,557 cabins, with 1,075 staterooms spanning Interior, Oceanview, Balcony, and Suite categories. Standard cabins, like the 170 sq. ft. Interior rooms, are comfortable, and connecting options are available. Suites, located on prime decks, include Junior, Grand, Owner’s, and Royal Suites, with most offering concierge service and a private balcony. Some balcony cabins on Deck 7 and Oceanview stateroom 7506 have obstructed views. Overall, the cabins are well-appointed for a mid-size vessel, with sufficient storage and efficient bathrooms, though not as expansive as those on newer ships.

Star of the Seas

On Star of the Seas, service is enhanced for suite guests, with Sky Tier guests receiving concierge services and Star Tier guests enjoying a Personalized Royal Genie. The ship embraces a modern, high-tech style, offering Starlink-powered VOOM internet and a frequently updated Royal Caribbean app for managing schedules and reservations. The onboard environment is designed for efficiency and guest comfort on a grand scale, aiming to deliver a seamless and highly engaging experience across its numerous venues and activities, though the sheer size can mean a less intimate feel.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas offers attentive service, particularly for suite guests who benefit from complimentary concierge services, including priority check-in and reservations. The onboard style is classic and comfortable, with helpful touch screen 'wayfinders' located throughout the ship to aid navigation. While high-speed VOOM internet is available, the ship lacks self-service laundry facilities. The atmosphere is generally more intimate due to the ship's smaller size, fostering a friendly environment where crew members often remember guest preferences, contributing to a Personalized experience, though some areas like the Casino Royale can have a smoky odor.

Star of the Seas

Star of the Seas focuses primarily on 7-night Eastern and Western Caribbean itineraries, with every sailing including a stop at Royal Caribbean's private island, Perfect Day at CocoCay. This consistent inclusion highlights the ship's commitment to delivering a high-energy, sun-drenched vacation experience that seamlessly extends the onboard thrills to a renowned island destination. It’s perfect for those seeking tropical adventures with a blend of relaxation and excitement, especially those looking to maximize their time at CocoCay.

Brilliance of the Seas

Brilliance of the Seas offers a diverse range of itineraries, making it a versatile choice for various travel preferences. Its cruises include Southern Caribbean, Eastern Caribbean, and Bahamas getaways, often featuring stops at Perfect Day at CocoCay on shorter sailings. Beyond the Caribbean, it sails to European destinations like Italy and Croatia, Greek Isles, and offers transatlantic crossings. This variety allows guests to explore distinct cultures and scenic vistas across different regions, appealing to those who prioritize destination immersion and a broader travel scope.