Ship Comparison
Ovation of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas offers a vibrant, tech-forward journey with diverse entertainment and a world-class art collection, while Icon of the Seas redefines family cruising with unparalleled thrills, expansive neighborhoods, and an inclusive atmosphere for all ages.
The verdict
Choosing between Ovation of the Seas and Icon of the Seas truly comes down to the flavor of adventure you seek. Ovation, a Quantum-class ship, shines with its innovative high-tech attractions, global art, and varied itineraries that include the stunning Alaskan wilderness and vibrant Asian ports. It’s perfect for those who appreciate a blend of modern thrills and cultural exploration on a large but manageable vessel. Icon of the Seas, on the other hand, is a colossal marvel, purpose-built as the ultimate family resort at sea. Its sheer scale and dedicated 'neighborhoods' offer an unmatched array of pools, slides, and family-focused entertainment, making it the ideal choice for multi-generational groups prioritizing non-stop fun and convenience within a resort-like environment. While Ovation offers a taste of the future, Icon delivers a full-fledged, immersive family vacation experience unlike any other.
Choose Ovation of the Seas if…
Travelers who appreciate innovative, high-tech attractions and world-class art, enjoy diverse itineraries including Alaska and Asia, and seek a dynamic cruise experience with plenty of activities for all ages.
Best for
- Families seeking a mix of high-tech thrills and relaxation
- Couples who appreciate world-class art and diverse dining
- Travelers interested in scenic destinations like Alaska and Asia
- Guests who value efficient digital services and connectivity
Avoid if
- You prefer an intimate, small-ship experience
- You are on a tight budget for specialty dining and activities
- You dislike crowds, especially during peak times
- You prioritize extensive, tranquil adult-only spaces
Choose Icon of the Seas if…
Families and multi-generational groups looking for the ultimate resort-at-sea experience with extensive waterparks, dedicated family neighborhoods, and a vast array of dining and entertainment options designed for collective fun and individual relaxation.
Best for
- Multi-generational families with young children and teens
- Guests seeking an all-inclusive, resort-like experience at sea
- Thrill-seekers who love waterparks and unique rides
- Those who enjoy vibrant, high-energy entertainment and activities
Avoid if
- You prefer smaller, quieter ships with fewer crowds
- You are looking for a highly refined, adult-centric luxury experience (without family focus)
- You prefer itineraries with many diverse port calls over ship-as-destination
- You are on a strict budget for dining, as many highlights are specialty venues
Overall Vibe
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas, launched in 2016 as a Quantum-class mega-liner, offers a vibrant and technologically forward-thinking cruise experience. The ship, with its 14 decks, creates a dynamic atmosphere, blending relaxation with high-energy thrills. Its design and amenities reflect a modern, global appeal, having been designed with its original deployment in China in mind. Guests can expect a sophisticated yet fun environment, where cutting-edge attractions like the North Star observation capsule and RipCord by iFLY skydiving simulator are seamlessly integrated into the cruise experience. The ship boasts an impressive A$5.8 million art collection, adding a touch of cultural elegance to its innovative spirit, making it feel like a floating modern art gallery.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas, a new Icon-class mega-ship launched in 2023, truly lives up to its name as a floating family resort, spanning an impressive 20 decks. Its vibe is one of unparalleled family fun and incredible choice, designed to be a destination in itself. The ship is powered by LNG, a nod to its modern engineering. With eight distinct neighborhoods, five of which are entirely new, Icon is meticulously crafted to cater to every mood and age group, providing seamless transitions between high-octane thrills and tranquil retreats. The introduction of the first-ever Chief Dog Officer, Rover, a golden retriever puppy, further enhances its unique, welcoming, and joyful atmosphere for all guests.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas fosters a high-energy, family-friendly atmosphere, welcoming up to 4,180 passengers and supported by a dedicated crew of 1,500. This translates to a bustling, lively environment with a good crew-to-guest ratio, ensuring attentive service. The ship's diverse itineraries, including Alaska and Asia, attract a cosmopolitan mix of guests, though the demographic can shift depending on the region. During peak times, popular venues and activities can get busy, but the ship's design, with multiple zones like the tranquil Solarium and the lively SeaPlex, helps distribute crowds. It's a ship that encourages interaction and shared experiences, yet still provides quieter corners for those seeking a moment of calm.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas is a grand vessel built for a bustling, multi-generational crowd, accommodating up to 5,610 passengers with a substantial crew of 2,350. This creates a vibrant, almost city-at-sea ambiance, where the energy is palpable across its eight distinct neighborhoods. Despite its immense capacity, the thoughtful layout aims to manage crowds, offering diverse spaces from the boisterous Thrill Island to the serene Central Park. The ship's primary focus on family fun means a lively, joyful atmosphere is ever-present, with constant activities and entertainment. However, guests should anticipate that popular areas and attractions will be busy, reflecting its status as a premier floating family resort destination.
Dining
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas offers a wide array of 16 culinary experiences, balancing included options with specialty venues. Guests can enjoy diverse global flavors at the complimentary Main Dining Room and the expansive Windjammer Marketplace, or savor Mediterranean dishes at Solarium Bistro. For quick bites, Cafe Promenade and the SeaPlex Dog House are popular spots. Specialty dining includes the theatrical Japanese cuisine at Izumi Teppanyaki, classic American steakhouse fare at Chops Grille, and rustic Italian at Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen. The innovative Wonderland Imaginative Cuisine provides a whimsical, element-inspired culinary journey, while the exclusive Coastal Kitchen caters to suite guests with Mediterranean and Californian fusion.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas boasts an impressive selection of 40 ways to dine and drink, catering to every palate with a strong emphasis on family-friendly options. Complimentary choices abound, from the three-level Dining Room with its rotating international menus to the extensive Windjammer Marketplace buffet. New concepts like the Surfside Eatery are tailored for families with young children, while the AquaDome Market offers a food hall experience with five unique stands. Specialty restaurants elevate the experience with options like the upscale Empire Supper Club, the New England-style Hooked Seafood, and the lively Izumi Hibachi & Sushi. Pier 7 offers a la carte all-day brunch, ensuring a diverse and exciting culinary journey.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas is a hub of high-tech entertainment and dynamic nightlife. The Royal Theatre hosts Broadway-style productions like 'The Beautiful Dream' and 'Live. Love. Legs,' alongside comedy and magic shows. The innovative Two70 transforms from a panoramic lounge by day to a multimedia spectacle with aerialists and robotic screens by night, also hosting a Silent Disco. For active fun, the SeaPlex features bumper cars, roller skating, and trapeze classes. Live music can be found at the Music Hall, Schooner Bar, and Boleros, while the newly added Sound Cellar offers epic tunes. Casino Royale provides gaming action, ensuring a lively atmosphere well into the evening.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas takes entertainment and nightlife to new heights with its groundbreaking venues. The AquaTheatre, set within the AquaDome, features gravity-defying aquatic shows like 'Aqua Action!' and 'Pirates vs. Mermaids,' while the Royal Theater presents Broadway hits like 'The Wizard of Oz' and 'Showband!'. Absolute Zero, the largest ice arena at sea, hosts captivating ice shows. For adult nightlife, guests can enjoy dueling pianos, live jazz at Lou’s Jazz 'n Blues in Central Park, or cocktails at the 1400 Lobby Bar. The Music Hall and Casino Royale ensure the party continues, while unique thrill attractions like Crown's Edge offer daytime excitement, truly making the ship a destination for non-stop fun.
Cabins & Suites
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas offers 2,091 cabins, with 75% featuring balconies, providing ample choice for ocean views. A notable innovation is the 375 interior cabins equipped with 'virtual balconies,' offering real-time external views. Cabins are generally spacious, decorated in soothing blue and light brown tones, and include thoughtful storage solutions. All cabins come with kettles, USB ports, and US/European sockets. Suite guests benefit from three tiers of Royal Suite Class (Sea, Sky, Star), with escalating perks such as access to Coastal Kitchen and personalized Royal Genie service in Star Class. Loft Suites, including the expansive 1,640 sq. ft. Royal Loft Suite, offer luxurious two-floor living, while Studio cabins cater to solo travelers.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas features 2,805 cabins across 28 subcategories, with over 80% designed to accommodate three or more guests, emphasizing its family-centric approach. Approximately 70% of cabins have traditional or 'infinite' balconies, where a window drops down to create an open-air space. Cabins are decorated in a modern palette of blue, gray, and wood, equipped with king-sized beds that convert to twins, ample USB and North American outlets, and mini-coolers. Suite options are extensive, also divided into Sea, Sky, and Star Tiers, offering increasing levels of luxury and personalized services. The standout Ultimate Family Townhouse on Deck 8, complete with a slide and interactive gaming, provides an unparalleled family experience, albeit at a premium.
Service & Onboard Style
Ovation of the Seas
Service on Ovation of the Seas is generally efficient and attentive, with a crew of 1,500 dedicated to ensuring a smooth experience for 4,180 guests. The onboard style is modern and high-tech, characterized by interactive features and a sophisticated art collection. Guests benefit from the Royal IQ app for easy reservations and scheduling, and the option of RFID WOWband wristbands streamlines transactions. While the atmosphere is lively, the crew maintains a professional demeanor, offering assistance where needed. Dining experiences in specialty venues often come with excellent, personalized service, enhancing the overall upscale feel. The ship's global deployment influences its diverse offerings and guest interactions.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas provides a highly personalized and attentive service, supported by a crew of 2,350 for its 5,610 guests, with a strong emphasis on family needs. The onboard style is vibrant and resort-like, designed for maximum comfort and convenience across its distinct neighborhoods. The Royal IQ app is virtually essential for navigating the ship and managing reservations, providing a personalized experience. A unique touch is the presence of Rover, the Chief Dog Officer, who adds a heartwarming, friendly element to the ship's ambiance. Suite guests, particularly those in Star Tier, receive Royal Genie service, elevating their journey with bespoke attention, reflecting the ship's premium, innovative approach to cruising.
Best Itineraries
Ovation of the Seas
Ovation of the Seas is particularly well-suited for itineraries that highlight scenic beauty and diverse cultural experiences. Its Alaska voyages, including Northbound and Southbound sailings to destinations like Hubbard Glacier, are a perfect match for the North Star observation pod, offering unparalleled views. The ship also explores the Mexican Riviera, visiting Cabo, Catalina, and Ensenada, and offers exciting cruises through Asia, with ports in Singapore, Tokyo, Penang, and Phuket. These longer, more destination-focused voyages allow guests ample time to fully immerse themselves in the ship’s extensive onboard activities and explore the unique charm of each port, blending adventure with cultural immersion.
Icon of the Seas
Icon of the Seas is designed for Caribbean itineraries, offering 7-night Eastern and Western Caribbean cruises that frequently include a stop at Perfect Day at CocoCay. This combination is ideal for families and groups who view the ship itself as a primary destination, with the private island stop enhancing the overall resort experience. The shorter, warm-weather sailings allow guests to maximize their time enjoying the ship's unparalleled waterparks, pools, and family-centric neighborhoods without extensive travel days. Its focus on the Caribbean ensures a consistent, sun-drenched vacation experience, perfect for those seeking a high-energy, fun-filled escape close to home.
What reviewers say
Ovation of the Seas
4.5/5Ovation of the Seas is a ground-breaking Quantum-class ship packed with high-tech entertainment and attractions, offering nonstop fun for all. It delights and excites in equal measure, making it ideal for longer itineraries to fully enjoy its many onboard attractions.
Icon of the Seas
4.5/5Innovation and fun are found at every turn on the biggest ship in the world, delivering on its promise of family thrills and incredible choice. This ship offers an exceptional experience for families or groups traveling together who want a ship that is the destination.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Ovation of the Seas
Icon of the Seas
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Ovation of the Seas: High-Tech Fun for All Ages
Discover groundbreaking attractions like North Star and SeaPlex for an unforgettable journey.
Ship Guide
Icon of the Seas: The World's Biggest Family Adventure
Discover endless thrills and incredible choices for families and groups on this innovative ship.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B