Ship Comparison
Norwegian Star vs Pride of America
Norwegian Star offers a classic NCL Freestyle experience with global itineraries, while Pride of America delivers an unparalleled, immersive Hawaiian journey.
The verdict
Both Norwegian Star and Pride of America embody the flexible spirit of Norwegian Cruise Line, yet they offer distinctly different cruise experiences. The Star, having undergone a significant refurbishment in 2018, provides a contemporary mid-sized ship feel with a diverse array of dining and entertainment options across various global routes. It's a solid choice for those seeking the traditional NCL Freestyle experience with plenty of choices. The Pride of America, uniquely U.S.-flagged and sailing exclusively in Hawaii since its 2016 enhancement, stands out for its immersive, destination-rich itinerary with no sea days, offering a deep dive into the islands' culture. While its entertainment might be more localized, its focus on the Hawaiian experience and stellar service makes it an exceptional choice for those prioritizing the destination.
Choose Norwegian Star if…
Norwegian Star is ideal for travelers who appreciate the flexibility of Freestyle Cruising and a wide array of dining and entertainment options on a mid-sized ship. It appeals to families with children of various ages, couples looking for diverse nightlife, and individuals seeking relaxation or activity without strict schedules. Its varied itineraries across the Mediterranean, Northern Europe, Caribbean, and Transatlantic routes also make it suitable for those who enjoy exploring different regions.
Best for
- High energy, live music, vibrant nightlife, theatrical performances, comedy shows, social gatherings, elegant bars, casual pubs, dance floors, casino excitement, themed parties, engaging activities, diverse entertainment, lively atmosphere, cocktail lounges, friendly competition, interactive games, late-night fun, energetic crowds, dynamic spaces.
- Tranquil spa, serene ambiance, fitness focus, healthy living, relaxation zones, rejuvenating treatments, scenic jogging, quiet retreats, indoor pools, thermal suites, ocean views, personal wellness, peaceful moments, comfortable lounges, invigorating workouts, holistic health, self-care, calm environment, refreshing experiences, mindful travel.
- Culinary adventure, diverse flavors, intimate dining, vibrant restaurants, casual eateries, elegant ambiance, international cuisine, flexible mealtimes, gourmet experiences, lively bars, romantic dinners, family-friendly dining, fresh ingredients, specialty cocktails, global menus, relaxed atmosphere, food exploration, unique venues, varied options, delicious desserts.
- Family-friendly, kids' activities, teen hangouts, splash pools, children's programs, youth clubs, casual dining, flexible schedules, engaging entertainment, safe environment, supervised fun, parent relaxation, multi-generational travel, active kids, creative play, movie nights, video games, outdoor recreation, family bonding, memorable vacations.
Avoid if
- Many activities and premium experiences, including certain fitness classes, alcohol tastings, and access to the Thermal Suite or Spice H2O, come with additional fees, which can add up quickly.
- While the fitness center is generally included, access to the spa's Thermal Suite, lap pool, whirlpool, and hydrotherapy pool comes with an extra charge.
- While there are complimentary options, many of the most enticing dining experiences, such as Moderno Churrascaria and Le Bistro, incur additional a la carte fees or fixed charges, plus a service charge.
- No diapers of any kind, including 'swim' diapers, are allowed in any of the ship's pools, which can restrict water play for infants and toddlers.
Choose Pride of America if…
Pride of America is perfectly suited for those whose primary focus is an in-depth exploration of the Hawaiian islands. Its unique year-round, port-intensive itinerary with no sea days ensures maximum time ashore. Families, couples, and culture seekers will appreciate the ship's relaxed, American-centric atmosphere, diverse dining, and enrichment programs centered on Hawaiian culture, all delivered with a high standard of service.
Best for
- Family-friendly, active, cultural immersion, scenic views, daily adventures, kid-focused, spacious, comfortable, island hopping, vibrant, educational, outdoor fun, memorable, convenient, diverse activities, relaxed evenings, American-centric.
- Relaxed elegance, comfortable, sophisticated, intimate (some venues), scenic views, quality dining, attentive service, tranquil, mature ambiance, stylish, well-appointed, romantic, leisurely, quiet corners, refined, uncrowded.
- Cultural immersion, educational, scenic beauty, active exploration, authentic experiences, local insights, historical, natural wonders, adventurous, relaxed pace (onboard), destination-focused, enriching, picturesque, engaging, unique.
- Gourmet dining, diverse cuisines, upscale, refined, culinary adventure, intimate dining, specialty restaurants, elegant, flavorful, sophisticated palate, food-focused, indulgent, romantic dinners, quality ingredients, attentive service, international flavors.
Avoid if
- Shore excursions are extremely popular and often fill up before the cruise even departs, requiring advance booking.
- While there are diverse venues, the overall entertainment offerings, particularly the main shows, could be better according to the editor.
- With the ship in port every day and excursions being highly sought after, spontaneous booking can lead to disappointment as popular options sell out quickly.
- While complimentary options are good, the editor notes that the 'definitely better' food is found at the extra-fee specialty restaurants.
Overall Vibe
Norwegian Star
The Norwegian Star, built in 2001 and thoroughly refurbished in 2018, presents a comfortable and modernized mid-sized ship experience. With 11 decks, it was one of NCL's original Freestyle Cruising vessels, offering a blend of intimate and lively public spaces. The ambiance leans towards casual flexibility, inviting guests to explore over ten diverse restaurants and nearly ten bars and lounges at their leisure. Its design integrates both relaxation, like the Thermal Suite, and active pursuits, such as sports courts, providing a well-rounded atmosphere for a variety of preferences.
Pride of America
Launched in 2005 and significantly enhanced in 2016, Pride of America offers a uniquely American-themed journey, perfectly tailored for its year-round Hawaiian itineraries across 11 decks. The ship exudes a comfortable, spacious mainstream feel with a strong focus on its destination, evident in its Hawaiian ambassador-led enrichment classes and local touches. Its layout and offerings are geared towards maximizing the island experience, creating a relaxed yet engaging environment for guests to savor the beauty of Hawaii without the distraction of sea days.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Norwegian Star
With a capacity for 2,348 guests and a crew of 1,100, Norwegian Star cultivates a casual and flexible atmosphere that appeals to a broad demographic, from families to retirees. Public spaces are designed to accommodate both exuberant gatherings, such as those found in the Bliss Ultra Lounge or by the Oasis Pool, and more intimate moments in venues like Gatsby's Champagne Bar or The Library. The ship's Freestyle concept encourages guests to set their own pace, fostering a relaxed environment where mingling and diverse interests can comfortably coexist.
Pride of America
Carrying 2,186 passengers and a crew of 950, Pride of America offers a distinctly American ambiance, reflecting its exclusive Hawaiian itineraries. The atmosphere is comfortable and spacious, catering well to families, couples, and those seeking cultural immersion. With no sea days, the onboard vibe often revolves around anticipation for the next port, though evenings offer opportunities for relaxation and localized entertainment in venues like the Mardi Gras Cabaret Lounge or the Gold Rush Saloon. It generally maintains a more mature and less frenetic energy, appealing to those prioritizing destination over high-octane shipboard activities.
Dining
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star offers a robust selection of dining experiences, boasting over ten diverse restaurants. Complimentary options include the contemporary Aqua and traditional Versailles main dining rooms, the 24-hour O'Sheehan's Bar & Grill for pub fare, Ginza for Asian fusion, and the Garden Café buffet. For those seeking a specialized experience, additional cost venues like Cagney's Steakhouse, La Cucina for Italian, Le Bistro for French, Moderno Churrascaria for Brazilian meats, and Teppanyaki for Japanese hibachi provide elevated choices. Room service is also available for a fee.
Pride of America
Pride of America features a wide array of culinary choices, blending traditional NCL offerings with a Hawaiian flair. Guests can enjoy complimentary meals at the Skyline Restaurant, Liberty Restaurant, East Meets West for Asian fusion, the 24/7 Cadillac Diner, Aloha Café buffet, and Key West Bar & Grill. Specialty dining, available for an additional cost, includes Jefferson's Bistro (French), Cagney's Steakhouse, La Cucina (Italian), Moderno Churrascaria (Brazilian), and Teppanyaki. Starbucks and Dolce Gelato are also available for a fee, and room service incurs a convenience charge.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Norwegian Star
Entertainment on Norwegian Star is vibrant and varied, centered around the three-deck Stardust Theatre, which hosts Broadway and Vegas-style productions like "Famous Riffz" and "Women of Rock," along with game shows such as "Deal or No Deal." For nightlife, guests can choose from the electrifying Bliss Ultra Lounge, the sophisticated Gatsby's Champagne Bar, or the casual Proof Whiskey Bar. Spice H2O offers an adults-only pool deck by day that transforms into a lively dance spot under the stars. The Star Casino provides gaming action for those feeling lucky.
Pride of America
Onboard entertainment on Pride of America leans into its unique Hawaiian setting. The Hollywood Theatre showcases cultural performances like "Aloha Polynesia" and other production shows. Nightlife options include the New Orleans-inspired Mardi Gras Cabaret Lounge & Nightclub, the casual Waikiki Bar, Pink's Champagne Bar with live piano music, and the Gold Rush Saloon for sports and karaoke. While it lacks a casino due to its U.S. flagging, guests can enjoy daily Hawaiian enrichment classes, trivia, and various dance classes, creating a more destination-focused evening experience.
Cabins & Suites
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star offers 2,348 berths across a wide range of accommodations. Standard rooms feature a 'split bathroom' design, nautical prints, cherry furnishings, and include USB charging ports. Suites are particularly noteworthy, from the spacious Club Balcony Suites to the expansive 3-Bedroom Garden Villas, which include private gardens, hot tubs, and butler/concierge service. Penthouse and Owner's Suites also offer generous living spaces, luxury baths, and enhanced services, providing comfortable options for various group sizes and preferences.
Pride of America
Pride of America accommodates 2,186 guests with a diverse selection of cabins and suites, many reflecting its 2016 enhancement with modern cherry wood finishes. Standard rooms offer amenities like flat-screen TVs and mini-refrigerators. Solo travelers are well catered for with dedicated Solo Studios and Solo Balcony staterooms, which include access to an exclusive Studio Lounge. Suites range from Family Club Balcony Suites to opulent Deluxe Owner's Suites, some boasting baby grand pianos, private hot tubs on large balconies, and comprehensive butler and concierge services, ensuring a luxurious stay.
Service & Onboard Style
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star embodies NCL's Freestyle Cruising ethos, promoting a relaxed and casual onboard style where guests can truly "feel free" to dine and dress as they please. Service is generally attentive, with suite guests benefiting from Personalized butler and concierge services that enhance their journey. The overall atmosphere, from the design of its public spaces to the dining options, is geared towards flexibility and choice, allowing guests to tailor their cruise experience to their individual preferences without rigid schedules.
Pride of America
Pride of America prides itself on stellar customer service, a hallmark of its U.S.-flagged operation. The onboard style is comfortable and distinctly American, with staff known for their friendly and efficient demeanor, enhancing the immersive Hawaiian experience. Suite guests receive Personalized butler and concierge services, adding a layer of luxury. The ship’s overall ambiance is designed to feel welcoming and relaxed, aligning with the laid-back island vibe while maintaining high standards of attentiveness across all dining and activity venues.
Best Itineraries
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star is an excellent choice for travelers eager to explore a variety of global destinations. Its itineraries span the historic and culturally rich Mediterranean, the scenic beauty of Northern Europe, the sun-drenched beaches of the Caribbean, and classic Transatlantic crossings. This diversity allows guests to select voyages that align with their specific travel interests, whether seeking ancient ruins, vibrant cityscapes, tropical relaxation, or the open ocean experience between continents.
Pride of America
Pride of America offers a singularly focused and highly sought-after itinerary: year-round cruises to the Hawaiian Islands. This ship is the only one providing a 7-day, 4-island, 5-port itinerary with no sea days, maximizing time ashore. It's truly the best option for those who want an immersive, comprehensive Hawaiian experience, visiting Maui, Hilo, Kona, and Kauai, allowing guests to deeply engage with the unique culture and natural beauty of the archipelago.
What reviewers say
Norwegian Star
4/5Norwegian Star delivers many of Norwegian's most beloved features on a more intimate scale. Its recent refurbishments have successfully kept this original Freestyle ship modern and appealing to a broad range of cruisers.
Pride of America
4.5/5The Pride of America, significantly enhanced in 2016, offers a stylish and comfortable journey through Hawaii with daily port calls and exceptional service. It caters to diverse interests with a variety of venues, though some of the best dining options come with an additional fee and entertainment could be more robust.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Norwegian Star
Pride of America
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Ship Guide
Norwegian Star: Modern Freestyle Cruising on an Intimate Scale
Discover Norwegian Star, offering a modern take on NCL's Freestyle Cruising with broad appeal.
Ship Guide
Pride of America: Your Hawaiian Islands Cruise
Discover a stylish and comfortable journey through Hawaii with exceptional service and diverse venues on Pride of America.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B