Ship Comparison
Norwegian Gem vs Norwegian Star
For a lively atmosphere and diverse entertainment with a loyal following, choose Norwegian Gem; for a recently refreshed, intimate Freestyle experience across varied itineraries, Norwegian Star is an excellent option.
The verdict
Norwegian Gem and Norwegian Star, both mid-sized ships from Norwegian Cruise Line, offer distinct yet equally appealing takes on Freestyle Cruising. The Gem, launched in 2007 and refreshed in 2015, fosters a lively, convivial atmosphere with a strong emphasis on engaging entertainment and diverse dining, drawing a loyal fan base who appreciate its generous open deck spaces and bustling Atrium. The Star, an older vessel from 2001 but thoroughly modernized in 2018, provides a more intimate and relaxed experience, pioneering many of NCL's signature features on a slightly smaller scale. While both excel in offering flexible dining and entertainment, the Gem leans into vibrant social energy and classic cruise fun, whereas the Star balances modern amenities with a tranquil wellness focus and a broader global reach for itineraries. Your choice hinges on whether you prefer the Gem's energetic, established charm or the Star's recently updated, more serene, yet equally versatile environment.
Choose Norwegian Gem if…
Norwegian Gem is ideal for Freestyle Socialites who thrive on casual, flexible cruising with lively theme parties and diverse activities. It's also a great fit for Family Adventure Crews seeking dedicated kids' clubs and fun pool areas. Entertainment Seekers will appreciate the high-quality shows and active nightlife, while Culinary Explorers can enjoy a wide range of complimentary and specialty dining. Lastly, Relaxed Ocean Lovers will find ample open deck space and scenic views for unwinding.
Best for
- The Freestyle Socialite
- The Family Adventure Crew
- The Entertainment Seeker
- The Culinary Explorer (Flexible)
- The Relaxed Ocean Lover
Avoid if
- You prefer a very quiet, subdued atmosphere, as the ship can be lively.
- You dislike the idea of additional charges for specialty dining and late-night kids' club supervision.
- You seek extensive, high-tech thrill attractions beyond a rock-climbing wall and slides.
- You prefer fixed dining times and formal dress codes over flexible Freestyle Cruising.
Choose Norwegian Star if…
Norwegian Star is perfect for Social Explorers who enjoy vibrant nightlife, diverse live music, and engaging entertainment across numerous lounges. Wellness & Relaxation Enthusiasts will appreciate the Mandara Spa, indoor pools, and jogging track. Freestyle Foodies will delight in the ship's over 10 diverse restaurants, offering both complimentary and specialty options. Finally, Family Fun Seekers will find dedicated kids' and teen clubs, along with a lively splash pool area.
Best for
- The Social Explorer
- The Wellness & Relaxation Enthusiast
- The Freestyle Foodie
- The Family Fun Seeker
Avoid if
- You require extensive pool access for infants and toddlers, as non-potty-trained children are restricted from pools.
- You prefer a ship with a dedicated 'ship-within-a-ship' Haven complex, as Star's suite offerings are integrated differently.
- You are on a strict budget for onboard spending, as many premium experiences incur additional fees.
- You expect cutting-edge, brand-new ship features and attractions, as Star is an older, albeit refurbished, vessel.
Overall Vibe
Norwegian Gem
The Norwegian Gem, launched in 2007 and last refurbished in 2015, offers a cherished, mid-size ship experience, weighing in at 93,530 tons and spanning 15 decks. It embodies Norwegian's Freestyle Cruising concept with a casual yet lively spirit, known for its passionate repeat passengers. The ship strikes a balance between offering diverse activities and maintaining a comfortable scale, appealing to those who enjoy a convivial atmosphere without feeling overwhelmed. Her design prioritizes open deck spaces and a central Atrium that serves as a bustling hub, ensuring a fun-filled journey with a touch of classic cruising charm.
Norwegian Star
The Norwegian Star, introduced in 2001 and significantly refurbished in 2018, presents a modern and refreshed take on a mid-sized vessel, offering 14 decks of amenities. With a tonnage of 91,740, she was a pioneer for NCL's Freestyle Cruising, blending extensive dining and entertainment with a relaxed ambiance. The recent updates have kept her contemporary and inviting, making her an ideal choice for cruisers who seek the beloved Norwegian experience on a more intimate scale. She offers a comfortable and flexible environment, balancing vibrant public spaces with opportunities for quiet relaxation.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Norwegian Gem
Carrying 2,394 guests with a dedicated crew of 1,070, the Norwegian Gem cultivates a casual, flexible, and distinctly convivial atmosphere. Passengers often describe it as lively and fun-filled, especially appealing to diverse age groups and families during holiday periods. The strong crew-to-guest ratio ensures attentive service while maintaining a relaxed vibe where guests feel free to socialize or find their own pace. The ship’s design encourages interaction, creating a friendly community feel, which is a hallmark of its loyal fan base.
Norwegian Star
The Norwegian Star hosts 2,240 passengers with a crew of 1,100, fostering an atmosphere that is both casual and flexible, yet manages to feel intimate. It successfully caters to a broad demographic, from families enjoying dedicated youth clubs to retirees seeking a relaxed pace. Public spaces offer a blend of exuberant energy and calmer retreats, allowing guests to tailor their experience. The attentive crew contributes to a comfortable environment, making it a welcoming home at sea for those who appreciate a balanced and adaptable cruising style.
Dining
Norwegian Gem
Dining on Norwegian Gem offers considerable variety, embracing the Freestyle concept. Complimentary options include the elegant Grand Pacific and the contemporary Magenta main dining rooms, alongside the expansive Garden Café buffet and the casual O'Sheehan's Bar & Grill, a 24/7 pub fare favorite. For a surcharge, guests can indulge in French cuisine at Le Bistro, premium cuts at Cagney's Steakhouse, Italian classics at La Cucina, or the interactive Teppanyaki. The Orchid Garden provides Asian fusion without an additional cover charge, offering a diverse culinary journey.
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star boasts over 10 diverse dining venues. Complimentary choices include the contemporary Aqua and traditional Versailles main dining rooms, the extensive Garden Cafe buffet, and the ever-popular 24-hour O'Sheehan's Bar & Grill. Ginza offers Asian cuisine as a complimentary option, featuring a sushi bar and teppanyaki room (though the teppanyaki itself carries a fee). Specialty restaurants like the Brazilian Moderno Churrascaria, French Le Bistro, Italian La Cucina, and Cagney's Steakhouse offer elevated experiences for an additional charge, ensuring a rich culinary landscape.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Norwegian Gem
The Norwegian Gem truly shines in its entertainment, particularly with its "excellently produced Las Vegas-style shows" in the Stardust Theatre, such as 'Blazing Boots,' 'Ignite the Night,' and 'The Broadway Cabaret.' Nightlife buzzes with diverse bars like Sugarcane Mojito Bar and Maltings Beer & Whiskey Bar, while Bliss Ultra Lounge offers dancing and karaoke. Game shows like 'Deal or No Deal' and 'Wheel of Fortune' engage audiences, and the Gem Casino provides gaming excitement. The popular Glow Party in Spinnaker Lounge keeps the energy high well into the evening.
Norwegian Star
Entertainment on Norwegian Star is vibrant and varied, centered around the Stardust Theatre, which presents Broadway and Vegas-style productions like 'Famous Riffz' and 'Women of Rock.' For those seeking a lively evening, the Bliss Ultra Lounge offers a high-energy dance floor, while Proof Whiskey Bar and Gatsby's Champagne Bar provide more refined settings for drinks. The Star Casino offers gaming, and the adults-only Spice H2O transforms from a daytime retreat to an outdoor dance party under the stars, ensuring diverse options for every mood.
Cabins & Suites
Norwegian Gem
Norwegian Gem offers 1,197 cabins, ranging from comfortable standard rooms to expansive suites. Standard accommodations, including Inside, Oceanview, and Balcony staterooms, are well-laid out, often featuring a 'split bathroom' design. The Haven, a keycard-access-only enclave on Deck 14, provides an exclusive 'ship within a ship' experience. Here, guests find luxurious 3-Bedroom Garden Villas, Deluxe Owner's Suites, and 2-Bedroom Family Villas, complete with private courtyards, hot tubs, butler, and concierge services, offering a truly elevated and personalized stay.
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star features a wide array of accommodations, from standard staterooms to luxurious suites. Standard rooms are comfortably appointed with nautical prints, ample storage, and a 'split bathroom' design, including mini-fridges and USB charging ports. The ship is noted for its enormous 3-Bedroom Garden Villas, accommodating up to seven guests with private gardens, saunas, and hot tubs. Other lavish options include Deluxe Owner's Suites with two balconies and Penthouses, all benefiting from concierge and butler services, enhancing the sense of Personalized attention and comfort.
Service & Onboard Style
Norwegian Gem
Norwegian Gem champions a casual and flexible "Freestyle Cruising" ethos, allowing guests to dine and socialize on their own schedule without formal dress codes or fixed seating. This approach fosters a relaxed, inclusive atmosphere where passengers feel comfortable and at ease. The ship’s style emphasizes fun and interaction, with a crew known for friendly service that contributes to its high repeat passenger rate. It’s a place where guests can truly toss their timetable to the breeze and enjoy a spontaneous holiday.
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star embodies the original spirit of Freestyle Cruising, offering a casual and adaptable onboard experience. Her 2018 refurbishment ensured a modern style, blending contemporary aesthetics with a relaxed, welcoming ambiance. The service culture is attentive and personalized, supporting guests' freedom to choose their dining times and activities. This ship is particularly adept at catering to both those who seek vibrant social spaces and those who prefer quieter moments, reflecting a versatile and accommodating approach to passenger satisfaction.
Best Itineraries
Norwegian Gem
Norwegian Gem is a versatile vessel, offering year-round cruises to a broad spectrum of destinations. Her itineraries frequently include the sun-drenched Caribbean and Bahamas, the historic charm of Europe, and the scenic beauty of Canada & New England. She also embarks on longer Transatlantic voyages and "Extraordinary Journeys," making her a flexible choice for travelers seeking diverse routes, from quick weekend getaways to more extended explorations across oceans and continents.
Norwegian Star
Norwegian Star is well-traveled, known for her extensive and varied itineraries. She frequently sails to the captivating destinations of the Mediterranean and the picturesque landscapes of Northern Europe, offering rich cultural experiences. Additionally, she explores the warm waters of the Caribbean and undertakes Transatlantic crossings, providing a comprehensive range of voyages for guests. Her diverse routes ensure that whether you crave historical sites or tropical beaches, there's likely an itinerary to suit your travel aspirations.
What reviewers say
Norwegian Gem
4/5Norwegian Gem, though not the newest or largest, boasts a fierce fan base drawn to its casual Freestyle Cruising, excellent Las Vegas-style shows, and diverse dining. It offers an accessible and fun experience with generous open deck space and a convivial atmosphere for most cruisers.
Norwegian Star
4/5Norwegian Star delivers many of Norwegian's most beloved features on a more intimate scale. Its recent refurbishments have successfully kept this original Freestyle ship modern and appealing to a broad range of cruisers.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Norwegian Gem
Norwegian Star
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Norwegian Gem: Your Guide to Freestyle Cruising
Discover why Norwegian Gem's loyal fans love its diverse dining, vibrant shows, and relaxed atmosphere.

Ship Guide
Norwegian Star: Modern Freestyle Cruising on an Intimate Scale
Discover Norwegian Star, offering a modern take on NCL's Freestyle Cruising with broad appeal.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B