MSC Lirica

    MSC Cruises

    MSC Lirica

    MSC World America

    MSC Cruises

    MSC World America

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    MSC Lirica vs MSC World America

    For a taste of traditional European elegance, choose MSC Lirica; for a bold, modern, and family-centric Caribbean adventure, MSC World America is your ship.

    The verdict

    These two MSC ships offer distinctly different cruise experiences. MSC Lirica, a smaller, classic vessel, provides an intimate, multi-lingual European ambiance with traditional dining and a focus on Mediterranean itineraries. MSC World America, a newer mega-ship, is designed with the North American market in mind, boasting a plethora of high-energy activities, diverse dining, and exclusive luxury options, primarily sailing the Caribbean. Your ideal choice hinges on whether you seek classic charm and cultural immersion or a vibrant, activity-packed, modern resort at sea.

    Choose MSC Lirica if…

    Travelers who appreciate a more intimate atmosphere, a strong European cultural presence, and traditional dining experiences, especially those exploring the Mediterranean's rich history.

    Best for

    • Travelers seeking a classic, intimate cruise experience
    • Guests who enjoy a multi-lingual European ambiance
    • Those preferring traditional dining with fixed seating
    • Cultural immersion in Mediterranean ports
    • Budget-conscious travelers looking for value

    Avoid if

    • You prefer a large, bustling mega-ship environment
    • You require extensive, high-tech entertainment options
    • You desire flexible, casual evening dining alternatives
    • You are sensitive to noise, as some cabins may be sound-challenged
    • You prioritize cutting-edge modernity and brand-new facilities

    Choose MSC World America if…

    Families and guests seeking a lively, activity-rich, modern cruise experience with extensive dining choices and innovative entertainment, particularly for Caribbean itineraries.

    Best for

    • Families with children and teenagers seeking abundant activities
    • Guests who enjoy a lively, energetic atmosphere
    • Travelers seeking a modern resort-at-sea experience
    • Those looking for diverse dining and entertainment options, including specialty restaurants
    • Cruisers focused on Caribbean itineraries with private island access

    Avoid if

    • You prefer an intimate, quieter cruise experience
    • You dislike large crowds and bustling public areas
    • You are on a very strict budget, as many activities and premium dining incur extra fees
    • You prefer smaller, more traditional ships
    • You are prone to seasickness and prefer lower, middle cabins on smaller vessels

    Overall Vibe

    MSC Lirica

    MSC Lirica, a Mistral-class ship launched in 2003 and refurbished in 2014-2015, exudes a classic, Italian-designed elegance. At 9 decks high, she offers a sleeker, more traditional feel with intimate public rooms and floor-to-ceiling windows providing expansive ocean views. The ambiance is relaxed and spacious, appealing to those who enjoy a refined, less bustling environment where the journey itself is a key part of the charm. It's a ship that favors traditional cruise aesthetics over modern thrills.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America presents a bold, modern, and vibrant atmosphere, characteristic of a new World Class mega-ship. Spanning 16 decks and designed to blend European elegance with American comfort, this vessel offers a revolutionary yet harmonious environment. It features seven distinct themed districts, from serene adult-only areas to action-packed family zones, creating a dynamic and lively setting for a diverse range of guests. The ship feels like a destination in itself, prioritizing extensive onboard experiences.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    MSC Lirica

    With a capacity for 1,976 passengers and a crew of 671, MSC Lirica fosters a more intimate and personal atmosphere. The ship primarily caters to a European audience, resulting in a multi-lingual environment that adds to its authentic charm. Expect a crowd that appreciates cultural immersion and a relaxed pace, with public rooms designed for comfortable socializing rather than large-scale gatherings. It’s ideal for those who prefer a less crowded, more subdued cruising experience.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America is a significantly larger vessel, accommodating up to 6,762 passengers, creating a bustling and energetic environment. Specifically designed to appeal to the North American market, the ship attracts a diverse, often family-oriented crowd. While it offers designated tranquil zones like the Zen Area, many public spaces, especially the Aquapark and World Promenade, can be lively and crowded, reflecting its focus on high-energy activities and broad appeal for all ages.

    Dining

    MSC Lirica

    Dining on MSC Lirica leans towards a traditional experience, featuring included main restaurants like La Bussola and L'Ippocampo, offering sit-down meals with fixed dinner seatings. Casual options include the informal Le Bistrot Cafeteria and La Pergola, which serves pizza, pasta, and burgers in an outdoor setting. Specialty venues, available for an additional charge, include Kaito Sushi Bar for Japanese cuisine, Jia Yao for Chinese, and a delightful Italian Ice Cream Bar. Room service offers a complimentary continental breakfast with a limited menu.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America boasts a wide and diverse culinary landscape, blending included options with numerous specialty restaurants. Main dining rooms like Esagono, Bubbles, and La Foglia offer international cuisine, while Les Dunes caters to Aurea guests with flexible dining times. Specialty options are extensive, including the first Eataly at sea, the new Paxos Greek restaurant, Butcher's Cut steakhouse, and HOLA! Tacos & Cantina. Casual choices range from the expansive Il Mercato buffet to Luna Park Pizza & Burger, ensuring a variety of flavors and dining styles.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    MSC Lirica

    Entertainment on MSC Lirica provides a mix of classic cruise activities and European-inspired offerings. The Broadway Theatre hosts main stage shows with two nightly seatings, while the Las Vegas Casino offers gaming excitement. Live music can be found at the L'Atmosphere Piano Bar and Le Cabaret Lounge, and The Blue Club Disco keeps the party going late. Daytime activities include 'crazy' contests and enriching Italian cooking and language classes, alongside a Lord Nelson Pub for quieter evenings.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America offers a dynamic and innovative entertainment lineup. The World Theatre and Panorama Lounge host high-energy productions like 'Dirty Dancing in Concert' and 'Queen Symphonic.' The ship introduces unique venues such as The Loft comedy club with dueling pianos, the All-Stars Sports Bar, and a secret Prohibition-themed Speakeasy. Thrill-seekers will appreciate the Aquapark, the Cliffhanger over-water swing, the Jaw Drop @ The Spiral dry slide, and bumper cars in the Sportplex, ensuring constant excitement for all ages.

    Cabins & Suites

    MSC Lirica

    MSC Lirica features 988 cabins, with 64 percent offering outside views. Accommodations range from Junior Interior and Ocean View cabins to Junior Balcony and Junior Suite Aurea options. The Junior Suites provide more living space with a 23 sqm interior and a 5 sqm balcony, plus larger bathrooms with bathtubs. While generally comfortable, some cabins have been noted for being 'badly-soundproofed,' which is something to consider for light sleepers, particularly on decks 9-10 where many cabins are located.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America offers 2,614 cabins across a vast spectrum, including the fleet's largest MSC Yacht Club with 152 suites, featuring Owner's Suites with whirlpools and Duplex Suites over two levels. Outside the Yacht Club, Aurea category suites provide perks like thermal area access. Standard Deluxe Balcony and Interior cabins are modern but can feel a bit small with limited storage and cramped bathrooms. Unique Infinite Ocean View rooms offer a faux balcony with a sliding top pane for fresh air, adding a distinctive touch to the onboard experience.

    Service & Onboard Style

    MSC Lirica

    MSC Lirica maintains a traditional, European-influenced service style. The atmosphere is generally relaxed, with a crew count of 671 for 1,976 passengers, aiming for attentive service. The ship embraces a multi-lingual environment, reflecting its diverse European clientele. Dining operates on a 'traditional dining concept' with fixed seating times, fostering a classic cruise experience. While Wi-Fi is available, its quality is noted as limited to an Internet cafe with paid access.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America emphasizes a personalized and modern onboard style, particularly within its expansive MSC Yacht Club, which offers 24-hour butler and concierge service, priority embarkation, and complimentary thermal suite access. For other guests, perks like priority boarding are available with Aurea experiences. While the ship aims for American comfort, the scale of a mega-ship can lead to crowded public areas. The MSC for Me app is available for onboard navigation, though it has been noted to have user-friendliness issues.

    Best Itineraries

    MSC Lirica

    MSC Lirica is ideally suited for enriching Mediterranean itineraries, offering voyages that delve into the historical and cultural heart of Europe. Cruises often visit iconic ports such as Valencia, Barcelona, Marseille, Genoa, Livorno, and Civitavecchia, or explore the Greek Isles with stops in Venice-Marghera, Kotor, Mykonos, and Syros. She also sails to destinations like Istanbul and Bari, providing opportunities for deep cultural immersion and scenic exploration in a more classic cruising fashion.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America is purpose-built for Caribbean exploration, with a year-round base in Miami. Her itineraries focus on the sun-drenched islands and vibrant coastal cities of the region, including calls at Isla de Roatan, Costa Maya, Cozumel, Puerto Plata, and San Juan. A key highlight is the inclusion of Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve, MSC's private island, offering exclusive beach experiences. This ship is perfect for those seeking warm-weather adventures combined with extensive onboard family fun.

    What reviewers say

    MSC Lirica

    3/5

    MSC Lirica is a medium-sized, traditional Mistral-class ship, launched in 2003 and significantly refurbished in 2014-2015. It offers a tasteful Italian-designed interior with intimate public rooms, catering primarily to a European audience.

    MSC World America

    MSC World America is MSC Cruises' boldest claim to conquer the North American market, specifically designed for U.S. cruisers while retaining its strong Italian roots. It offers a terrific value for Caribbean sailings, boasting a family-friendly vibe and a stunning, modern design despite some noise issues.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    MSC Lirica

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    MSC World America

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons