Ship Comparison
MSC Lirica vs MSC Poesia
For a taste of classic European cruising, MSC Lirica offers intimate charm, while MSC Poesia steps up with added luxury and diverse global itineraries.
The verdict
Choosing between MSC Lirica and MSC Poesia truly depends on the kind of experience you're seeking. MSC Lirica, a slightly older and smaller ship, embraces a traditional, intimate European charm, perfect for those who appreciate a more subdued pace and multi-cultural environment with a focus on value. MSC Poesia, while still distinctly European, is a larger and more recently enhanced vessel, particularly with the introduction of the MSC Yacht Club, offering a more luxurious and amenity-rich experience. If you prioritize a cozy, classic ambiance and Mediterranean explorations, Lirica might be your ideal. However, if you desire more onboard variety, upgraded dining, exclusive services, and a broader range of global itineraries, Poesia presents a compelling, albeit different, proposition.
Choose MSC Lirica if…
Travelers seeking a traditional, intimate cruise experience with a strong European flair and excellent value, particularly families looking for child-friendly activities in a multi-lingual setting.
Best for
- Travelers who appreciate a traditional, medium-sized ship experience
- Families seeking child-friendly facilities and activities with a European flair
- Budget-conscious cruisers looking for great value in the Mediterranean
- Guests who enjoy a multi-lingual, international atmosphere
- Those who prefer fixed dining times and a more structured cruise routine
Avoid if
- Guests expecting a large, ultra-modern ship with extensive amenities
- Travelers sensitive to noise, due to noted cabin soundproofing issues
- Those who prefer flexible, casual dining options every evening
- Cruisers seeking a predominantly North American onboard vibe and service style
- Individuals requiring high-speed, ship-wide Wi-Fi connectivity in cabins
Choose MSC Poesia if…
Guests desiring an elegant, amenity-rich cruise with enhanced luxury options like the MSC Yacht Club, diverse dining, and a wider array of global itineraries, all within a lively European-influenced atmosphere.
Best for
- Guests seeking a more luxurious experience with the MSC Yacht Club amenities
- Families looking for diverse kid's clubs and family-friendly dining programs
- Travelers interested in a wide range of global itineraries, including the Caribbean and Alaska
- Cruisers who enjoy elegant decor and a lively, international onboard atmosphere
- Those who appreciate a variety of specialty dining and bar options
Avoid if
- Travelers expecting proactive, American-style service without needing to ask
- Guests sensitive to crowded gyms or inconsistent outdoor activity availability
- Those looking for extensive teen-specific lounges or babysitting services
- Individuals preferring a smaller, more intimate ship experience
- Cruisers who prioritize a brand-new ship aesthetic, as Poesia is older despite enhancements
Overall Vibe
MSC Lirica
MSC Lirica, a medium-sized Mistral-class ship launched in 2003 and refurbished between 2014-2015, exudes a classic, Italian-designed elegance. Across its 9 decks, you'll find a sleek, traditional atmosphere with intimate public rooms that feel comfortably spacious. The decor leans towards tasteful Italian style, creating a relaxed environment where guests can enjoy unimpeded ocean views from various lounges. It's a ship that offers a distinctive cruise experience centered on comfort and hospitality, appealing to those who appreciate a more subdued and culturally rich journey.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia, a larger Musica-class vessel launched in 2008, offers a noticeably more elegant and sophisticated ambiance across its 13 decks. The ship's design blends classic charm with tasteful exuberance, featuring brass handrails, marble countertops, and even a stunning atrium waterfall. It provides a relaxed pace with an international flair, aiming to delight guests with thoughtfully designed public areas for both quiet moments and joyful celebrations. The introduction of the MSC Yacht Club elevates its luxury offering, promising a 'poetic' and memorable cruise experience.
Atmosphere & Crowd
MSC Lirica
With a capacity for 1,976 passengers and a crew of 671, MSC Lirica fosters a multi-lingual European ambiance, making it a wonderful choice for those who enjoy a diverse international crowd. The atmosphere is generally relaxed, with public rooms designed to feel intimate rather than grand. While there are activities for all, it tends to attract a clientele appreciative of its traditional cruising style and the opportunity for cultural immersion. Expect a convivial environment where various European languages are commonly spoken, enhancing the feeling of a global journey.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia caters to a larger crowd, hosting up to 2,550 passengers with a crew of 987, creating a more bustling yet still relaxed European-style atmosphere. The ship often attracts passengers in the 40-to-60 age range, alongside a good number of younger couples and families, particularly during summer sailings. While service is attentive, it reflects a European approach, meaning it's helpful but perhaps less proactively anticipatory than some North American lines. The international flair is evident, and guests should embrace the diverse cultural tapestry onboard.
Dining
MSC Lirica
MSC Lirica offers a traditional dining experience, primarily through its included main restaurants, La Bussola and L'Ippocampo, which provide sit-down meals for breakfast, lunch, and two dinner seatings. For more casual fare, Le Bistrot and La Pergola serve buffet options, with La Pergola also offering outdoor pizza, pasta, and burgers. For a taste of something different, specialty venues like Kaito Sushi Bar, The Italian Ice Cream Bar, and the Vitamin Bar are available for an additional charge, providing variety without overwhelming options.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia provides a more expansive culinary journey. Included dining features the elegant Il Palladio and Le Fontane Restaurants, offering continental cuisine with traditional set-seating dinners, while Le Fontane also provides casual open-seating for breakfast and lunch. The Villa Pompeiana Buffet is a casual international option, open for all meals and late-night snacks. For an additional fee, guests can indulge in the Kaito Sushi Bar or the Butcher's Cut steakhouse. The exclusive MSC Yacht Club Restaurant and Grill & Bar further elevate dining for Yacht Club guests, offering gourmet creations and a dedicated Sommelier.
Entertainment & Nightlife
MSC Lirica
Entertainment on MSC Lirica centers around its two-deck high Broadway Theatre, hosting nightly variety shows designed for a general audience. For evening enjoyment, guests can choose from the Las Vegas Casino, dance to Latin music in the Lirica Lounge, or enjoy mellow tunes at L'Atmosphere Piano Bar. The Blue Club Disco offers late-night dancing, while the Lord Nelson Pub provides a quieter spot for drinks. Daytime activities include 'crazy' contests, Italian cooking and language classes, and a 24-hour video arcade, ensuring diverse options for all ages.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia offers a vibrant array of entertainment designed to captivate a diverse audience. The Teatro Carlo Felice features dazzling nightly shows with acrobats, jugglers, singers, and dancers, transcending language barriers. Nightlife comes alive at the S32 Disco with a live DJ, the Casino Royal for games, and various lounges like the Zebra Bar for dancing to international tunes, or Il Grappolo d'Oro Wine Bar for live piano music and wine tastings. A unique poolside cinema screen offers movies under the stars, adding to the ship's lively and engaging atmosphere.
Cabins & Suites
MSC Lirica
MSC Lirica offers 988 cabins, with options ranging from interior to balcony suites. Standard cabins, averaging 13 sqm, are decorated simply and include a safe, non-interactive TV, and minibar. A notable feature is the 132 balcony mini-suites, which offer a more generous 13 sqm of living space plus a 3 sqm balcony, along with larger bathrooms featuring bathtubs. While comfortable, some guests have noted that soundproofing between cabins could be improved. Wheelchair-accessible cabins are available, ensuring comfort for guests with reduced mobility.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia provides 1223 cabins, including an impressive range of luxury suites within the new MSC Yacht Club. These include the Royal Suite with a whirlpool bath (47 sqm + 78 sqm balcony), Two-Room Grand Suite (28 sqm + 9 sqm balcony), Deluxe Suite (24-30 sqm + 4-6 sqm balcony), and Interior Suite (20 sqm). Standard cabins, from 14 sqm interiors to 18 sqm balcony cabins, feature cream, black, and gold decor with vibrant accents. All cabins come with standard amenities, though internet connectivity requires an Ethernet cable for laptops, as wireless is not available in all cabins.
Service & Onboard Style
MSC Lirica
On MSC Lirica, the service is characterized by its European charm and a multi-lingual crew, fostering a welcoming environment for an international clientele. Guests can personalize their cruise experience through various 'Experiences' such as Bella, Fantastica, and Aurea, each offering different benefits and flexibility. While the service is attentive, it aligns with a traditional European approach, where staff are helpful upon request, contributing to a relaxed and unhurried onboard style that appeals to those seeking authentic continental cruising.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia elevates service, especially with the introduction of the MSC Yacht Club, which offers 24-hour Butler service, a dedicated concierge, and exclusive venues. Across the ship, the service maintains an unabashedly European style, meaning staff are highly capable and helpful, but perhaps less proactively anticipatory than some North American cruise lines. The onboard style is elegant and refined, creating an upscale hotel-like atmosphere. Guests can expect a personalized touch, particularly within the Yacht Club, enhancing the overall feeling of luxury and attentive care.
Best Itineraries
MSC Lirica
MSC Lirica is ideally suited for exploring the rich history and beautiful coastlines of the Mediterranean. Its itineraries frequently visit iconic ports across Italy, Greece, Turkey, Croatia, and Egypt, offering deep cultural immersion. Cruises often depart from hubs like Valencia, Genoa, Marseille, Ancona, or Bari, providing diverse embarkation options. For those who cherish port-intensive cruises with a focus on ancient sites, sun-drenched islands, and vibrant coastal cities, Lirica offers a thoughtfully curated journey through some of the world's most captivating regions.
MSC Poesia
MSC Poesia boasts a truly global reach, offering diverse itineraries that cater to a wide range of travel desires. During the winter, she frequently sails the Caribbean from Miami, exploring destinations like Ocho Rios, Cartagena, and the ABC islands. In the summer, Poesia ventures to the stunning landscapes of Alaska, departing from Seattle to visit Ketchikan, Juneau, and Tracy Arm. Additionally, she undertakes exciting Panama Canal crossings, connecting these vibrant regions. This makes Poesia an excellent choice for adventurers eager to explore multiple continents and diverse cultures.
What reviewers say
MSC Lirica
3/5MSC Lirica is a medium-sized, traditional Mistral-class ship, launched in 2003 and significantly refurbished in 2014-2015. It offers a tasteful Italian-designed interior with intimate public rooms, catering primarily to a European audience.
MSC Poesia
4/5If you're looking for an affordable sailing with an international flare without having to travel too far, this might just be the ship for you. However, it's important to understand what you can expect, as cruises on Poesia aren't bad; they're just different.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
MSC Lirica
MSC Poesia
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B

