Ship Comparison
Explorer of the Seas vs Independence Of The Seas
For a classic, activity-rich cruise, Explorer of the Seas delivers; for modern thrills and updated spaces, Independence of the Seas is the vibrant choice.
The verdict
Choosing between Explorer of the Seas and Independence of the Seas largely comes down to whether you prefer a more traditional Royal Caribbean experience or one that has been recently updated with new, high-energy attractions. Explorer offers a robust selection of activities and dining, embodying the original 'floating resort' feel, though some areas may show their age due to a cancelled refurbishment. Independence, having undergone a significant 'Royal Amplified' refurbishment in 2018, boasts cutting-edge entertainment and refreshed venues, making it a compelling option for those seeking the latest onboard innovations and a lively, modern atmosphere. Both ships excel in providing extensive family-friendly options, but Independence offers a dedicated nursery for the youngest cruisers.
Choose Explorer of the Seas if…
Travelers who appreciate a classic, activity-packed cruise experience with a broad range of options, and are comfortable with a ship that maintains its original charm despite its age.
Best for
- Families seeking a wide range of activities for all ages, including older children and teens.
- Cruisers who prefer a traditional, bustling ship atmosphere with plenty of options.
- Guests interested in diverse itineraries, including European and transatlantic voyages.
- Value-conscious travelers looking for a comprehensive cruise experience with many included activities.
Avoid if
- Guests seeking the latest, most modern ship amenities and decor.
- Light sleepers who may be disturbed by noise from the Royal Promenade in adjacent cabins.
- Travelers looking for a dedicated nursery for babies and toddlers (under 3 years old).
Choose Independence Of The Seas if…
Families and social cruisers eager for the latest onboard thrills, modern entertainment, and refreshed spaces, including dedicated care for very young children.
Best for
- Families with young children, thanks to the Splashaway Bay water park and dedicated nursery.
- Thrill-seekers eager for cutting-edge activities like Sky Pad, Laser Tag, and Escape Rooms.
- Social cruisers who enjoy a vibrant nightlife with diverse bars, lounges, and themed parties.
- Guests prioritizing a recently refurbished ship with modern decor and amenities.
Avoid if
- Those seeking a quieter, more intimate cruise experience.
- Guests who prefer less crowded outdoor deck spaces on sea days.
- Cruisers looking for extensive European or transatlantic itineraries.
Overall Vibe
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas, launched in 2000, offers a classic take on the Royal Caribbean "floating resort" concept. While its planned 2020 refurbishment was unfortunately cancelled, it maintains an active and engaging atmosphere for guests seeking a traditional, yet activity-rich, cruise experience. The ship's design, emphasizing broad appeal and a variety of options, still shines through, providing a welcoming environment for families and those who appreciate a bustling ship with plenty to do, even if some areas show their age. It's a solid, reliable choice for a fun-filled holiday.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas, launched in 2008 and significantly "Royal Amplified" in 2018, presents a refreshed and high-energy vibe. This ship is a dynamic hub of modern thrills and diverse entertainment, designed to keep everyone engaged from morning to night. Its recent updates brought a contemporary edge, ensuring that guests experience cutting-edge activities alongside classic cruise comforts. It's a lively vessel, perfect for cruisers who thrive on constant stimulation and a vibrant, up-to-date environment, making it a popular choice for families and social travelers.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas cultivates an active, family-friendly atmosphere, serving as a comprehensive floating resort for a broad demographic. Carrying up to 4,290 passengers and supported by 1,185 crew members, the ship can feel quite lively and busy, particularly in popular areas. While it offers a wealth of activities for all ages, guests should anticipate a bustling environment and potential queues during peak times. The vibe is generally energetic and social, appealing to those who enjoy a vibrant community at sea.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas exudes a high-energy, fun-focused atmosphere, particularly appealing to families with its extensive range of activities. With a passenger capacity of up to 4,515, it's a social and vibrant ship where there's always something happening. While the decks and popular venues can get crowded, especially on sea days, the ship's design aims to distribute guests across numerous entertainment zones. The overall feeling is one of continuous engagement and excitement, perfect for those who enjoy a lively, spirited holiday.
Dining
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas provides a diverse culinary landscape, anchored by the complimentary Sapphire Dining Room offering rotating international menus, and the 24-hour Cafe Promenade for quick bites. The Windjammer buffet is available, though its steam-table offerings are noted as mediocre. For those inclined to splurge, specialty options like the classic Chops Grille steakhouse, rustic Italian fare at Giovanni's Table, Japanese dishes at Izumi Sushi & Hot Rocks, and the intimate Chef's Table offer enhanced experiences. Johnny Rockets also serves up classic American diner food for a fee.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas offers a slightly more expansive array of dining options, with complimentary venues including the Main Dining Room (Romeo & Juliet, Macbeth, King Lear), Windjammer Cafe, Sorrento's Pizzeria, and the 24-hour Cafe Promenade. Unique complimentary additions like Fish & Ships provide casual British seaside fare, and Sprinkles offers soft-serve ice cream. For a fee, guests can enjoy Izumi Sushi & Hibachi for an interactive Japanese experience, Chops Grille, Giovanni's Table, Johnny Rockets, the sports bar grub at Playmakers, and sweet treats at Sugar Beach. Room service is also available for a flat rate.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas delivers a robust entertainment program, featuring Broadway-style revues in the Palace Theatre, ice skating shows in Studio B, and a bustling Royal Promenade with parades and live music. Active guests will enjoy the FlowRider surf simulator, Perfect Storm water slides, and rock climbing wall. Nightlife is varied with over fifteen bars and lounges, including the nautical Schooner Bar, R Bar, English Pub, and the late-night Club Twenty disco. Traditional cruise activities like game shows, trivia, and outdoor film nights complete the offerings.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas boasts an amplified entertainment lineup, highlighted by the Broadway show 'Grease' in the Royal Theatre and thrilling ice skating performances in Studio B. Innovative attractions include the Sky Pad virtual reality bungee trampoline, the Royal Escape Room: The Observatorium, and glow-in-the-dark laser tag: Battle for Planet Z. The ship features 17 bars and lounges, such as the lively Playmakers Sports Bar & Arcade, Latin-themed Boleros, and the elegant Vintages wine bar. Numerous live bands, DJs, silent discos, and themed parties ensure a vibrant nightlife for all tastes.
Cabins & Suites
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas offers 1,643 staterooms, including 119 suites, across 14 decks. Standard cabins, ranging from 150-275 sq ft, are designed in earth tones and are generally spacious, featuring twin beds convertible to a queen, flat-screen TVs, and basic bathrooms with sliding shower doors. Suite options, like Junior, Grand, Owner's, and the expansive Royal Suite, offer increased space and perks, with the Royal Suite boasting a balcony hot tub. However, Royal Promenade-facing cabins can lack privacy, and some lower-deck staterooms may experience noise from public areas.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas has 1,929 cabins across 38 categories, with 107 newer cabins featuring a modern gray and beige palette, while older ones retain a nautical blue-and-green scheme. All cabins are spacious and comfortable, equipped with interactive flat-screen TVs and ample storage. Suite guests enjoy enhanced amenities, including priority services and access to the exclusive Suite Lounge. Notably, Independence offers a wider array of suite types, including the large Royal Family and Presidential Family Suites, which can accommodate up to 14 guests, making it highly flexible for larger groups or those seeking premium comfort.
Service & Onboard Style
Explorer of the Seas
The service onboard Explorer of the Seas is consistently described as attentive and friendly, particularly within the Main Dining Room. The ship's style leans towards a classic Royal Caribbean feel, with grand public spaces like the multi-deck Royal Promenade. Suite guests and high-tier loyalty members benefit from personalized service and exclusive access to the Concierge Club, which offers complimentary breakfast and evening drinks. While the ship's decor may show some signs of its age, the crew's dedication to guest experience remains a strong point.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas, especially after its 2018 refurbishment, maintains a contemporary and vibrant onboard style. The service is generally attentive, with dedicated Youth Staff for the Royal Babies and Tots Nursery being a standout for families. Suite guests (excluding Junior Suites) receive a host of perks, including access to a private Suite Lounge and sun deck, enhancing their personalized experience. While the ship's design is modern and engaging, the efficiency of the crew ensures a smooth experience, even with the high number of activities and guests seeking their services.
Best Itineraries
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas offers a diverse range of itineraries that take guests far beyond the Caribbean. It's an excellent choice for those looking to explore European destinations, with sailings to Italy, France, Croatia, Greece, and Malta. Additionally, the ship provides unique transatlantic voyages, allowing for extended sea days and exploration between continents, including routes from Spain to Morocco or Bermuda. This variety caters to cruisers who desire cultural immersion and varied port experiences.
Independence Of The Seas
Independence of the Seas primarily focuses on popular routes in the Caribbean, Bermuda, and Canada/New England. It's particularly well-suited for guests who want to experience Royal Caribbean's private destination, Perfect Day at CocoCay, as many of its Caribbean sailings include a stop there. The Bermuda and Canada/New England cruises offer scenic coastal explorations and charming port calls. This ship is ideal for cruisers seeking shorter, activity-packed getaways or classic Caribbean beach holidays with plenty of sun and fun.
What reviewers say
Explorer of the Seas
4.5/5Explorer of the Seas offers a wealth of entertainment, facilities, and activities appealing to all age groups, embodying a floating resort concept. Despite showing some age and having a high passenger capacity that can lead to queuing, its broad range of offerings ensures something for everyone, from active cruisers to families.
Independence Of The Seas
4.5/5Independence of the Seas, affectionately known as Indy, is a beloved Freedom Class ship that underwent a significant refurbishment in 2018, amplifying its focus on onboard activities, entertainment, and thrilling experiences. It offers a vast array of options for all ages, from Broadway shows and water parks to specialty dining and lively bars, making it a highly popular choice for families and social cruisers alike.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Explorer of the Seas
Independence Of The Seas
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Explorer of the Seas: A Dynamic Royal Caribbean Cruise
Discover a wealth of entertainment, facilities, and activities on this Royal Caribbean ship, perfect for active cruisers and families.

Ship Guide
Independence of the Seas: Activities & Family Fun
Discover a Freedom Class ship known for amplified entertainment, water parks, and dining options for everyone.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B