Explorer of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Explorer of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Icon of the Seas

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Explorer of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas

    For a classic, activity-rich cruise, Explorer of the Seas delivers, while Icon of the Seas redefines family adventure with innovative neighborhoods and amplified thrills.

    The verdict

    Choosing between Explorer of the Seas and Icon of the Seas truly depends on what kind of Royal Caribbean vacation you're envisioning. Explorer, a seasoned Voyager-class ship, offers a familiar, robust 'floating resort' experience with a broad array of activities that have delighted guests for years. It's a fantastic option for those who appreciate a well-established cruise formula, where traditional entertainment and dining options blend with signature thrills like the FlowRider and rock-climbing wall. Icon of the Seas, on the other hand, is a groundbreaking vessel, designed from the keel up to be the ultimate family resort at sea. Its innovative 'neighborhood' concept and expanded facilities push the boundaries of what a cruise ship can offer, providing an unparalleled level of choice and immersion. If you seek the very latest in cruise innovation, with distinct zones catering to every mood and age, Icon is the clear choice. However, if you prefer a slightly more intimate, though still lively, atmosphere with proven Royal Caribbean staples, Explorer remains a compelling option, often at a more accessible price point.

    Choose Explorer of the Seas if…

    Travelers who appreciate a robust, activity-filled cruise experience with classic Royal Caribbean features and a broad appeal across generations, without necessarily needing the very latest innovations.

    Best for

    • Families seeking a comprehensive, active vacation without the newest ship price tag.
    • Cruisers who enjoy classic Royal Caribbean amenities like FlowRider and ice skating.
    • Guests looking for diverse itineraries beyond just the Caribbean, including Europe and Transatlantic.
    • Social travelers who appreciate a lively atmosphere with traditional bars and lounges.

    Avoid if

    • You prioritize the absolute newest ship innovations and modern design.
    • You are a light sleeper and sensitive to potential noise from public areas in certain cabins.
    • You prefer a very intimate, quiet, or boutique cruise experience.
    • You expect consistent gourmet dining without additional fees.

    Choose Icon of the Seas if…

    Families and groups seeking the cutting-edge of cruise innovation, with distinct themed neighborhoods, extensive waterpark thrills, and a ship that is a destination in itself, offering a truly immersive experience.

    Best for

    • Families with young children or teens seeking an unparalleled array of dedicated activities.
    • Thrill-seekers looking for the largest waterpark at sea and unique adrenaline-pumping experiences.
    • Travelers who value innovative ship design and distinct themed 'neighborhoods' for diverse experiences.
    • Suite guests desiring enhanced luxury, personalized service, and exclusive amenities like Royal Genie.

    Avoid if

    • You prefer a smaller, more intimate ship experience with fewer crowds.
    • You are on a strict budget, as the newest ship often comes with a higher price point and many paid extras.
    • You seek itineraries with a broader global reach beyond the Caribbean.
    • You prefer a traditional, subdued cruise atmosphere over a high-energy, bustling resort at sea.

    Overall Vibe

    Explorer of the Seas

    Explorer of the Seas, a Voyager-class ship launched in 2000, embodies a classic 'floating resort' feel. While it shows its age in some areas (its planned refurbishment was unfortunately cancelled), its enduring design across 14 decks still offers a comprehensive and active experience. It's built for those who enjoy a lively, entertainment-rich atmosphere with plenty of signature Royal Caribbean activities readily available. The ship carries a seasoned charm, providing a comfortable and familiar setting for a diverse range of cruisers looking for a vibrant, fun-filled getaway.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas, launched in 2023, is a groundbreaking vessel across 20 decks, designed as the ultimate 'floating family resort.' This ship radiates an innovative and high-energy vibe, segmented into eight distinct neighborhoods, each with its own character and activities. It’s a destination in itself, offering a fresh, modern, and highly immersive experience that pushes the boundaries of cruise ship design. From tranquil oases to adrenaline-pumping thrills, Icon provides a dynamic and visually striking environment crafted for multi-generational enjoyment, promising a holiday that is truly next-level.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Explorer of the Seas

    The atmosphere on Explorer of the Seas is generally active and family-friendly, appealing to a broad demographic. With a maximum passenger capacity of 4,290 and a dedicated crew of 1,185, the ship can feel lively, especially during peak seasons. While popular activities and dining times might lead to queues, the layout ensures there's always something happening, fostering a social environment. Guests can expect a vibrant energy, particularly around the Royal Promenade and pool deck, making it ideal for those who enjoy a bustling, engaging communal experience.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas generates an incredibly vibrant and innovative atmosphere, specifically tailored for multi-generational families. Its substantial size, accommodating up to 5,610 passengers with a crew of 2,350, is managed through clever 'neighborhood' design, aiming to distribute crowds. Expect a high-energy environment, particularly in areas like Thrill Island and Surfside, balanced by more serene zones such as Central Park and The Hideaway. The ship fosters a sense of shared adventure and collective excitement, making it a bustling hub for all ages seeking diverse experiences.

    Dining

    Explorer of the Seas

    Explorer of the Seas offers a solid mix of complimentary and specialty dining. The Main Dining Room provides a formal, three-course experience with rotating international menus and attentive service. For casual bites, the 24-hour Cafe Promenade and the buffet-style Windjammer Marketplace are available, though the latter can be mediocre. Specialty options like Chops Grille for steaks, Giovanni's Table for Italian, and Izumi for Japanese fare are well-regarded and worth the extra cost, providing quality, cooked-to-order meals for those seeking an elevated culinary experience.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas boasts an expansive culinary landscape with 40 ways to dine and drink, catering to every palate. Complimentary options like the three-level Dining Room offer varied themes, while the well-designed Windjammer Marketplace provides a strong buffet experience. New concepts like the AquaDome Market food hall and Surfside Eatery cater to diverse tastes, though some venues may be 'so-so.' Specialty restaurants such as Empire Supper Club for gourmet dining, Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen, and Hooked Seafood are highlights, offering premium, personalized experiences that truly stand out.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Explorer of the Seas

    Entertainment on Explorer of the Seas is a blend of classic cruise fun and signature Royal Caribbean thrills. Guests can enjoy Broadway-style shows in the Palace Theatre, ice-skating spectaculars in Studio B, and a casino royale. Active options include the FlowRider surf simulator, The Perfect Storm waterslides, and a rock-climbing wall. Nightlife spans over fifteen bars and lounges, from the nautical Schooner Bar with piano sing-alongs to the elegant R Bar. The Royal Promenade hosts parades and themed parties, ensuring a lively atmosphere day and night.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas elevates entertainment with innovative, boundary-pushing experiences. It features Category 6, the largest waterpark at sea, and the adrenaline-inducing Crown's Edge thrill ride. The AquaTheater presents gravity-defying shows like 'Aqua Action!', while Absolute Zero hosts impressive ice-skating productions. Nightlife is diverse, with Dueling Pianos, the Music Hall, Spotlight Karaoke, and specialized bars like Lou’s Jazz n’ Blues and the 1400 Bar. The ship's eight neighborhoods offer varied entertainment, ensuring constant engagement and new discoveries for all ages.

    Cabins & Suites

    Explorer of the Seas

    Explorer of the Seas offers 1,643 staterooms, including 119 suites, providing a comfortable retreat. Standard cabins are spacious, decorated in earth tones, and feature essential amenities. Suite guests enjoy access to the Concierge Club, offering continental breakfast and evening drinks. While Royal Promenade-facing staterooms provide unique views, they can be noisy. Light sleepers might also find noise an issue in cabins near public spaces on lower decks. The Royal Suite, Owner's Suite, and Grand Suites offer enhanced space and perks, with the Ocean View Panoramic Suites providing expansive windows without a balcony.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas features a remarkable 2,805 cabins, with over 80% designed to accommodate three or more guests, reflecting its family focus. It introduces 28 cabin subcategories, including innovative infinite balconies and new family-specific layouts. Suites are tiered into Sea, Sky, and Star classes, each offering escalating perks from Coastal Kitchen access to personalized Royal Genie service. The standout Ultimate Family Townhouse, complete with a slide and private backyard, is a testament to its family-centric luxury. Cabins feature a modern, subdued palette, generally offering good soundproofing, though storage can be tight for larger groups.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Explorer of the Seas

    On Explorer of the Seas, the service is generally attentive and friendly, particularly in the Sapphire Dining Room. The onboard style leans towards a classic, well-established cruise experience where guests can expect reliable service delivery. Suite guests benefit from personalized attention and exclusive access to the Concierge Club, enhancing their journey with dedicated amenities. While not focused on cutting-edge personalization, the crew strives to provide a warm and welcoming environment, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable cruise for all passengers.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas elevates service and onboard style with a focus on innovative, personalized experiences across its distinct neighborhoods. Suite guests in the Sky and Star tiers receive enhanced benefits, including Royal Genie service for the highest categories, offering a truly bespoke journey. The ship even features a Chief Dog Officer, Rover, adding a unique, heartwarming touch to the onboard community. The overall style is modern and vibrant, with thoughtful design choices aimed at creating seamless and memorable interactions for every guest, from family programming to specialized bar concepts.

    Best Itineraries

    Explorer of the Seas

    Explorer of the Seas offers a diverse range of itineraries, catering to various travel desires. It frequently sails to destinations across the Mediterranean, including Italy, France, Croatia, Greece, Adriatic, and Malta, providing rich cultural and historical experiences. Additionally, it offers numerous Caribbean cruises, visiting Eastern, Western, and Southern Caribbean ports, often including stops at Perfect Day at CocoCay. For those seeking longer voyages, Transatlantic crossings to Spain and Morocco or Spain and Bermuda are also available, showcasing its global reach and adaptability.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas, as Royal Caribbean's newest and largest ship, primarily focuses on captivating Caribbean itineraries. Its sailings are heavily centered around the Eastern and Western Caribbean, with a consistent highlight being visits to Perfect Day at CocoCay, Royal Caribbean's private island. This focus allows guests to fully immerse themselves in the ship's extensive onboard offerings and the enhanced island experience. The itineraries are designed to complement the ship's 'floating resort' concept, making the journey as much a destination as the ports themselves, perfect for those seeking tropical adventures.

    What reviewers say

    Explorer of the Seas

    4.5/5

    Explorer of the Seas offers a wealth of entertainment, facilities, and activities appealing to all age groups, embodying a floating resort concept. Despite showing some age and having a high passenger capacity that can lead to queuing, its broad range of offerings ensures something for everyone, from active cruisers to families.

    Icon of the Seas

    4.5/5

    Innovation and fun are found at every turn on the biggest ship in the world, delivering on its promise of family thrills and incredible choice. This ship offers an exceptional experience for families or groups traveling together who want a ship that is the destination.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Explorer of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Icon of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons