Ship Comparison
Explorer of the Seas vs Star of the Seas
The Explorer of the Seas offers a classic, activity-rich Royal Caribbean experience, while the Star of the Seas introduces a new era of expansive, family-focused innovation with groundbreaking features and neighborhoods.
The verdict
Choosing between Explorer of the Seas and Star of the Seas really comes down to the kind of cruise experience you're seeking. Explorer, a seasoned Voyager-class vessel, offers a well-loved, active 'floating resort' feel with a slightly more intimate scale, having been refurbished in 2020. It's a fantastic choice for those who appreciate a broad range of established Royal Caribbean staples, from rock climbing to ice skating, without the sheer scale of the newest ships. Star of the Seas, on the other hand, is a brand-new Icon-class ship launching in 2025, pushing boundaries with its sheer size and innovative, distinct neighborhoods. It's designed to be the ultimate family vacation, packed with cutting-edge thrills, diverse dining, and expansive spaces that redefine what a mega-ship can offer. If you prioritize the very latest in onboard experiences and a truly vast array of options, Star is your pick; if you prefer a slightly more familiar, yet still vibrant, atmosphere, Explorer holds its own.
Choose Explorer of the Seas if…
The Explorer of the Seas is ideal for families and active cruisers who enjoy a traditional, activity-packed Royal Caribbean experience on a slightly smaller, yet still grand, scale. It appeals to those seeking a balance of adventure and relaxation with a solid array of dining and entertainment options, without needing the absolute newest innovations.
Best for
- Families seeking a classic Royal Caribbean experience with diverse activities
- Active cruisers who enjoy rock climbing, surfing, and ice skating
- Guests looking for a balance of traditional cruising and modern amenities
- Those interested in European cultural itineraries or varied Caribbean routes
Avoid if
- You prioritize the very latest in ship design and technology
- You prefer a quiet, adults-only cruise experience exclusively
- You are sensitive to potential noise from Promenade-facing cabins
- You expect consistent gourmet quality across all complimentary dining venues
Choose Star of the Seas if…
The Star of the Seas is perfect for multi-generational families and thrill-seekers looking for the ultimate, most expansive, and innovative cruise vacation. It's designed for guests who want to explore distinct themed neighborhoods, enjoy record-breaking attractions, and indulge in a vast array of dining and entertainment on a brand-new, cutting-edge ship.
Best for
- Families desiring the most expansive and innovative cruise vacation
- Thrill-seekers eager to experience the largest waterpark at sea and unique attractions
- Guests who appreciate themed neighborhoods and diverse entertainment options
- Cruisers who want guaranteed visits to Perfect Day at CocoCay
Avoid if
- You prefer a smaller, more intimate ship experience
- You dislike large crowds and potential queues at popular attractions
- You are on a strict budget, as specialty dining and premium extras can add up
- You prefer a more traditional, less 'resort-like' cruise atmosphere
Overall Vibe
Explorer of the Seas
The Explorer of the Seas, launched in 2000, embodies the classic Royal Caribbean 'floating resort' concept, offering a comprehensive and engaging experience for guests of all ages across its 14 decks. While its refurbishment was cancelled, it continues to deliver a lively, comfortable atmosphere, balancing signature thrills like the FlowRider and rock climbing with more relaxed spaces. The ship feels grand but manageable, with a welcoming environment that encourages both adventure and leisurely enjoyment. It’s a ship that has cultivated a loyal following, appreciated for its well-rounded offerings.
Star of the Seas
Debuting in 2025, the Star of the Seas is a groundbreaking Icon-class vessel, setting a new standard for a family vacation at sea across its impressive 20 decks. As one of the world's largest cruise ships, it presents a vibrant, colorful, and whimsically tropical atmosphere, segmented into eight distinct neighborhoods. The ship is engineered for an all-encompassing, resort-like experience, offering a blend of record-breaking thrills and serene escapes. Its design emphasizes innovation and variety, promising a truly immersive and engaging journey for everyone onboard.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Explorer of the Seas
With a passenger capacity of 4,290 and a crew of 1,185, Explorer of the Seas fosters an active and family-friendly atmosphere that appeals to a broad demographic. The ship is designed for lively engagement, from athletic competitions on the sports court to vibrant parades on the Royal Promenade. While it can feel bustling, especially in popular areas, the ratio of guests to crew aims for attentive service. Guests tend to be energetic and social, seeking fun and varied experiences, making for a generally upbeat and welcoming environment.
Star of the Seas
The Star of the Seas is built to host a significant crowd, with a passenger capacity of 7,600, creating a dynamic and bustling atmosphere. It's designed to be a vibrant hub for families and thrill-seekers, with distinct neighborhoods that help distribute the flow of guests while maintaining a high-energy vibe. The ship's focus is on delivering a continuous stream of entertainment and activity, ensuring that every corner offers something new to discover, catering to those who thrive in a lively, grand-scale vacation setting.
Dining
Explorer of the Seas
Dining on Explorer of the Seas offers a mix of complimentary and specialty options. The three-level Main Dining Room provides international menus, including healthy and vegetarian choices, with attentive service. For casual bites, the 24-hour Cafe Promenade and the Windjammer buffet are available, though Windjammer's quality can be inconsistent. Specialty venues like Chops Grille for steak, Giovanni's Table for Italian, and Izumi for Japanese cuisine provide elevated, cooked-to-order experiences at an additional charge, offering a worthwhile upgrade for culinary enthusiasts.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas elevates the culinary journey with 23 dining options, showcasing an expansive variety of flavors. Complimentary highlights include the three-story Dining Room, the Pearl Cafe for 24-hour snacks, and the innovative AquaDome Market food hall with diverse international stalls. The family-focused Surfside Eatery and grab-and-go Surfside Bites cater specifically to younger guests. For an elevated experience, specialty venues like the new Lincoln Park Supper Club, Chops Grille, Hooked Seafood, and Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar offer premium, distinct culinary adventures for an additional fee.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas delivers a robust entertainment program, from Broadway-style shows in The Palace Theatre to ice-skating spectaculars in Studio B. Active guests can enjoy the FlowRider surf simulator, The Perfect Storm waterslides, and a rock-climbing wall. Nightlife is varied, with Casino Royale, live music at the Schooner Bar, themed parties on the Royal Promenade, and cocktails at the R Bar and English Pub. There’s a consistent buzz across the ship, ensuring options for all ages and preferences, from quiet lounges to lively dance floors.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas offers an unparalleled spectrum of entertainment, featuring 'Back to the Future: The Musical' in the Royal Theater, immersive ice shows in Absolute Zero, and high-diving performances in the AquaTheater. Thrill Island boasts the Category 6 waterpark and the daring Crown's Edge skywalk. Nightlife flourishes with Dueling Pianos, live jazz at Lou’s Jazz n’ Blues, comedy at The Attic, and the Music Hall for dancing. Unique bars like the Swim & Tonic swim-up bar and The Hideaway infinity pool provide distinct social settings, ensuring diverse options for every evening.
Cabins & Suites
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas features 1,643 staterooms, including 1,001 ocean views and 652 balcony cabins. Standard cabins, ranging from 150 to 275 sq ft, are designed in earth tones with quality furnishings, offering twin beds convertible to queen, and basic amenities. Suite options, including Junior, Grand, Owner's, and the Royal Suite, provide more space and luxury, with access to the Concierge Club. It's worth noting that Royal Promenade-facing staterooms may experience noise, and some aft cabins have partially obstructed views, which is something to consider when booking.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas offers 2,805 cabins across 28 categories, with approximately 70% featuring a balcony. Even entry-level interior rooms are thoughtfully designed, starting at 156 sq ft. The ship introduces innovative options like the Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony cabins and diverse suite tiers (Sea, Sky, Star) with escalating perks. Signature suites include the three-story Ultimate Family Townhouse with its own slide, and the Royal Loft Suite with expansive views. Cabins are equipped with modern amenities and designed to maximize comfort and functionality for families and groups.
Service & Onboard Style
Explorer of the Seas
Onboard Explorer of the Seas, the service is generally described as attentive and friendly, particularly in the Main Dining Room. The ship maintains a classic cruise style, where guests can enjoy traditional activities like dance lessons and art auctions. While some aspects of the ship show its age, the crew's dedication to creating a welcoming environment is consistent. Suite guests benefit from access to the Concierge Club, providing an added layer of personalized service and exclusive amenities, enhancing the overall experience for those seeking a more premium touch.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas aims for a high standard of service, particularly for its suite guests, who benefit from a tiered system of perks including concierge service and Royal Genies for Star Tier guests. The ship's modern design and numerous distinct zones contribute to a contemporary and vibrant onboard style. Technology plays a role in enhancing the guest experience, with the Royal Caribbean app facilitating reservations and navigation. The overall ethos is one of innovation and a personalized approach, ensuring guests feel well-cared for amidst the ship's expansive offerings.
Best Itineraries
Explorer of the Seas
Explorer of the Seas offers a diverse range of itineraries, appealing to various travel preferences. For those seeking cultural immersion, European cruises to destinations like Italy, France, Croatia, and the Greek Isles are popular choices. Sun-seekers can opt for Eastern, Western, or Southern Caribbean sailings, often including visits to Royal Caribbean's private destination, Perfect Day at CocoCay. The ship also undertakes transatlantic voyages to Spain and Morocco, providing longer, more relaxed sea days for a different kind of adventure.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas is primarily focused on Caribbean itineraries, with every sailing including a stop at the highly acclaimed Perfect Day at CocoCay. This emphasis positions it as a premier choice for those seeking sun-drenched, activity-filled island getaways in the Eastern and Western Caribbean. The inclusion of Perfect Day at CocoCay on all voyages ensures guests can experience Royal Caribbean’s private island destination, known for its extensive waterpark and beach club options, making it ideal for families and couples alike seeking a comprehensive island experience.
What reviewers say
Explorer of the Seas
4.5/5Explorer of the Seas offers a wealth of entertainment, facilities, and activities appealing to all age groups, embodying a floating resort concept. Despite showing some age and having a high passenger capacity that can lead to queuing, its broad range of offerings ensures something for everyone, from active cruisers to families.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas, Royal Caribbean's second Icon-class vessel, debuts in August 2025 as one of the world's largest cruise ships, offering a comprehensive, family-friendly resort-like experience. It expands on the Oasis Class concept with extensive dining, activities, and cabin options, featuring notable upgrades and variations from its sister ship, Icon of the Seas.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Explorer of the Seas
Star of the Seas
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Explorer of the Seas: A Dynamic Royal Caribbean Cruise
Discover a wealth of entertainment, facilities, and activities on this Royal Caribbean ship, perfect for active cruisers and families.

Ship Guide
Star of the Seas: Royal Caribbean's New Family Adventure
Set sail August 2025 on a comprehensive, resort-like cruise designed for all ages.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B