Carnival Valor

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Valor

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Splendor

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Carnival Valor vs Carnival Splendor

    For a classic 'Fun Ship' experience with a touch of Americana, choose Valor; for a bold, family-centric voyage with enhanced spa offerings, Splendor awaits.

    The verdict

    Carnival Valor provides a comfortable, inclusive cruise with a lively spirit and unique American history theme, perfect for those who appreciate attentive service and port-intensive itineraries. Carnival Splendor, while boasting a vibrant, sometimes eclectic decor, offers an extensive array of activities and a standout spa, making it an excellent choice for families and groups seeking constant entertainment and relaxation opportunities.

    Choose Carnival Valor if…

    Travelers seeking a lively, comfortable cruise with a classic Carnival 'Fun Ship' atmosphere, diverse complimentary dining, and a crew known for attentive service.

    Best for

    • Families and groups seeking a lively, value-oriented cruise
    • Travelers who appreciate attentive and friendly crew service
    • Guests interested in American history-themed decor
    • Foodies who enjoy diverse, complimentary casual dining options like Guy's Burgers and BlueIguana Cantina
    • Cruisers who prefer port-intensive itineraries

    Avoid if

    • Those sensitive to noise from connecting cabins or nearby kids' clubs
    • Guests looking for ultra-modern cabin aesthetics
    • Travelers who dislike a casual, high-energy 'Fun Ship' atmosphere
    • Individuals who require more than one 110V outlet in their cabin
    • Passengers seeking extensive, exclusive spa amenities

    Choose Carnival Splendor if…

    Families and groups who prioritize abundant activities, a large spa, and a festive, energetic environment, even if the decor is a bit unconventional.

    Best for

    • Families with children and teens due to extensive youth programs and waterslides
    • Wellness enthusiasts seeking a comprehensive spa experience with thermal suites and thalassotherapy
    • Guests who enjoy high-energy entertainment, including Broadway-style shows and a vibrant nightlife
    • Food lovers interested in diverse dining options, including Indian cuisine at Masala Tiger
    • Cruisers who appreciate a ship as a destination with many onboard activities

    Avoid if

    • Travelers sensitive to bold, sometimes jarring interior decor
    • Those seeking a consistently quiet and uncrowded ship experience
    • Guests expecting recently refurbished, modern cabins
    • Individuals who prefer a more subdued or elegant onboard atmosphere
    • Passengers who prioritize fast main dining room service before shows

    Overall Vibe

    Carnival Valor

    The Carnival Valor, launched in 2004 and refurbished in 2016, embodies a lively, comfortable, and inclusive atmosphere, perfectly aligned with Carnival's 'Fun Ship' ethos. Spanning 14 decks, she has a distinctive American history theme woven throughout her public spaces, offering a sense of playful patriotism. Guests can expect a casual environment where the emphasis is on relaxation and enjoyment, with many modern amenities from her Fun Ship 2.0 upgrades, creating a well-rounded and engaging vacation experience for everyone onboard.

    Carnival Splendor

    The Carnival Splendor, built in 2008, presents a vibrant and fun-focused atmosphere, though its bold and sometimes eclectic decor, featuring bright pink crown molding and squiggly patterns, certainly makes a statement. This vessel, spread across 14 decks, is designed to keep all 3,012 passengers entertained with a huge array of activities. While the interior design might not be to everyone's taste, the ship's festive spirit and extensive offerings ensure a memorable voyage, particularly for those who appreciate constant diversions and a lively, energetic setting.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Carnival Valor

    Carnival Valor cultivates a relaxed 'no shoes, no shirt, no problems' ambiance, drawing a diverse crowd of all ages. With a capacity for 2,980 guests and 1,180 crew members, the ship manages to feel comfortable and inclusive, rather than overly crowded. The atmosphere is generally upbeat, with plenty of opportunities for socializing in various lounges or by the pools. Guests can enjoy a balance of active fun and quieter moments, supported by a crew known for being attentive and friendly, ensuring a pleasant journey for everyone seeking a cheerful cruise experience.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor, carrying 3,012 passengers and 1,160 crew, lives up to its name with a lively, fun-focused, and family-friendly atmosphere that appeals to a broad demographic, from young children to seniors. While the ship's energy is infectious, there can be an occasional sense of overcrowding, particularly in popular areas and during peak dining times. However, the sheer volume of activities and entertainment options helps disperse guests, allowing for both bustling social hubs and more tranquil spots like the dedicated adults-only Serenity deck.

    Dining

    Carnival Valor

    Dining on Carnival Valor offers a blend of complimentary and specialty options. Guests can enjoy traditional multi-course meals in the Art Deco-styled Washington and Lincoln Dining Rooms, which also host a popular SeaDay Brunch. For casual bites, the Rosie's Restaurant Lido buffet is a go-to, alongside highly-rated poolside favorites like Guy's Burger Joint for savory burgers and BlueIguana Cantina for fresh tacos and burritos. Other included options include Mongolian Wok, Ol’ Fashioned BBQ, and Pizza Pirate. For a more intimate experience, Scarlett's Steakhouse and The Chef's Table are available for an additional cost, with Java Cafe offering specialty coffees and sweets.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor provides a robust dining scene with many complimentary choices. The Gold Pearl and Black Pearl main dining rooms offer traditional dinners with singing wait staff, while the multi-level Splendido Lido buffet is a hub for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Standout included options are Guy's Burger Joint for customizable burgers, Pizzeria del Capitano for 24/7 pizza, and the popular Masala Tiger for Indian cuisine. Specialty dining includes Fahrenheit 555 steakhouse, The Chef's Table, and The Seafood Shack, all available for an additional fee. JavaBlue and Juice & Java cater to coffee and fresh juice cravings, rounding out a diverse culinary journey.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Carnival Valor

    Carnival Valor’s entertainment lineup is designed for broad appeal, featuring Broadway-style production shows like 'Nightclub Express' and 'Far from Over' in the Ivanhoe Theater, alongside popular Playlist Productions. Comedy lovers can head to The Punchliner Comedy Club for family-friendly and adult-only shows. Nightlife thrives with numerous bars such as the RedFrog Pub, Alchemy Bar, SkyBox Sports Bar, and the lively Lindy Hop Piano Bar. Daytime fun includes trivia, poolside games, mini-golf on Deck 12, and the exhilarating 214-foot Twister waterslide on Deck 10, ensuring constant engagement for all ages.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor keeps the party going with a diverse range of entertainment across its 14 decks. The Spectacular Spectacular Theatre hosts Broadway-style shows and interactive game shows, while The Punchliner Comedy Club offers nightly laughs in the El Morocco Lounge. A key highlight for water lovers is WaterWorks, featuring the thrilling Green Lightning thrill-slide and a tamer Twister Waterslide, complemented by the Splendido Lido Pool with its retractable roof and Dive-In Movies. Nightlife options abound with the Red Carpet Dance Club, Grand Piano Bar, and the sophisticated Alchemy Bar, alongside live music and casino gaming in the Royal Flush Casino.

    Cabins & Suites

    Carnival Valor

    Carnival Valor offers 1,492 cabins, generally well-maintained and spacious, with interior rooms at 185 sq ft and ocean-view at 220 sq ft. The decor features a burnt-orange color scheme with cherry-wood furniture, providing a comfortable, if somewhat dated, feel. Standard amenities include robes, a hair dryer, safe, and flat-screen TV. Suites, ranging from Junior to the expansive Captain's Suite, offer added space, larger balconies, and VIP perks like priority boarding. It's worth noting that connecting interior cabins can be prone to noise, and the kids' club location on Deck 12 is directly above the spa, which may affect tranquility for spa-goers.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor's cabins, totaling 1,503, are consistently sized at 185 sq ft for standard interior, ocean-view, and balcony categories, with balconies adding 3 to 7 sq m of outdoor space. While functional, the rooms generally feel dated, lacking major refurbishments since 2008, with some featuring bold, bright-pink crown molding. A significant draw is the Cloud 9 Spa cabins and suites, which offer exclusive spa access, upgraded amenities, and priority embarkation. Guests should be aware that interior cabins with windows overlooking walkways may have privacy concerns, and bathrooms in standard cabins are shower-only, unlike the larger suite bathrooms with whirlpool tubs.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Carnival Valor

    On Carnival Valor, the service is consistently highlighted as attentive and friendly, contributing significantly to the ship's comfortable and inclusive atmosphere. The crew of 1,180 works diligently to uphold the 'Fun Ship' mantra, ensuring guests feel welcome and well-cared for, from the dining room staff to stateroom attendants. The overall style is casual and relaxed, encouraging guests to embrace a carefree vacation. This personalized approach to service helps create a positive and memorable experience, making guests feel like part of the Carnival family.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor's onboard style is characterized by a festive and energetic ambiance, delivered by its 1,160 crew members who strive to provide a fun-filled experience. While the service is generally efficient, it's the ship's vibrant personality and extensive activity schedule that truly define the onboard style. The crew embraces the high-energy environment, from singing wait staff in the main dining rooms to engaging youth counselors. Guests can expect a cheerful, dynamic atmosphere, where the focus is on maximizing fun and creating memorable moments through a wide range of offerings.

    Best Itineraries

    Carnival Valor

    Carnival Valor is particularly well-suited for travelers who appreciate port-intensive itineraries, offering frequent opportunities to explore diverse destinations. The ship's design and activity set cater to guests who enjoy balancing their time between exciting onshore adventures and a lively, comfortable shipboard experience. Its schedule often features shorter, engaging cruises that allow for a quick getaway without sacrificing the full Carnival 'Fun Ship' experience, making it a great option for those looking to maximize their time in port and enjoy a relaxed journey.

    Carnival Splendor

    Carnival Splendor excels in offering itineraries that cater broadly to families and groups, providing a wealth of onboard activities and entertainment options to keep everyone engaged, regardless of the destination. While specific itineraries aren't detailed, the ship's extensive amenities, from its WaterWorks slides to the Cloud 9 Spa, ensure that the journey itself is a significant part of the vacation. It's an ideal choice for cruisers who value a ship as a destination in itself, with plenty of diversions and a vibrant atmosphere to enjoy between calls at various ports.

    What reviewers say

    Carnival Valor

    4/5

    Carnival Valor offers excellent value and a comfortable, fun atmosphere appealing to all ages. Its attentive service and diverse onboard offerings ensure a satisfying cruise experience without feeling like an exclusive party.

    Carnival Splendor

    4/5

    Carnival Splendor offers a fun-filled, value-packed cruise experience with ample activities and entertainment for all ages. While its decor is bold and cabins could use updating, the ship's festive spirit and extensive spa make for a memorable voyage.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Carnival Valor

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Carnival Splendor

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons