Ship Comparison
Carnival Spirit vs Carnival Tropicale
The Carnival Spirit offers a proven, value-packed journey with a friendly crew, while the upcoming Carnival Tropicale promises a new era of family-centric innovation and spacious design.
The verdict
For travelers seeking an established, fun-filled experience with a highly attentive crew and diverse activities, Carnival Spirit is a solid choice. Its 'hodgepodge' decor contributes to its unique charm, and the value for money is consistently highlighted. On the other hand, Carnival Tropicale, set to launch in 2028, is for those who prioritize the very latest in cruise ship innovation, particularly large families. Its Excel-class design, new waterpark, and expanded interconnecting cabins suggest a cutting-edge, activity-rich environment, even if some features are yet to be fully experienced.
Choose Carnival Spirit if…
Travelers who appreciate a lively, established ship with a reputation for exceptional crew service, a wide variety of dining, and entertainment options for all ages, particularly those seeking a great value family holiday.
Best for
- Families seeking a wide range of activities and kids' clubs
- Couples looking for a mix of lively fun and adult-only relaxation areas
- Value-conscious cruisers who appreciate abundant complimentary dining options
- Social travelers who enjoy live music, comedy, and engaging pub experiences
- Guests who value attentive and friendly crew service
Avoid if
- Those who prefer ultra-modern or minimalist ship decor
- Travelers seeking the absolute newest ship innovations
- Guests who prefer a very quiet, intimate cruising experience at all times
- Cruisers on a strict budget for spa treatments
Choose Carnival Tropicale if…
Families and active cruisers eager to experience Carnival's newest Excel-class innovations, including a sprawling new waterpark and enhanced youth programming, in a larger, modern setting.
Best for
- Large families or groups needing interconnecting cabins
- Thrill-seekers eager to experience a brand-new waterpark with multiple slides
- Modern cruisers interested in the latest ship design and features
- Guests who enjoy high-energy, vibrant social and musical entertainment
- Parents with infants or toddlers, due to the dedicated 'Turtles' program
Avoid if
- Travelers who prefer smaller, more intimate ship environments
- Guests specifically seeking the BOLT roller coaster found on other Excel-class ships
- Those who prefer established ships with proven service records
- Cruisers who dislike large crowds and bustling public areas
Overall Vibe
Carnival Spirit
The Carnival Spirit, built in 2001 and refurbished in 2015, exudes a characterful, mass-market charm. Its decor is often described as an eclectic 'hodgepodge of styles,' ranging from Egyptian to English manor, which some find delightfully quirky. This Spirit-class ship has cultivated a reputation as a top-value holiday, offering a laid-back and genuinely fun atmosphere. Despite its age, it remains a favorite, celebrated for providing a comprehensive cruise experience where relaxation and excitement comfortably coexist for a diverse range of guests.
Carnival Tropicale
The Carnival Tropicale, launching in 2028, represents the future of Carnival's Excel-class mega-ships, promising a fresh and innovative cruising experience. As a newbuild, it will debut with a modern aesthetic and cutting-edge features. This ship is designed to be a destination in itself, focusing on expansive, vibrant spaces and advanced amenities, including being powered by liquified natural gas (LNG). Its very name pays tribute to Carnival's history while setting the stage for a new generation of onboard excitement and style.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit cultivates a wonderfully laid-back, fun, and friendly atmosphere. With a passenger capacity of 2,124 and a dedicated crew of 930, the ship maintains an inviting ratio that contributes to its renowned service. The crowd typically comprises a pleasant mix of families, couples, and singles, all united by a desire for an enjoyable and unpretentious holiday. The emphasis here is on shared fun and a welcoming environment, making every guest feel part of the lively onboard community.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is designed to host a significantly larger crowd, with a passenger capacity of 5,356. While its crew count of 926 is similar to Spirit's, the much higher guest capacity suggests a bustling, high-energy environment. The atmosphere is anticipated to be vibrant and active, heavily geared towards families and those seeking a dynamic, activity-filled cruise. The sheer scale of this Excel-class ship means public spaces will be grander, accommodating a diverse, energetic demographic ready for constant engagement and excitement.
Dining
Carnival Spirit
Dining on Carnival Spirit offers a delightful blend of included and specialty options. Guests can enjoy three-course meals in the grand Empire Restaurant or casual, variety-packed selections at La Playa Grille, which includes 24-hour pizza and ice cream. Complimentary poolside favorites like Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina are highly popular. For an elevated experience, there's Nouveau Restaurant for steaks, Bonsai Sushi 2, the fresh Seafood Corner, and the highly recommended Chef's Table, offering a multi-course degustation with free-flowing wine.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale will expand on Carnival's popular dining concepts, featuring complimentary mainstays like Guy's Burger Joint, Pig & Anchor Smokehouse Brewery for BBQ, and Big Chicken. A new, currently unnamed dining outlet will replace the former Chibang concept, promising fresh culinary experiences. While specific details on other specialty venues are pending, the Excel-class lineage suggests a broad array of choices designed to cater to diverse palates within its larger, modern framework, ensuring plenty of casual and included options for all guests.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit offers a vibrant entertainment lineup, from Vegas-style revues and Playlist Productions in Pharaoh's Palace to the adult-focused Punchliner Comedy Club with multiple shows nightly. Guests can enjoy live music and sing-alongs at the Shanghai Piano Bar or RedFrog Pub, test their luck at the Louis XIV Casino, or dance into the late hours at Dancin' Nightclub. The Alchemy Bar provides a sophisticated cocktail experience, while Dive-In Movies on the Lido Deck offer family-friendly evening viewing under the stars.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is set to introduce innovative entertainment, with new music venues spread across decks 6, 7, and 8, including zones for outdoor performances. A major highlight will be the Sunsation Point waterpark, which transforms into a lively evening venue with illuminations and a DJ, offering a unique party atmosphere for all ages. While specific production shows are yet to be detailed, the ship's Excel-class status and focus on dynamic, modern experiences suggest a forward-thinking approach to onboard fun, catering to socializers and music lovers.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit features 1,062 cabins, with approximately 75% being outside staterooms (ocean views or balconies), and 80% of those boasting balconies. The decor leans towards earth tones, and all cabins are equipped with essentials like twin beds convertible to a king, flat-screen TVs, and Australian power points. Suites, including Grand, Vista, Ocean, and Junior categories, offer enhanced space, larger balconies, and VIP amenities such as priority services, complimentary laundry, pillow-top mattresses, and ELEMIS bath products, with some even featuring whirlpool tubs.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale will significantly enhance cabin flexibility, introducing 1,000 interconnecting cabins, a 70% increase compared to previous Excel-class ships. This design choice caters directly to larger families and groups traveling together, making multi-room bookings more convenient. Notably, it will not feature the Family Harbor staterooms found on other Excel ships, indicating a shift towards broader interconnecting options rather than a dedicated family zone. The focus is on modern, spacious accommodations to support the ship's family-centric and active atmosphere.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Spirit
The Carnival Spirit is consistently lauded for its 'exceedingly friendly and attentive crew,' often described as 'five-star.' This high level of personalized service creates a warm and welcoming onboard style, where staff anticipate needs and contribute significantly to the ship's fun-loving atmosphere. From the main dining room's singing waiters to the efficient guest services, the crew's dedication ensures a comfortable and enjoyable journey, fostering a sense of familiarity and genuine care that keeps guests returning.
Carnival Tropicale
As a new Excel-class ship, Carnival Tropicale will embody a modern and efficient onboard style. While specific crew reviews are not yet available for this future vessel, Carnival's brand standard for service remains. However, with a significantly higher passenger capacity, the service approach may lean more towards streamlined, technologically integrated experiences. The ship's design, emphasizing large public spaces and innovative self-service options, will likely shape an onboard style that prioritizes convenience and broad appeal for its diverse and active guest demographic.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit, with its established appeal to Australian cruisers and a versatile array of activities, is ideally suited for itineraries that offer a blend of relaxation and adventure, often within regional waters. Its mid-size capacity allows for varied port calls, providing a 'top-value holiday' that balances time onboard enjoying the Green Thunder waterslide and Guy's Burger Joint with exploring diverse destinations. It's perfect for those seeking a comprehensive, fun-focused experience without necessarily venturing on the longest voyages.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale, as an Excel-class mega-ship launching in 2028 with significant innovations like Sunsation Point and enhanced youth programming, is destined for itineraries where the ship itself is a major draw. Its large capacity and extensive onboard attractions make it a prime choice for longer voyages and cruises to popular, high-demand destinations that can accommodate its size. The ship will appeal to families and active travelers looking for a destination-rich journey where the onboard experience is as central as the ports of call.
What reviewers say
Carnival Spirit
4.5/5Carnival Spirit offers a top-value holiday for all ages, delivering fun activities, good food, and exceptional service. Despite its eclectic decor, the ship provides a laid-back, friendly atmosphere that keeps passengers returning.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is an upcoming Excel-class ship, slated for a 2028 launch, promising significant innovations and a strong family focus. This preview highlights its new top-deck attractions and enhanced cabin configurations designed to cater to a broad audience.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Tropicale
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B

