Ship Comparison
Carnival Elation vs Carnival Tropicale
For a classic, intimate cruise full of fun, consider Carnival Elation, or look to the future of family-friendly mega-ships with the innovative Carnival Tropicale.
The verdict
Choosing between Carnival Elation and the forthcoming Carnival Tropicale really comes down to your cruising style and what you prioritize in a vacation. The Elation, a seasoned Fantasy-class ship, offers a charming, smaller-ship experience, perfect for those seeking a laid-back, value-focused trip with plenty of proven Carnival fun. Its recent refurbishments ensure comfort, but it retains a nostalgic feel. Tropicale, on the other hand, represents the cutting edge of Carnival's Excel-class, promising a grand, energetic, and activity-rich environment that will likely appeal to families and thrill-seekers looking for the very latest in onboard experiences. It's a choice between established comfort and exciting innovation.
Choose Carnival Elation if…
Carnival Elation is ideal for cruisers who appreciate a traditional, smaller-ship experience with a strong emphasis on value and a lively, unpretentious atmosphere. It's particularly well-suited for families with children who will enjoy the dedicated youth programs and waterpark, as well as adults seeking a relaxed getaway with accessible dining and entertainment.
Best for
- Families seeking an affordable, fun-filled cruise with dedicated kids' programs.
- Cruisers who prefer a classic, smaller-ship experience with easy navigation.
- Guests looking for a casual, unpretentious atmosphere with popular included dining options.
- Adults desiring a peaceful retreat at the Serenity Deck while still enjoying a lively ship.
Avoid if
- You prefer the latest high-tech features and modern ship design.
- You are sensitive to potential noise from public venues in certain cabins.
- You seek extensive upscale specialty dining and shopping options.
- You're looking for a very quiet, adults-only luxury experience.
Choose Carnival Tropicale if…
Carnival Tropicale is designed for modern families and active cruisers eager for the newest and most expansive onboard attractions. With its focus on innovative top-deck experiences, enhanced youth facilities, and a significant number of interconnecting cabins, it will cater to multi-generational groups and those who thrive in a vibrant, high-energy mega-ship environment.
Best for
- Families with children of all ages, especially those with infants, due to dedicated programs and extensive interconnecting cabins.
- Thrill-seekers and active guests looking for innovative waterparks, adventure trails, and sports facilities.
- Modern cruisers interested in new ship concepts, LNG-powered vessels, and cutting-edge entertainment.
- Social travelers who enjoy vibrant music venues and lively evening events with DJs and illuminations.
Avoid if
- You prefer a smaller, more intimate ship experience with fewer crowds.
- You specifically want a BOLT roller coaster, as Sunsation Point replaces it.
- You are looking for Family Harbor staterooms, as this ship will not feature them.
- You prefer a very quiet, traditional cruise experience without mega-ship amenities.
Overall Vibe
Carnival Elation
The Carnival Elation, launched in 1998 and last refurbished in 2017, offers a classic, comfortable cruise experience. As a Fantasy-class ship, it's known for its more intimate scale compared to newer vessels, providing an uncrowded atmosphere that appeals to those seeking a relaxed pace. While its decor features a blend of 1970s colors and Vegas touches, it exudes a charming retro feel. It's a ship that values traditional cruising fun and good value, making it a reliable choice for guests who enjoy a familiar and easy-to-navigate environment without the overwhelming scale of larger ships.
Carnival Tropicale
The Carnival Tropicale, slated for launch in 2028, is a brand-new Excel-class mega-ship, representing the future of Carnival's fleet. This vessel promises a modern, innovative, and high-energy atmosphere, powered by liquified natural gas (LNG). It's designed to showcase cutting-edge features and new concepts, building on the success of its predecessors. The overall vibe will be vibrant and active, appealing to cruisers who desire the latest in ship design, technology, and entertainment, all within a grand and expansive setting that pushes the boundaries of onboard experiences.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Elation
With a passenger capacity of 2190 and a dedicated crew of 920, Carnival Elation fosters a lively, casual, and distinctly family-friendly atmosphere. Its smaller size means public spaces feel less overwhelming, and the crew-to-guest ratio allows for a more attentive and personalized service. Guests often describe the environment as unpretentious and easygoing, where socializing comes naturally. It's a ship where families can enjoy dedicated activities like Camp Ocean, and adults can find their calm at the Serenity Adult-Only Retreat, all while feeling part of a cheerful, community-like cruise experience.
Carnival Tropicale
The Carnival Tropicale, with a substantial passenger capacity of 5356 and a crew of 926, will present a bustling, vibrant, and active mega-ship atmosphere. This Excel-class vessel is designed to accommodate a larger crowd, emphasizing diverse activities and entertainment zones that can absorb many guests simultaneously. Its focus on innovative outdoor attractions and enhanced youth programming suggests a dynamic environment, particularly appealing to families and groups seeking constant engagement. The scale of the ship means a lively buzz will permeate throughout, offering endless opportunities for social interaction and energetic fun.
Dining
Carnival Elation
Carnival Elation offers a robust selection of dining options, with many popular complimentary choices. Guests can enjoy the casual, poolside delights of Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina for fresh burgers and Mexican fare. The Tiffany's Lido Restaurant provides a varied buffet, while the Inspiration and Imagination Restaurants serve as main dining rooms, offering both assigned and flexible dinner times, plus breakfast. For a special treat, The Chef's Table provides an exclusive, multi-course experience for an additional cost, complemented by a la carte options at Bonsai Sushi Express and JavaBlue Café.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is set to continue Carnival's tradition of popular, included dining, featuring favorites like Guy's Burger Joint for poolside burgers, Pig & Anchor Smokehouse Brewery for BBQ, and Big Chicken for casual chicken dishes. The ship will also introduce an unnamed new outlet, replacing a previous Chinese and Mexican eatery, promising a fresh culinary concept. While specific details on specialty dining are still emerging, its Excel-class heritage suggests a focus on diverse, accessible, and high-quality casual options that cater to the ship's vibrant, family-oriented atmosphere, ensuring plenty of choices for every palate.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Elation
Entertainment on Carnival Elation centers around classic cruise fun, offering a variety of choices for all ages. The Limelight Lounge hosts the popular Punchliner Comedy Club with both family-friendly and adult-only shows, while Playlist Productions features lively musical performances. Live music can be found across several venues, including Duke's Piano Bar and the Drama Bar. For daytime thrills, WaterWorks boasts the Twister waterslide and racing slides, complemented by mini-golf and outdoor deck games. Evenings also offer casino action, ensuring a full spectrum of engaging activities.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is poised to introduce innovative and high-energy entertainment options. A major highlight will be the new Sunsation Point Waterpark, replacing the BOLT roller coaster, which will feature six slides, splash pads, and even evening illuminations with a DJ. This promises a dynamic space for both daytime fun and nighttime festivities. Beyond the waterpark, the ship will offer a Treehouse-inspired Elevated Adventure Trail, a ropes course, sports court, and a new mini-golf course. New music venues across decks 6, 7, and 8, including outdoor performance zones, indicate a vibrant nightlife scene catering to diverse musical tastes.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Elation
Carnival Elation provides generally spacious and comfortable cabins across various categories. Standard interior and ocean view staterooms measure around 185 square feet, accommodating up to five guests, with some unique porthole options. Balcony staterooms offer a private 35 square foot outdoor oasis. For those desiring more space and perks, suites like the Junior, Grand, and Grand Vista Suites provide enhanced comfort, larger balconies (up to 115 sq ft), and VIP amenities such as priority check-in and complimentary laundry. Guests should note potential noise on certain decks and some obstructed views in specific Junior Suites.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is designed with a strong emphasis on family and group accommodations, boasting 1,000 interconnecting cabins, a significant 70 percent increase compared to its Excel-class predecessors. This innovative approach aims to provide flexible and convenient options for larger families or friends traveling together. While specific square footage details for all cabin types are not yet available, the focus on interconnecting rooms highlights a commitment to practical and communal living spaces. It's important to note that, unlike some other Excel ships, Tropicale will not feature Family Harbor staterooms, signaling a different approach to family-specific areas.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Elation
The service on Carnival Elation is often lauded for its friendly and attentive crew, a hallmark of Carnival's classic fleet. With a guest-to-crew ratio that allows for more personalized interactions, guests can expect a comfortable and unpretentious onboard style. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, encouraging a sense of ease and familiarity. This ship embodies a traditional cruise experience, where the crew plays a significant role in creating a welcoming and fun environment, ensuring that guests feel well-cared for without excessive formality, contributing to its overall good value.
Carnival Tropicale
As a new Excel-class ship, Carnival Tropicale is expected to offer a modern and dynamic onboard style, driven by its innovative features and expansive size. The service will be geared towards efficiently managing a larger guest capacity while maintaining Carnival's reputation for fun and engaging crew interactions. While the sheer scale might lead to a different feel than a smaller ship, the emphasis on enhanced youth programming and diverse activity zones suggests a crew well-versed in facilitating high-energy experiences. The overall style will be vibrant, active, and contemporary, aiming to provide a seamless and exciting vacation for all.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Elation
While specific itineraries for Carnival Elation are not provided in the current information, as a Fantasy-class ship, it typically excels on shorter, value-oriented cruises to popular regional destinations. Its comfortable size and proven onboard offerings make it a fitting choice for quick getaways or introductory cruises. The ship's focus on fun and relaxation translates well to itineraries where the journey itself, coupled with accessible port calls, is the main attraction, rather than extended, exotic voyages. Guests can anticipate a pleasant and convenient cruising experience to well-loved locales.
Carnival Tropicale
Specific itineraries for Carnival Tropicale are not yet announced, but as a new Excel-class mega-ship launching in 2028, it will likely be deployed on varied and perhaps longer itineraries that showcase its extensive new features. Its LNG power and significant capacity suggest it will operate on popular routes, potentially including longer Caribbean or European voyages, allowing ample time for guests to explore its innovative attractions like Sunsation Point and the new music venues. This ship is designed to be a destination in itself, making it suitable for itineraries that maximize sea days and onboard exploration.
What reviewers say
Carnival Elation
4/5Carnival Elation, though an older Fantasy-class ship, offers a charming, uncrowded experience with a strong focus on family fun and value. Its recent upgrades and dedicated crew ensure a good time for those seeking a classic cruise without the mega-ship scale.
Carnival Tropicale
Carnival Tropicale is an upcoming Excel-class ship, slated for a 2028 launch, promising significant innovations and a strong family focus. This preview highlights its new top-deck attractions and enhanced cabin configurations designed to cater to a broad audience.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Elation
Carnival Tropicale
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B

