Ship Comparison
Carnival Spirit vs Carnival Sunshine
For a classic Carnival experience with a touch of Australian charm, choose Spirit; for a sun-drenched, thoroughly modernized fun-ship, Sunshine is your vibrant escape.
The verdict
Carnival Spirit offers a well-loved, value-driven cruise experience, particularly appealing to Australian cruisers with its eclectic charm and exceptionally friendly crew. Its entertainment and dining are solid, but its decor is quite varied. Carnival Sunshine, on the other hand, stands as a testament to a significant transformation, providing a more contemporary and polished 'fun-ship' experience. It boasts an expanded adults-only retreat and a more modern design, making it a strong contender for social and family-adventure seekers who appreciate updated amenities and diverse dining options.
Choose Carnival Spirit if…
Travelers seeking a laid-back, friendly, and value-conscious cruise with a lively atmosphere and a strong emphasis on attentive crew service, particularly appealing to families and couples who enjoy diverse dining and entertainment without a rigid structure.
Best for
- Value-Conscious Cruisers
- Family Fun-Seekers
- Foodie Adventurers
- Social Explorers & Party People
- Relaxed Adults & Couples
Avoid if
- Seeking ultra-modern, understated decor
- Strictly adhering to a tight budget for spa treatments
- Requiring explicitly marked vegetarian options in the main dining room
Choose Carnival Sunshine if…
Cruisers looking for a highly social and entertainment-focused vacation on a modernized ship, ideal for families and adults who appreciate extensive outdoor activities, a wide array of dining choices, and a more contemporary design aesthetic.
Best for
- The Social Fun-Seeker
- The Family Adventure Crew
- The Value-Conscious Gourmand
- The Relaxed Adult Escapist
- The Entertainment Enthusiast
Avoid if
- Seeking Broadway-style theatrical productions
- Prioritizing intimate, crowd-free adults-only areas at all times
- Expecting consistent gourmet quality across all complimentary dining options
Overall Vibe
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit, launched in 2001 and last refurbished in 2015, carries 2,124 passengers and 930 crew across its decks, embodying a 'Spirit-class' charm. While its decor is described as a 'hodgepodge of styles,' it fosters a distinctly laid-back, fun, and friendly atmosphere. The ship's personality shines through its five-star crew and features like the Green Thunder water slide and the tranquil Serenity adults-only retreat, creating a top-value holiday for all ages. It feels like a familiar, welcoming friend, emphasizing enjoyment over formality.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine, a result of a $155 million transformation from the former Carnival Destiny, presents a revitalized and modern 'fun-ship.' With a capacity for 3,006 passengers and 1,040 crew, it leans into an unpretentious, highly social, and entertainment-focused experience. The ship's design moved from its original garishness to a more understated elegance, offering updated amenities that cater to a price-conscious crowd. Its standout features include a triple-deck Serenity area and an enhanced WaterWorks, promising a vibrant and contemporary vacation.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Spirit
The Carnival Spirit cultivates a wonderfully laid-back, fun, and genuinely friendly atmosphere. It attracts a diverse mix of families, couples, and singles, all united by a 'let's have fun' spirit. With 2,124 passengers and a substantial crew of 930, the ship maintains a good guest-to-crew ratio, contributing to the exceedingly friendly and attentive service noted by many. This creates a comfortable, communal feeling where everyone feels included, making it easy to relax and enjoy the journey without pretense.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine is characterized by an unpretentious, highly social, and price-conscious atmosphere, driven by a 'relentless emphasis on fun.' Accommodating 3,006 passengers with a crew of 1,040, it's a larger vessel geared towards organized fun and social interaction. While it can feel bustling, the ship's updated amenities and design aim to create a cohesive experience where guests are encouraged to engage. It’s a place where the energy is high, and fellow cruisers are often eager to participate in the lively onboard activities.
Dining
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit offers a broad culinary journey, from complimentary options like Guy's Burger Joint and the fresh offerings at BlueIguana Cantina to the more refined Nouveau Steakhouse. The Empire Restaurant provides a classic three-course experience with lively waitstaff performances, while the Lido Marketplace is a casual, variety-packed buffet. For a special treat, the Chef's Table delivers a molecular gastronomy experience, and Seafood Corner sources fresh local catches. Guests appreciate the inclusion of Australian power points, even in dining areas, for convenience.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine presents an extensive and diverse dining landscape, featuring many popular Carnival staples. Complimentary options include Guy's Burger Joint for poolside burgers, BlueIguana Cantina for fresh Mexican, and the 24-hour Pizzeria del Capitano. Specialty dining like Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse offers a sophisticated evening, while JiJi Asian Kitchen and Cucina del Capitano provide unique international flavors. The Havana Bar even offers Cuban specialties for breakfast and lunch, ensuring a wide array of choices for every palate throughout the day.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Spirit
Nightlife on Carnival Spirit is vibrant and varied, catering to diverse tastes. Pharaoh's Palace hosts Vegas-style revues and Playlist Productions, while the Punchliner Comedy Club offers adult-only shows later in the evening. For more interactive fun, guests can enjoy karaoke in the Shanghai Piano Bar or pub quizzes in the RedFrog Pub, which also features live music. The Dancin' Nightclub keeps the party going late, and the sophisticated Alchemy Bar provides a quieter spot for cocktail connoisseurs, ensuring options from lively to relaxed.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine shines with its entertainment, offering high-energy Playlist Productions like 'Epic Rock' with ultra-HD graphics. The Limelight Lounge doubles as the Punchliner Comedy Club for nightly laughs, and 'Hasbro, the Game Show' provides interactive fun for all ages. Bars like the RedFrog Pub, BlueIguana Tequila Bar, and the classic Havana Bar (which transforms into a lively Latin nightspot) offer diverse atmospheres for evening enjoyment. The ship’s casino and The Warehouse arcade also provide additional options for gaming and social engagement.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit features 1,062 cabins, with nearly 75% being outside cabins, and 80% of those boasting balconies. The decor across all cabins is appealing with earth tones, offering twin beds convertible to a king, flat-screen TVs, and ample storage. Suites, including Junior, Ocean, Vista, and Grand, provide even more space, large balconies, and enhanced amenities like whirlpool tubs in many Ocean Suites. Grand Suites, located aft on decks 7 and 8, offer direct wake views, while Vista Suites feature wraparound balconies for panoramic vistas.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine's cabins are generally well-sized with good storage, though some decor may appear a bit dated. All cabins include twin beds convertible to a king, couches with inset drawers, and functional bathrooms. The ship offers a wide range of suites, from Ocean Suites with separate sitting areas and two TVs to the expansive Captain's Suites at the ship's front, which are entirely glass-fronted and can accommodate up to five guests. Cloud 9 Spa cabins and suites further enhance the experience with green accents, Elemis toiletries, and thermal suite access.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit is renowned for its 'five-star crew,' who are consistently described as exceedingly friendly and attentive. This dedication to guest experience is a major draw, creating a welcoming and personalized atmosphere despite the ship's mass-market class. The onboard style, while a 'hodgepodge of styles' in decor, is consistently focused on fostering a fun and easygoing environment. The crew's ability to make every guest feel valued contributes significantly to the ship's overall positive and memorable impression.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine, after its extensive transformation, showcases a triumph of updated style over its original design, moving towards a more muted and understated elegance. The service is characterized by an organized fun approach, with staff like the casino hosts and youth counselors ensuring engaging experiences. While not explicitly detailed as 'five-star' across the board like Spirit, the overall emphasis on updated amenities and efficient operations aims to deliver a seamless and enjoyable vacation for its social and value-conscious demographic.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit is a favorite among Australian cruisers, suggesting its itineraries often cater to this market, likely including voyages within Australia, to New Zealand, or the South Pacific. Its features like the domed swimming pool, Green Thunder water slide, and family-friendly programs make it suitable for destinations where both warm weather outdoor activities and sheltered indoor options are appreciated. The ship's inclusive nature and diverse dining support longer voyages, allowing guests to fully immerse themselves in the onboard experience between port calls.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine's design, with its extensive outdoor deck spaces, triple-deck Serenity area, and comprehensive WaterWorks, is ideally suited for warm-weather itineraries. This suggests cruises to destinations like the Caribbean, Bahamas, or other sunny regions where passengers can fully enjoy the ship's outdoor amenities. The emphasis on social fun and diverse dining options also makes it a strong choice for cruises that appeal to a broad demographic looking for an active and engaging vacation experience under the sun.
What reviewers say
Carnival Spirit
4.5/5Carnival Spirit offers a top-value holiday for all ages, delivering fun activities, good food, and exceptional service. Despite its eclectic decor, the ship provides a laid-back, friendly atmosphere that keeps passengers returning.
Carnival Sunshine
4/5Carnival Sunshine, a result of a $155 million transformation from the former Carnival Destiny, showcases a quiet revolution in design, moving from garish to understated elegance. It successfully caters to Carnival's core demographic of social, fun-loving, and value-conscious cruisers, offering a blend of updated amenities and a persistent emphasis on onboard enjoyment.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Sunshine
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Carnival Spirit: A Fun-Filled Cruise for All Ages
Enjoy a top-value holiday aboard Carnival Spirit with activities, good food, and exceptional service for everyone.

Ship Guide
Carnival Sunshine: A Transformed Ship with New Elegance
Experience a quiet revolution in design with updated amenities for a social and fun cruise.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B