Ship Comparison
Carnival Spirit vs Carnival Sunshine
For cruisers seeking a vibrant, fun-filled escape, Carnival Spirit offers a laid-back Australian favorite, while Carnival Sunshine shines with its extensive, transformed amenities.
The verdict
Carnival Spirit stands out as a genuine crowd-pleaser, particularly for the Australian market, blending a welcoming, unpretentious atmosphere with a wide array of activities and dining that appeals to all ages. Its crew is consistently praised for being exceptionally friendly and attentive, ensuring a personalized experience despite its "hodgepodge of styles" decor. Carnival Sunshine, on the other hand, represents a significant evolution, having undergone a substantial $155 million transformation. This renewal has imbued it with a more understated elegance and an impressive suite of updated features, from diverse dining to expanded adult-only retreats. Both ships deliver on Carnival's promise of fun and value, but Sunshine offers a slightly more modern and extensive experience, while Spirit charms with its consistent warmth and established character.
Choose Carnival Spirit if…
Carnival Spirit is ideal for families, couples, and singles who appreciate a relaxed, friendly atmosphere and excellent value. It particularly resonates with Australian cruisers seeking abundant activities, diverse dining, and a highly attentive crew, making for an enjoyable and unpretentious holiday.
Best for
- Families seeking a wide range of activities for all ages, including water slides and kids' clubs.
- Value-conscious cruisers looking for a comprehensive holiday with many complimentary dining options.
- Guests who appreciate exceptionally friendly and attentive crew service.
- Australian cruisers desiring a ship with local touches and a laid-back atmosphere.
Avoid if
- Those sensitive to eclectic or "hodgepodge" interior decor styles.
- Travelers seeking an extremely quiet or consistently intimate cruise experience, especially in popular adult-only areas.
- Cruisers looking for extensive, cutting-edge technology or highly modern cabin designs.
Choose Carnival Sunshine if…
Carnival Sunshine is perfect for social, fun-loving, and value-conscious cruisers who desire a modernized ship with extensive amenities. Its post-transformation design and wide range of dining and entertainment options cater to those looking for an energetic yet comfortable cruise experience.
Best for
- Social and energetic cruisers who enjoy a lively, fun-focused atmosphere with many bars and entertainment options.
- Families and teens seeking a wide array of activities, including a ropes course, extensive water park, and dedicated teen clubs.
- Guests who prefer a recently transformed ship with a more modern and understated design aesthetic.
- Food enthusiasts looking for a broad selection of both complimentary and specialty dining venues.
Avoid if
- Passengers desiring a very intimate, small-ship feel, as Sunshine accommodates over 3,000 guests.
- Those who prefer traditional Broadway-style shows over modern, high-tech Playlist Productions.
- Cruisers who might find the main Lido Deck pool too crowded during peak times.
Overall Vibe
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit, launched in 2001 and refurbished in 2015, carries 2,124 guests across 12 decks, offering a distinctly laid-back and friendly atmosphere. While its decor is described as an eclectic "hodgepodge of styles," this only adds to its unpretentious charm. It's truly a top-value holiday, consistently delivering enjoyment for all ages, with its warm spirit often cited as its defining characteristic. The ship feels like a familiar, welcoming friend, prioritizing fun and guest satisfaction over strict formality, fostering a genuinely relaxed experience.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine, originally built in 1996 and undergoing a comprehensive $155 million transformation, now accommodates 3,002 passengers across 14 decks. This extensive refurbishment brought about a "quiet revolution in design," moving towards a more understated elegance from its previous garish aesthetic. The ship emphasizes "organized fun" with updated amenities and a relentless focus on enjoyment, presenting a more modern and expansive environment. It appeals to those seeking a contemporary, social cruise experience with a touch of updated sophistication.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Spirit
The atmosphere on Carnival Spirit is notably laid-back, fun, and friendly, attracting a healthy mix of families, couples, and singles. With 2,124 guests and a dedicated crew of 930, there's a comfortable crew-to-guest ratio that contributes to the ship's personalized and attentive service. The crowd here is definitely a "let's have fun" group, making for a lively but not overwhelming environment. You'll find a genuine sense of camaraderie, where fellow passengers and crew alike contribute to a welcoming and engaging cruise.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine cultivates an unpretentious and highly social atmosphere, catering to 3,002 passengers with a crew of 1,040. This larger scale, coupled with a relentless emphasis on "organized fun," means the ship buzzes with activity and interaction. Guests are typically price-conscious and eager to socialize, making for an energetic and vibrant onboard community. While larger than Spirit, Sunshine effectively manages its crowd through diverse activity zones, ensuring there's always a lively spot to join the fun or a quieter corner to observe the bustling scene.
Dining
Carnival Spirit
Dining on Carnival Spirit offers a blend of traditional and casual options. The complimentary Empire Restaurant provides three-course meals with lively waiter entertainment, alongside the expansive Lido Marketplace buffet, open 24 hours for pizza and ice cream. For casual bites, Guy's Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina, and Fat Jimmy's C-Side BBQ are popular choices. Specialty options include the Nouveau Restaurant for a steakhouse experience at AU$45, Bonsai Sushi 2 for fresh Japanese fare, and the highly recommended Chef's Table, a molecular gastronomy experience for AU$90.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine presents an even broader culinary landscape. Complimentary choices abound, from the main Sunrise and Sunset Dining Rooms with their traditional service and waitstaff performances, to the bustling Lido Marketplace, 24-hour Pizzeria del Capitano, Guy's Burger Joint, and BlueIguana Cantina. Unique complimentary lunch options include Mongolian Wok and The Pasta Bar. For an elevated experience, Fahrenheit 555 steakhouse, JiJi Asian Kitchen, and Cucina del Capitano offer diverse flavors for a fee, while The Chef's Table provides an intimate, curated dining journey for $95.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit lights up the evenings with varied entertainment. The Pharaoh's Palace hosts Vegas-style revues and Playlist Productions featuring 70s/80s hits. For laughs, The Punchliner Comedy Club offers both family-friendly and 18+ shows. Guests can enjoy sing-alongs at the Shanghai Piano Bar, craft cocktails at the Alchemy Bar, or dance the night away in the Dancin' Nightclub. Daytime brings Dive-In Movies on the big screen, trivia, and casino action at Louis XIV, ensuring continuous engagement.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine boasts a dynamic entertainment lineup following its transformation. Playlist Productions stages high-energy shows like "Epic Rock" with ultra-HD graphics. Interactive fun comes alive with "Hasbro, the Game Show." For nightlife, the Havana Bar transforms into a vibrant Cuban hotspot with Latin music and dancing, complementing the Piano Bar's sing-alongs and the Limelight Lounge, which doubles as The Punchliner Comedy Club. The Casino and Skybox Sports Bar offer further options, while the Alchemy Bar creates personalized drink concoctions for cocktail enthusiasts.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit offers 1,062 cabins, with nearly 75% being outside cabins, and 80% of those featuring balconies. Standard cabins are attractively decorated in earth tones, equipped with Australian power points, and offer ample storage. Suites, including Junior, Ocean, Vista, and Grand categories, provide enhanced space, VIP check-in, and larger balconies. Vista Suites feature unique wraparound balconies for panoramic views, while Grand Suites offer direct wake views from their aft positions, catering to those desiring a more expansive private retreat.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine provides generally well-sized cabins, though some decor may appear a bit dated post-transformation. Cabins are functional with ample storage and a mix of U.S. and Euro-style power outlets. The ship features a range of suites, from Ocean Suites with separate sitting areas to the expansive Captain's Suites, which are glass-fronted and include two bathrooms. Unique Cloud 9 Spa Cabins offer special green accents, Elemis toiletries, and exclusive spa access and perks, appealing to guests prioritizing wellness during their voyage.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Spirit
The service on Carnival Spirit is a significant highlight, with its 930-person crew consistently lauded as "five-star" and "exceedingly friendly and attentive." This personal touch truly elevates the cruise experience, making guests feel welcomed and cared for. While the ship's decor is a charming "hodgepodge of styles," the warm and genuine service creates an unpretentious and comfortable onboard atmosphere. The crew's dedication ensures that every interaction contributes positively to the relaxed and fun-loving vibe.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine's onboard style reflects its extensive $155 million transformation, showcasing a "quiet revolution in design" that moved from garish to "understated elegance." This refined aesthetic provides a more modern backdrop for its 3,002 guests and 1,040 crew. The service, while efficient and attentive, operates within a larger and more organized framework, supporting the ship's relentless emphasis on fun and updated amenities. The overall style is cohesive and contemporary, offering a refreshed environment that enhances the social and energetic cruise experience.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Spirit is celebrated as a "favorite among Australian cruisers," indicating its primary deployment in the Australian market. Its cabins are even equipped with Australian power points, a thoughtful touch for its regional clientele. While specific itineraries aren't detailed, its design and amenities are well-suited for voyages exploring the diverse and beautiful regions accessible from Australian ports, offering a tailored experience for this segment of travelers.
Carnival Sunshine
Carnival Sunshine primarily operates in North American markets, with mentions of "Texas and New York" in relation to its "Drinks On Us!" program. This suggests a focus on Caribbean, Bahamian, or other regional itineraries departing from U.S. homeports. Its extensive amenities, particularly the outdoor recreation and dining, are well-suited for warm-weather destinations, providing a sun-soaked experience for its North American guests.
What reviewers say
Carnival Spirit
4.5/5Carnival Spirit offers a top-value holiday for all ages, delivering fun activities, good food, and exceptional service. Despite its eclectic decor, the ship provides a laid-back, friendly atmosphere that keeps passengers returning.
Carnival Sunshine
4/5Carnival Sunshine, a result of a $155 million transformation from the former Carnival Destiny, showcases a quiet revolution in design, moving from garish to understated elegance. It successfully caters to Carnival's core demographic of social, fun-loving, and value-conscious cruisers, offering a blend of updated amenities and a persistent emphasis on onboard enjoyment.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Spirit
Carnival Sunshine
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Carnival Spirit: A Fun-Filled Cruise for All Ages
Enjoy a top-value holiday aboard Carnival Spirit with activities, good food, and exceptional service for everyone.

Ship Guide
Carnival Sunshine: A Transformed Ship with New Elegance
Experience a quiet revolution in design with updated amenities for a social and fun cruise.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B