Ship Comparison
Carnival Elation vs Carnival Mardi Gras
The Carnival Elation offers a charming, classic cruise experience, while the Carnival Mardi Gras delivers a high-energy, innovative mega-ship adventure with a roller coaster at sea.
The verdict
Choosing between Carnival Elation and Carnival Mardi Gras really boils down to your cruising style. Elation, a smaller, more intimate vessel, is perfect for those who appreciate a traditional, uncrowded atmosphere with a focus on familiar fun and value. It's a ship where you can easily find your way around and enjoy a relaxed pace. Mardi Gras, on the other hand, is a modern marvel, a true mega-ship packed with groundbreaking attractions and diverse themed zones. It's built for those seeking constant excitement, a wide array of dining choices, and a bustling, high-energy environment. Both ships offer that signature Carnival 'Fun Ship' spirit, but they deliver it on very different scales.
Choose Carnival Elation if…
The Carnival Elation is ideal for families seeking an affordable and straightforward cruise, couples looking for a relaxed getaway without the mega-ship crowds, or nostalgic cruisers who appreciate a classic, easy-to-navigate ship with a friendly crew.
Best for
- Families seeking an affordable and fun cruise experience
- Couples looking for a relaxed, less crowded atmosphere
- Cruisers who appreciate traditional ship layouts and a classic vibe
- Travelers prioritizing value and a friendly, attentive crew
- Those who enjoy familiar dining options like Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina
Avoid if
- You prefer the latest high-tech attractions and modern amenities
- You seek extensive specialty dining options and celebrity chef venues
- You dislike dated decor and a more traditional cruise ship aesthetic
- You require premium Wi-Fi for streaming and video calls
- You're looking for a very quiet, exclusive, luxury experience
Choose Carnival Mardi Gras if…
The Carnival Mardi Gras caters to thrill-seekers and party animals eager for unique attractions like a roller coaster at sea, foodies craving diverse culinary experiences from celebrity chefs, and families who desire a vast array of activities and entertainment options.
Best for
- Thrill-seekers eager to experience the first roller coaster at sea (BOLT)
- Foodies who want diverse dining, including celebrity chef restaurants
- Families and groups seeking a vast array of activities and entertainment options
- Travelers who appreciate modern ship design and high-tech amenities
- Guests desiring exclusive perks and amenities in suite categories like Excel or Havana
Avoid if
- You prefer smaller, more intimate ships with fewer crowds
- You seek a very quiet and tranquil cruise experience, especially on sea days
- You are on a strict budget, as specialty dining and some activities incur extra costs
- You dislike large, bustling environments and prefer easy navigation
- You prioritize extensive privacy in balcony cabins, especially mid-front on lower decks
Overall Vibe
Carnival Elation
The Carnival Elation, launched in 1998 and last refurbished in 2017, embodies a classic Fantasy-class charm. With its 15 decks, it feels more intimate and less overwhelming than larger vessels, offering a comfortable and often uncrowded experience. The ambiance leans towards lively and casual, with a distinct retro appeal in its decor. It's a ship that invites guests to relax or engage in familiar cruise activities at their own pace, providing a solid value for those who appreciate a traditional cruising style without the constant rush of newer, larger ships.
Carnival Mardi Gras
The Carnival Mardi Gras, launched in 2021, is a groundbreaking mega-ship that redefines the Carnival experience. Spanning 19 decks, it's a floating city designed for maximum impact, introducing six themed 'zones' that create distinct environments onboard. The ship's atmosphere is high-energy, vibrant, and innovative, powered by liquified natural gas (LNG), a modern touch. It blends Carnival's signature fun with a touch of contemporary sophistication, offering a dynamic and bustling environment for guests eager to explore a vast array of new and exciting features.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Elation
With a passenger capacity of 2,130 and a crew of 920, the Carnival Elation maintains a more intimate and less bustling atmosphere. Guests often note the ship feels uncrowded, allowing for easier navigation and a relaxed pace. The vibe is consistently family-friendly and casual, fostering a sense of community among passengers and crew. While there's plenty of activity, finding a quiet corner is generally simple, making it suitable for those who prefer a laid-back vacation experience where getting to know your surroundings is part of the charm.
Carnival Mardi Gras
The Carnival Mardi Gras hosts a substantial 5,282 passengers with a crew of 1,750, creating a lively and energetic atmosphere. The ship is designed to handle this crowd through its innovative 'zones,' which help distribute guests across various entertainment and dining areas. You'll find a bustling, high-energy environment, particularly around popular attractions and the Lido Deck. Despite its size, the ship aims for a fun, affordable, and sophisticated feel, though popular venues can certainly get busy, reflecting its appeal to a broad demographic seeking constant engagement.
Dining
Carnival Elation
Dining on Carnival Elation offers a comforting selection of included favorites. Guests can enjoy traditional main dining at Inspiration Restaurant with assigned seating or Imagination Restaurant for flexible 'Your Time Dining,' both featuring rotating menus and lively waiter entertainment. Casual options abound at Tiffany's Lido Buffet, Guy's Burger Joint, and BlueIguana Cantina for poolside bites, plus 24-hour Pizza Pirate. For a special treat, the Chef's Table offers an exclusive multi-course experience for an additional charge, while Bonsai Sushi Express provides a la carte sushi options.
Carnival Mardi Gras
Carnival Mardi Gras boasts an impressive and diverse culinary landscape, with many venues thoughtfully integrated into its themed zones. Complimentary options include the main Palm and Flamingo dining rooms, the extensive Lido Marketplace Buffet, Guy's Burgers, BlueIguana Cantina, Big Chicken, and innovative Street Eats food truck-style stations. Specialty dining, available for an additional charge, includes celebrity chef Emeril's Bistro 1396, Guy's Pig & Anchor Smokehouse | Brewhouse, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, and Rudi’s Seagrill, offering a wide spectrum of flavors from French Creole to upscale seafood and Japanese Teppanyaki.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Elation
Entertainment on Carnival Elation focuses on classic cruise fun. The Punchliner Comedy Club offers both family-friendly and adult-only shows, while Playlist Productions stages engaging musical revues. Live music can be found across various lounges, including Duke’s Piano Bar and the Atrium, which also hosts daily events. For active fun, there's the WaterWorks water park with its Twister Waterslide and racing slides, plus mini-golf and outdoor games. The Casablanca Casino provides gaming excitement, and the RedFrog Rum Bar and BlueIguana Tequila Bar keep the poolside party going.
Carnival Mardi Gras
Carnival Mardi Gras elevates entertainment with groundbreaking attractions. Dominating The Ultimate Playground is BOLT, the first roller coaster at sea, alongside an expansive WaterWorks water park and SportSquare with a ropes course and mini-golf. The Grand Central atrium transforms into a dynamic entertainment hub by night, complementing production shows in the Mardi Gras Theater. Nightlife is diverse with themed bars like The Brass Magnolia for jazz, Fortune Teller for mystical cocktails, and the lively Havana Bar. Family Feud Live brings a popular game show to sea, ensuring varied fun for all ages.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Elation
Cabins on Carnival Elation are generally spacious and comfortable, designed with practicality in mind. Standard interior and ocean view staterooms measure 185 sq ft, accommodating up to five guests, with porthole options also available. Balcony staterooms offer 220 total sq ft, including a 35 sq ft private outdoor space. Suites, such as the Grand Vista Suite and Grand Suite, provide more room and include perks like priority check-in and boarding, pillow-top mattresses, and bathrobes. Guests should note that some cabins on Empress and Promenade decks may experience noise from public areas.
Carnival Mardi Gras
Carnival Mardi Gras offers a modern array of accommodations, from interior rooms to expansive Carnival Excel Presidential Suites. All cabins feature thoughtful details like USB ports by the bed, ample storage, and upgraded bathrooms with glass shower doors. Unique categories include Havana staterooms with exclusive access to the Havana Pool area (ages 12+), Cloud 9 Spa staterooms with spa perks, and Family Harbor rooms with access to a dedicated lounge. The new Excel suites boast generous living spaces and large wraparound balconies, with some featuring private hot tubs and dedicated concierge service, enhancing the luxury experience.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Elation
Carnival Elation's service style is rooted in its classic cruise charm, characterized by a friendly and attentive crew. Guests can expect a dedicated stateroom attendant for all cabin categories, ensuring personalized care throughout their voyage. While specific concierge services are primarily reserved for suite guests (offering priority check-in and dining assignments), the overall ethos is one of approachable and efficient service, focusing on delivering a consistent, enjoyable experience in a relaxed, less formal environment. The ship's smaller size often allows for more personal interactions.
Carnival Mardi Gras
On Carnival Mardi Gras, service is designed to match the ship's innovative and upscale features, though maintaining Carnival's fun-loving spirit. Guests in Excel suites benefit from a dedicated concierge phone line, priority cabana reservations at Loft 19, and guaranteed dining reservations. All suite guests receive priority boarding and debarkation. The crew is adept at managing the ship's high passenger volume while striving for attentive service. The Carnival Hub app is central to personalized service, enabling easy activity planning and ordering, reflecting a modern, convenience-focused onboard style.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Elation
The Carnival Elation is well-suited for shorter, value-focused cruises, typically exploring popular Caribbean or Mexican ports. Its size makes it agile for various routes, often appealing to first-time cruisers or those seeking a quick, fun getaway without an extensive itinerary. The focus is more on the onboard experience and the joy of being at sea rather than deeply immersive destination exploration. Its proven track record and classic amenities make it a reliable choice for a straightforward, enjoyable cruise vacation.
Carnival Mardi Gras
The Carnival Mardi Gras is designed for destination-rich itineraries, particularly those featuring Carnival's exclusive private destinations like Celebration Key in the Bahamas or the pristine Half Moon Cay. These cruises leverage the ship's extensive onboard attractions and diverse dining, providing a full resort-at-sea experience complemented by unique shore excursions. Given its size and innovative features, Mardi Gras is ideal for longer cruises to the Caribbean, offering a blend of exciting port calls and a wide range of onboard activities that cater to every member of the family.
What reviewers say
Carnival Elation
4/5Carnival Elation, though an older Fantasy-class ship, offers a charming, uncrowded experience with a strong focus on family fun and value. Its recent upgrades and dedicated crew ensure a good time for those seeking a classic cruise without the mega-ship scale.
Carnival Mardi Gras
5/5If you give a cruise ship the name Mardi Gras, you're setting expectations that everyone onboard is going to have a good time -- and Carnival's newest ship delivers just that. With its own roller coaster and a stunning Atrium, the ship packs a punch with lots of free dining and entertainment options.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Elation
Carnival Mardi Gras
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Carnival Elation: Classic Fun, Great Value for Families
Enjoy an uncrowded, family-friendly cruise experience with dedicated crew and recent enhancements.

Ship Guide
Carnival Mardi Gras: A New Era of Fun at Sea
Discover this innovative ship with its thrilling roller coaster, stunning Atrium, and diverse dining.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B