Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Magic

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Magic

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Carnival Horizon vs Carnival Magic

    The Carnival Horizon elevates the 'Fun Ship' experience with modern flair and diverse venues, while the Carnival Magic offers a beloved classic Carnival journey, rich in entertainment and family appeal.

    The verdict

    Choosing between Carnival Horizon and Carnival Magic comes down to your preference for a refreshed, modern experience versus a cherished classic. The Horizon, a newer vessel launched in 2018, offers a slightly more sophisticated yet still vibrant atmosphere, with unique amenities like an IMAX theater and the exclusive Havana spaces. Its dining scene is particularly diverse, featuring Bonsai Teppanyaki and JiJi Asian Kitchen. The Magic, from 2011, embodies the traditional 'Fun Ship' spirit, excelling in its outdoor SportSquare with the first ropes course at sea and a beloved RedFrog Pub. While both are excellent choices for families, the Horizon might appeal to those seeking a contemporary edge, while the Magic continues to deliver reliable, high-energy fun.

    Choose Carnival Horizon if…

    Travelers seeking a modern, family-friendly cruise with a wide variety of dining and entertainment options, including unique attractions like an onboard IMAX theater and a pedal-powered SkyRide. Ideal for those who appreciate a blend of lively activities and more refined spaces like the Havana areas.

    Best for

    • Families seeking modern amenities and diverse activities
    • Couples looking for a mix of lively entertainment and relaxing adult-only spaces
    • Foodies interested in a wide array of specialty dining options, including Asian and Teppanyaki
    • Guests who enjoy unique onboard attractions like an IMAX theater and SkyRide

    Avoid if

    • You prefer a truly quiet and intimate cruise experience
    • You are sensitive to crowds, especially at peak times
    • You dislike paying extra for specialty dining and premium entertainment

    Choose Carnival Magic if…

    Families and groups who love the classic 'Fun Ship' atmosphere, prioritizing robust outdoor activities like the SkyCourse ropes course and a strong emphasis on complimentary, casual dining. Perfect for those who enjoy a bustling, high-energy environment with plenty of options for all ages.

    Best for

    • Families with children and teens who love active outdoor fun
    • Guests who enjoy a classic, high-energy 'Fun Ship' atmosphere
    • Value-conscious travelers who appreciate many complimentary dining options
    • Those seeking extensive sports and recreation facilities, including a ropes course at sea

    Avoid if

    • You prefer a very quiet and uncrowded cruise experience
    • You are sensitive to smoke, as it's permitted in some casino and nightclub areas
    • You dislike waiting in lines for popular dining venues and activities

    Overall Vibe

    Carnival Horizon

    The Carnival Horizon, launched in 2018, presents a bold and sophisticated take on the 'Fun Ship' concept. As a large vessel, it successfully blends modern design with Carnival's signature vibrant energy across its many decks. The ship feels contemporary and offers a diverse range of experiences, from the high-tech IMAX theater to the serene adults-only retreat. It’s designed to provide a comprehensive, fun-filled vacation that appeals to a wide demographic, making excellent use of its space to offer both excitement and pockets of calm.

    Carnival Magic

    The Carnival Magic, introduced in 2011, offers a classic 'Fun Ship' vibe that many guests have come to love. This mega-ship is a bustling, energetic destination in itself, known for pioneering some of Carnival's most popular venues, like the first ropes course at sea. While not the newest, its enduring charm lies in its dedication to offering a wide array of activities and dining that cater to multi-generational groups. The atmosphere is consistently lively, promising a high-energy vacation experience for all aboard.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Carnival Horizon

    With a passenger capacity of 3,960 and a crew of 1,450, the Carnival Horizon maintains a vibrant, energetic atmosphere that balances lively public spaces with quieter retreats. The ship's 'smart elevator concept' aims to manage the flow of guests, though popular areas will still draw crowds. Families will find a bustling, friendly environment with plenty of kids and teens, while adults can seek solace at the Serenity Adult-Only Retreat. The overall feel is modern and inclusive, fostering a social yet accommodating cruise experience.

    Carnival Magic

    The Carnival Magic accommodates 3,690 passengers with a crew of 1,386, creating a bustling, high-energy environment. This ship is particularly popular with families and groups, leading to lively common areas and pools. Guests should anticipate significant crowds and lines, especially at popular dining venues and during peak activity times. Despite the busy nature, the atmosphere remains consistently friendly and geared towards fun, appealing to those who thrive in a social, active setting and enjoy a constant buzz of activity.

    Dining

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon offers a broad and diverse culinary journey. Complimentary options include the main dining rooms (Meridian and Reflections), the expansive Lido Marketplace, Guy's Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina, Pizzeria del Capitano, and even Fresh Creations at Serenity. For a fee, guests can indulge in Bonsai Sushi or the interactive Bonsai Teppanyaki, savor steaks at Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, explore Asian flavors at JiJi Asian Kitchen, or enjoy family-style Italian at Cucina del Capitano. Guy's Pig & Anchor Smokehouse | Brewhouse offers BBQ and craft beers for dinner (complimentary buffet for lunch), adding to a rich gastronomic selection.

    Carnival Magic

    On Carnival Magic, guests will find a robust selection of dining, blending complimentary favorites with enticing specialty venues. The Northern Lights and Southern Lights dining rooms offer classic meals, complemented by the vast Lido Marketplace, Guy's Burger Joint, and BlueIguana Cantina. Unique complimentary options include Mongolian Wok and Tandoor kiosks within the Lido. For an extra charge, Cucina del Capitano provides authentic Italian, while Prime Steakhouse offers an upscale experience. The RedFrog Pub also features an à la carte food menu, and Guy's Pig & Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse serves up delicious BBQ, ensuring a satisfying meal for every palate.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Carnival Horizon

    The Carnival Horizon shines with a wide array of entertainment, from grand Playlist Productions shows in the Liquid Lounge to laugh-out-loud performances at The Punchliner Comedy Club, offering both family-friendly and adult-only sets. Unique attractions include the onboard IMAX theater and the thrilling Thrill Theater. Nightlife is vibrant with live music across various venues, including the Havana Bar with its Latin flair and the Piano Bar 88 for sing-alongs, plus a full casino. Daytime fun features the SkyRide, Dr. Seuss WaterWorks, and the SportSquare complex with its ropes course and mini-golf.

    Carnival Magic

    Carnival Magic delivers classic Carnival entertainment with a focus on interactive fun. The Showtime Theatre hosts Playlist Production Shows, while The Punchliner Comedy Club offers daily laughs. The Hat Trick Casino provides slots and table games, and the Vibe Nightclub keeps the party going late (though smoking is permitted). Signature outdoor attractions like the SportSquare, featuring the first ropes course at sea and mini-golf, along with the WaterWorks aqua park, ensure active daytime enjoyment. Live music fills the Magic Lobby and Play It Again Piano Bar, creating a lively atmosphere for all.

    Cabins & Suites

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon offers a diverse range of 1,980 cabins, including innovative specialty categories. Guests can choose from various Interior, Ocean View (some obstructed or with walkway views), and Balcony staterooms, including Premium and Cove options. The ship also features unique Havana staterooms and suites, offering exclusive access to the Havana Pool area (for guests 12+), and Family Harbor staterooms and suites with access to the Family Harbor Lounge. Cloud 9 Spa staterooms and suites provide priority spa reservations and exclusive amenities, ensuring a personalized stay for every type of cruiser.

    Carnival Magic

    Carnival Magic provides a comfortable and spacious array of cabins designed for various group sizes and preferences. It features 1,845 cabins, including standard Interior, Ocean View (some obstructed or with walkway views), and Balcony options, such as Premium Vista and Aft-View Extended Balconies. The ship is notable for its 'quint' cabins, designed to accommodate up to five guests, making it a great choice for larger families. Cloud 9 Spa staterooms and suites offer enhanced relaxation with priority spa access and thermal suite benefits, providing a tranquil retreat amidst the ship's lively atmosphere.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Carnival Horizon

    The Carnival Horizon maintains Carnival's reputation for friendly and attentive service, with a crew of 1,450 dedicated to enhancing the guest experience. The ship's modern design incorporates features like a 'smart elevator concept' aimed at improving guest flow, and the upgraded Hub App allows for convenient reservations and menu viewing. While the ship is large and can be bustling, the service strives to make each guest feel cared for. The overall style is contemporary and polished, reflecting its newer build.

    Carnival Magic

    Carnival Magic's service is characterized by its welcoming and energetic crew of 1,386, embodying the classic 'Fun Ship' ethos. While guests might encounter crowds and occasional queues at popular spots, the staff generally works to keep the atmosphere upbeat and enjoyable. The Carnival Hub app helps guests navigate activities, though some users report chat delays. The ship's style, while showing its 2011 heritage, is well-maintained and focuses on creating a lively, accessible environment where fun is always a top priority for all onboard.

    Best Itineraries

    Carnival Horizon

    The Carnival Horizon frequently sails to a variety of sun-drenched destinations, with itineraries typically exploring the Caribbean and other exotic locales. Its diverse range of onboard activities and dedicated zones for families, adults, and spa-goers make it well-suited for voyages that include a mix of relaxing sea days and vibrant port calls. Guests looking for a modern ship experience while visiting popular tropical ports will find its offerings particularly appealing.

    Carnival Magic

    Carnival Magic is a versatile ship, often deployed on itineraries across the Caribbean and other popular cruise regions. Its wide appeal to families and groups makes it a great choice for voyages of varying lengths, especially those with several sea days to fully enjoy its extensive onboard amenities. The ship's robust activity lineup and diverse dining options ensure that every day, whether at sea or in port, is filled with opportunities for fun and exploration, catering to guests who enjoy a dynamic cruise experience.

    What reviewers say

    Carnival Horizon

    4/5

    Carnival Horizon is a bold, beautiful ship brimming with activities, dining, and bars, offering a sophisticated yet fun Carnival experience. It's an excellent choice for families seeking a value-packed vacation with endless options for all ages.

    Carnival Magic

    4/5

    Carnival Magic delivers a fun-filled experience for all ages, provided you come prepared for crowds and are willing to adapt your routine. With a bit of patience, you'll create plenty of memorable Fun Ship moments and leave feeling relaxed.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Carnival Horizon

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Carnival Magic

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons