Ship Comparison
Carnival Liberty vs Carnival Radiance
For a lively, established Carnival experience, choose Liberty; for a fresh, amenity-rich mid-size ship with new culinary stars, Radiance shines.
The verdict
Carnival Liberty, launched in 2005 and refreshed in 2011, offers a well-loved, vibrant atmosphere with a strong focus on value and proven crowd-pleasers. It's a ship that reliably delivers on fun with its diverse dining and entertainment. Carnival Radiance, born from a significant 2021 dry dock of the former Carnival Victory, brings a revitalized, modern take on the 'Fun Ship' concept. It blends big-ship features with a more intimate, easy-to-navigate feel, appealing to both new cruisers and seasoned Carnival fans looking for fresh experiences like Shaq's Big Chicken.
Choose Carnival Liberty if…
Travelers seeking a vibrant, established Carnival experience with a wide array of complimentary dining and entertainment, prioritizing value and a lively social atmosphere.
Best for
- Families seeking abundant activities and dining options
- Value-oriented cruisers prioritizing inclusive experiences
- Social and entertainment seekers who enjoy lively venues
- Guests who appreciate consistently friendly and personable service
Avoid if
- Those seeking a very quiet, subdued cruise experience
- Travelers who prefer brand-new ships with the latest innovations
- Guests sensitive to potential crowds at popular spots
- Individuals desiring extremely spacious standard cabin bathrooms
Choose Carnival Radiance if…
Cruisers looking for a recently revitalized ship that offers a modern take on Carnival's 'Fun Ship' concept, blending popular amenities with new culinary experiences in an easy-to-navigate setting.
Best for
- Families looking for modern, diverse onboard activities like water parks and ropes courses
- Food enthusiasts eager to try new, celebrity-backed dining experiences
- Cruisers who appreciate a revitalized ship with contemporary design and amenities
- Guests seeking a balance between big-ship features and an easy-to-navigate environment
Avoid if
- Those extremely sensitive to noise, especially in Cloud 9 Spa rooms on Deck 11
- Travelers who dislike waiting in lines at popular complimentary dining venues
- Guests preferring a truly intimate, small-ship experience
- Individuals expecting a fully comprehensive gym with all muscle-specific machines
Overall Vibe
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Liberty, launched in 2005 and receiving a significant refurbishment in 2011, offers a classic Carnival experience focused on delivering consistent fun and excellent value. Though its exact tonnage isn't specified, it carries 2,974 guests across its decks, creating a lively yet manageable environment. The ship's personality is all about readily available, crowd-pleasing options designed to keep everyone engaged and happy, from diverse dining to varied activities. It embodies a carefree spirit where relaxation and enjoyment are the main priorities, reflecting a well-honed approach to mainstream cruising.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance, originally built in 2000 but essentially reborn after a substantial $200-million dry dock in 2021, presents a fresh, modern ambiance. While accommodating 2,984 passengers, it manages to feel more intimate than some larger vessels, striking a balance between big-ship amenities and mid-size coziness. This extensive transformation infused the ship with Carnival's latest and most popular features, from thrilling water slides to celebrity-backed eateries, creating an 'all hands-on deck' experience that feels both familiar and new. It’s designed for an enjoyable escape that's easy to navigate.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Liberty
With a capacity for 2,974 passengers and supported by a crew of 1,160, Carnival Liberty maintains a vibrant, carefree, and notably family-friendly atmosphere. The ship buzzes with an abundance of activities and dining options, all designed to keep guests happy and engaged, from morning to night. The crew is consistently described as friendly, helpful, and personable, contributing significantly to the ship's welcoming vibe. This creates a social environment where passengers of all ages can find something to enjoy, whether it’s a lively deck party or a quieter moment in a lounge.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance, accommodating 2,984 guests, cultivates a fun-filled and vibrant atmosphere that feels notably easy to navigate despite its capacity. The ship seamlessly blends big-ship amenities with the comfort of a mid-size vessel, appealing to a diverse range of cruisers. While a specific crew count isn't detailed, the overall experience is designed to be engaging and enjoyable for everyone, from families to solo travelers. The atmosphere encourages interaction and participation, making it a good choice for those who appreciate a dynamic yet approachable cruise setting.
Dining
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Liberty offers a delightful array of dining experiences, with many popular complimentary choices. Guests can savor Guy's Burger Joint for poolside burgers, BlueIguana Cantina for fresh Mexican fare, and the extensive Emile's Lido Buffet, which includes Mongolian Wok and Ol' Fashioned BBQ. The Golden and Silver Olympian Dining Rooms provide a more traditional, yet unstuffy, three-course experience. For an additional cost, options like the highly-regarded Diamonds Steakhouse, The Seafood Shack, and the exclusive Chef's Table elevate the culinary journey. There's also 24-hour Pizza Pirate and various cafes like Jardin Cafe for coffee and pastries.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance boasts an impressive selection of dining venues, highlighted by new additions from celebrity partners. Complimentary options include Shaq O'Neal's Big Chicken, Guy's Burger Joint, Blue Iguana Cantina for Mexican favorites, and Guy's Pig & Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. The Lido Marketplace buffet and the main dining rooms (Sunset and Sunrise) offer diverse choices, though popular spots can see long lines. Specialty dining, available for an additional cost, features the Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse with generous portions, Cucina del Capitano for Italian fare, and Bonsai Sushi. The variety ensures a satisfying culinary adventure, from quick casual bites to more refined experiences.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Liberty truly lives up to its 'Fun Ship' moniker with a packed entertainment schedule. The Venetian Palace Main Lounge hosts high-energy Playlist Productions and family-friendly shows. Dive-In Movies on the Lido Deck are a popular evening draw, complete with popcorn. For adult fun, The Punchliner Comedy Club consistently packs them in with both PG and explicit shows, and karaoke at The Stage Bar is a lively affair. The Czar's Palace Casino is a bustling hub nightly, offering slots and table games. Various bars like RedFrog Rum Bar, BlueIguana Tequila Bar, and the Piano Man Bar provide diverse atmospheres for socializing and enjoying live music or a quiet drink.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance offers a dynamic range of entertainment and nightlife options, integrating many of Carnival's beloved features. The Liquid Lounge Main Theater hosts high-tech Playlist Productions, though guests should arrive early due to its capacity. The Punchliner Comedy Club provides nightly laughs with both family-friendly and adult-only shows. For active fun, WaterWorks features thrilling slides like the AquaTunnel and Twister, while SportSquare offers SkyCourse, mini-golf, and basketball. Bars like the sophisticated Alchemy Bar, the lively RedFrog Pub, and Heroes Tribute Bar cater to different moods. The Casino, with its slots and table games, is another popular spot for evening excitement, ensuring there’s never a dull moment.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Liberty provides a range of accommodations, from comfortable interior staterooms to expansive suites. Standard cabins, around 185-220 square feet, feature a slightly dated peach and yellow decor but offer practical amenities like under-bed storage, ample closets, and flat-screen TVs. Bathrooms in non-suite categories have showers with curtains that can splash. Suites, including Junior, Ocean, Grand, and Captain's Suites (up to 750 sq ft), offer more space, upgraded amenities like whirlpool tubs and double sinks, plus VIP perks such as priority boarding and complimentary laundry. Balcony staterooms range from 35 to 75 square feet of outdoor space, offering personal sea views.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance's 2,984 staterooms, including 220 new additions during its refit, showcase a refreshed and bold design with a beachy blue and yellow color scheme. Standard cabins are equipped with modern touches like USB chargers by the bed and warm wood laminate. Bathrooms feature lipped entry showers with vinyl curtains and pump dispensers for toiletries. Suite categories, such as Captain's, Ocean, Grand, and Extended Balcony Grand Suites, boast dark wood accents, warm tones, and often include separate vanity areas and standalone tubs. It's worth noting that Cloud 9 Spa rooms on Deck 11 might experience noise from the Camp Ocean kids club above. All suites come with a range of priority services and enhanced amenities.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Liberty consistently receives high marks for its onboard service, with the crew frequently described as friendly, helpful, and personable. This attentive approach significantly enhances the overall guest experience, contributing to the ship's carefree and welcoming style. The service ethos focuses on ensuring passengers feel well-cared for and engaged, whether at the Guest Services desk, in dining rooms, or during various activities. This dedication to guest satisfaction is a core part of Liberty’s appeal, making every interaction feel genuine and Personalized, reinforcing the ship's reputation for delivering a great vacation value.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance, post-refit, embodies a modern and efficient onboard style, aiming to provide big-ship amenities with mid-size ship comfort. While specific crew comments are less detailed, the ship's design and operational flow contribute to an easy-to-navigate experience. The focus is on integrating Carnival's popular features smoothly, ensuring that guests can effortlessly transition between diverse dining and entertainment options. The overall impression is one of a well-orchestrated environment where everything is within reach, fostering a sense of relaxed enjoyment and a seamless vacation, appealing to a broad spectrum of cruisers seeking convenience and contemporary flair.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Liberty
While specific itineraries are not detailed in the provided information for Carnival Liberty, the ship's vibrant, family-friendly atmosphere and focus on crowd-pleasing activities make it well-suited for shorter, fun-packed cruises, particularly to destinations like the Bahamas. The emphasis on onboard entertainment and diverse dining ensures that the ship itself is a primary draw, complementing any port visits. Guests looking for a vacation where the ship's offerings are central to the experience will find Liberty's approach aligns perfectly with relaxed, value-oriented Caribbean or Bahamian sailings, with ample opportunities for shore excursions.
Carnival Radiance
Carnival Radiance, with its extensive 2021 refurbishment and new amenities, is primed for itineraries that highlight its diverse onboard offerings. Though specific routes aren't provided, its blend of thrilling attractions like WaterWorks and the SkyCourse, coupled with unique dining venues such as Big Chicken, suggests it thrives on shorter, energetic cruises to popular destinations. The ship's modernized facilities and easy-to-navigate layout make it an excellent choice for a wide audience, including families and groups, seeking a destination that offers both relaxation and high-energy fun. It’s well-equipped to make any sailing a memorable, activity-rich journey.
What reviewers say
Carnival Liberty
4.5/5Launched in 2005 and refurbished in 2011, Carnival Liberty makes the most of its $500 million overhaul with crowd-pleasing options at every turn. The carefree atmosphere and abundance of activities make it a great value.
Carnival Radiance
4.5/5Radiance has arrived primed to offer big-ship amenities with the coziness of a mid-size ship, making it a fun, easy-to-navigate, all hands-on deck cruise experience for newbies and veterans alike.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Liberty
Carnival Radiance
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

Ship Guide
Carnival Liberty: Carefree Cruises with Great Value
Enjoy a voyage filled with crowd-pleasing activities and diverse dining options at an excellent price.

Ship Guide
Carnival Radiance: Big Fun with a Mid-Size Feel
Discover diverse dining, thrilling entertainment, and comfortable cabins on Carnival Radiance, perfect for every traveler.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B