Carnival Elation

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Legend

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Legend

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Carnival Elation vs Carnival Legend

    Carnival Elation offers classic charm and value for families, while Carnival Legend provides a slightly larger, recently refreshed experience with more diverse dining and thrilling adventures.

    The verdict

    Choosing between Carnival Elation and Carnival Legend truly depends on your cruising priorities. The Elation, a beloved Fantasy-class ship, shines for those who appreciate a more intimate, value-driven experience with a focus on traditional fun and an exceptionally friendly crew. Its smaller size means easier navigation and a less overwhelming atmosphere, perfect for a relaxed family getaway. On the other hand, Carnival Legend, with its recent refurbishments, offers a slightly more expansive and modern feel, providing a broader range of dining choices and higher-octane thrills like the Green Thunder waterslide. It caters to a similar family-friendly demographic but with a touch more dynamism and flexibility in its offerings. Both ships deliver the signature Carnival 'Fun Ship' experience, but the Elation leans into nostalgic charm, while the Legend offers a refreshed, active adventure.

    Choose Carnival Elation if…

    Carnival Elation is ideal for families seeking an affordable, classic cruise experience with a friendly, unpretentious atmosphere, lively entertainment, and dedicated kids' activities, all within a comfortable, easily navigable ship layout.

    Best for

    • While offering plenty of activities, the Elation also caters to those who prefer a more laid-back vacation. The adults-only Serenity Deck and quiet spots like the Mark Twain Library provide peaceful retreats for unwinding.
    • Cruisers who enjoy a relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere with ample opportunities for socializing, live music, and comedy will find Elation appealing. The ship's various bars and lounges provide diverse settings for evening entertainment.
    • This ship is ideal for families looking for an affordable and fun cruise experience, with plenty of included activities and dining options for all ages. The dedicated kids' clubs and water park make it a strong choice for those traveling with children.
    • Those who appreciate the classic, smaller ship experience, where getting around is easy and the focus is on traditional cruise fun rather than mega-ship amenities, will feel at home on the Elation. The familiar Fantasy-class layout offers a sense of comfort.

    Avoid if

    • Noise from Public Spaces in Certain Cabins
    • Limited Upscale Dining & Shopping
    • Single Main Pool & Potential Crowds
    • Dated Decor & Limited Modern Amenities

    Choose Carnival Legend if…

    Carnival Legend suits active families and social travelers looking for a refreshed, mid-sized ship with diverse dining, thrilling waterslides, vibrant nightlife, and a wide array of global itinerary options.

    Best for

    • This persona appreciates a variety of dining options, from complimentary choices to affordable specialty venues, and enjoys trying new flavors without strict formality. The mix of free and fee-based restaurants, including 'Rare Finds' and 'International Flavors,' caters to this.
    • This persona is drawn to ships that offer diverse and extensive itineraries, allowing them to explore a wide range of global destinations. Carnival Legend's flexibility to handle many different homeports and sail to numerous worldwide locations is a key attraction.
    • This traveler prioritizes relaxation and quiet spaces, seeking adults-only areas, spa treatments, and serene poolside environments to unwind. The Serenity adults-only deck, Cloud 9 Spa, and quieter Camelot pool are ideal.
    • This traveler thrives on lively evenings, diverse live music, comedy, and opportunities to socialize in various bars and lounges. The ship's Playlist Productions, Punchliner Comedy Club, and numerous themed bars provide ample options.
    • This persona seeks active fun and entertainment for all ages, valuing thrilling water slides, engaging kids' programs, and family-friendly shows. Carnival Legend's WaterWorks, Seuss at Sea, and Camp Ocean are perfect fits.

    Avoid if

    • Spicy Surprises & Smaller Portions
    • Homeport Hopping
    • Serenity's Proximity Paradox
    • Late-Night Lull
    • Buffet Rush Hour

    Overall Vibe

    Carnival Elation

    The Carnival Elation, a classic Fantasy-class ship built in 1998 and last refurbished in 2017, exudes a comfortable, uncrowded charm. Its atmosphere blends a touch of 1970s color with some Vegas-style flair, offering a nostalgic yet updated experience. Passengers often describe it as a great value for those seeking traditional cruise fun without the overwhelming scale of newer vessels. While it may not boast the latest technological marvels, Elation focuses on tried-and-true Carnival staples, ensuring a relaxed pace and an easily navigable layout across its 11 accessible decks for a memorable, fun-filled vacation.

    Carnival Legend

    The Carnival Legend, launched in 2002 and extensively refurbished in 2024, presents a well-maintained, active, and engaging onboard experience. With its recent updates, the ship feels modern while retaining a comfortable, mid-sized feel across its 12 decks. The Legend's design pays homage to enduring legends, creating a distinctive ambiance that complements its diverse range of activities and dining options. It strikes a good balance, catering to guests who appreciate both thrilling adventures and sophisticated touches, all within a welcoming, family-friendly environment that is easy to explore.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Carnival Elation

    With a passenger capacity of 2,190 and a dedicated crew of 920, Carnival Elation maintains a lively yet manageable atmosphere. The ship is particularly well-suited for families and those who appreciate a casual, social environment. Guests often highlight the friendly and attentive crew, contributing to a warm, welcoming vibe. While the main pool area and WaterWorks can get quite active, the adults-only Serenity Deck offers a peaceful escape for those seeking quiet relaxation. It’s a ship where interactions feel more personal, fostering a sense of community among guests.

    Carnival Legend

    The Carnival Legend accommodates up to 2,680 passengers with a crew of 930, creating an active and energetic atmosphere. It's designed to be family-friendly, drawing a crowd that enjoys a dynamic cruise experience. Despite its capacity, the ship's layout facilitates easy navigation, preventing a feeling of being overly crowded. The ambiance is generally laid-back, with plenty of opportunities for socializing in various lounges and bars, while also providing dedicated spaces like the Serenity Adult-Only Retreat for quieter moments. The blend of diverse activities and a helpful crew ensures a vibrant and engaging vacation for all.

    Dining

    Carnival Elation

    Dining on Carnival Elation offers a range of complimentary and specialty options. Guests can enjoy traditional three-course meals in the main dining rooms, Inspiration Restaurant (with assigned seating) and Imagination Restaurant (with flexible "Your Time Dining"), both offering breakfast and dinner, plus a popular "Seaday Brunch." Casual bites are abundant at Tiffany's Lido Buffet, 24-hour Pizza Pirate, Guy's Burger Joint for poolside burgers, and BlueIguana Cantina for fresh tacos and burritos. For an elevated experience, The Chef's Table offers an exclusive multi-course dinner, and Bonsai Sushi Express caters to sushi lovers for an additional fee.

    Carnival Legend

    Carnival Legend provides a diverse culinary journey with both included and for-fee venues. The main dining room, Truffles, offers extensive three-course menus for breakfast, lunch on sea days, and dinner, including "Rare Finds" and "International Flavors." The Unicorn Cafe Lido Restaurant serves as the casual buffet, complemented by 24-hour pizza and ice cream. Poolside, Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina are popular for quick, delicious meals. Specialty options include Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse for an elegant dinner, Bonsai Sushi for Japanese fare, and The Chef's Table for an exclusive gourmet experience, all for an extra charge.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Carnival Elation

    Entertainment on Carnival Elation centers on classic cruise fun. The Limelight Lounge hosts the popular Punchliner Comedy Club with both family-friendly and adult-only shows. Playlist Productions delivers vibrant musical performances with singers and dancers. Live music can be found throughout the ship, from the casual RedFrog Rum Bar to the lively Duke’s Piano Bar and the Atrium, which often features a live band or DJ. For those seeking active fun, WaterWorks features the thrilling Twister Waterslide and racing slides, while the Casino offers various table games and slots, along with tournaments for adult guests.

    Carnival Legend

    Carnival Legend offers a dynamic array of entertainment and nightlife. The Follies Theatre is home to energetic Playlist Productions shows and the interactive Hasbro, the Game Show. Laughter fills the Punchliner Comedy Club with diverse acts. For evening festivities, guests can dance the night away at Medusa's Lair Nightclub, enjoy sing-alongs at Billie's Piano Bar, or find live music across various lounges like the RedFrog Pub. Thrill-seekers can brave the Green Thunder waterslide, billed as the fastest at sea, or the Twister waterslide, while the expanded Casino provides ample gaming excitement.

    Cabins & Suites

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Elation's cabins are known for being generally spacious and comfortable, offering ample storage. Standard interior and ocean view staterooms measure 185 sq ft, with some porthole options available. Balcony staterooms provide 220 total sq ft, including a 35 sq ft private outdoor space. Suites, such as the Junior, Grand, Grand Extended Balcony, and Grand Vista Suites, offer significantly more room and come with VIP perks like priority check-in and dedicated bath products. While standard bathrooms are basic with shower curtains, suites feature more luxurious amenities like shower/tub combos, with Junior Suites having showers.

    Carnival Legend

    Carnival Legend features 1,062 staterooms, with a high percentage of outside cabins and private balconies. Standard interior and ocean view cabins both measure 185 sq ft, while balcony staterooms offer 225 total sq ft. Suites, including Junior, Ocean, Vista, and Grand Suites, are particularly well-appointed, offering generous space, walk-in closets, and whirlpool tubs in many categories. Vista Suites boast unique wraparound balconies for panoramic views. All suites come with VIP services, such as priority embarkation and pillow-top mattresses, enhancing the sense of luxury and comfort for guests.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Elation's service is often praised for its friendly and attentive crew, contributing significantly to the ship's welcoming atmosphere. The onboard style reflects its classic Fantasy-class heritage, with a decor that blends 1970s elements and touches of Vegas flair, creating a distinctly retro charm. While not overtly luxurious, the ship prioritizes a fun, casual, and unpretentious experience, making guests feel at ease. Personalized service, particularly for suite guests with priority benefits, ensures a smooth and enjoyable journey. The overall feel is one of comfort and good value, focusing on traditional cruising enjoyment.

    Carnival Legend

    Service on Carnival Legend is characterized by a crew of 930 that supports an active and engaging onboard experience. The ship's style is well-maintained and family-friendly, having benefited from a 2024 refurbishment that keeps its facilities fresh. While the decor embraces a "legends throughout the ages" theme, it maintains a comfortable and accessible feel. Suite guests benefit from priority services like embarkation and disembarkation. The crew's attentiveness ensures a seamless vacation, whether guests are navigating the thrilling waterslides or enjoying a quiet moment in the Cloud 9 Spa. The emphasis is on active fun and guest satisfaction.

    Best Itineraries

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Elation's itineraries are well-suited for those seeking shorter, value-focused cruises, often exploring destinations that align with its classic, fun-filled vibe. While specific routes are not detailed in the provided information, its smaller size and emphasis on a comfortable, uncrowded experience suggest it's ideal for relaxed Caribbean or Mexican Riviera sailings, allowing guests to enjoy its onboard amenities and port calls without extensive travel. The ship’s focus on family-friendly activities makes it a strong contender for vacations where the journey itself is as important as the destination.

    Carnival Legend

    Carnival Legend offers a flexible and diverse range of itineraries, appealing to global itinerary enthusiasts eager for varied destinations. Its ability to handle many different homeports means it can sail to numerous worldwide locations, from the Caribbean to more exotic locales. This ship is an excellent choice for travelers who prioritize exploring a wide array of cultural and scenic landscapes. The recent 2024 refurbishment ensures a comfortable base for these adventures, making it suitable for longer, more destination-intensive cruises where guests can truly immerse themselves in diverse experiences both on and off the ship.

    What reviewers say

    Carnival Elation

    4/5

    Carnival Elation, though an older Fantasy-class ship, offers a charming, uncrowded experience with a strong focus on family fun and value. Its recent upgrades and dedicated crew ensure a good time for those seeking a classic cruise without the mega-ship scale.

    Carnival Legend

    4/5

    Carnival Legend offers an active, family-friendly cruise experience, consistently updated through recent refurbishments. It provides a good balance of fun activities, diverse dining, and comfortable accommodations for a memorable vacation.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Carnival Elation

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Carnival Legend

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons