Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Firenze

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Carnival Horizon vs Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Horizon offers a bold, modern, and fun-filled family adventure, while Carnival Firenze blends classic Carnival fun with an immersive Italian 'la dolce vita' experience.

    The verdict

    Carnival Horizon is a large, modern ship that successfully blends sophistication with Carnival's signature fun, making it particularly well-suited for families with its vast array of activities, diverse dining, and lively entertainment options. Carnival Firenze, while newer, offers a unique Italian-themed 'la dolce vita' experience, successfully delivering on value, vibrant atmosphere, delicious food, and lively nightlife, appealing to those who appreciate a strong cultural personality alongside their cruise fun.

    Choose Carnival Horizon if…

    Carnival Horizon is ideal for families and groups seeking a modern, high-energy cruise with abundant activities, diverse dining, and lively entertainment, all while enjoying well-utilized outdoor spaces and dedicated adult retreats.

    Best for

    • The Culinary Explorer
    • The Social Butterfly & Nightlife Enthusiast
    • The Active Adventurer
    • The Family Fun Seeker

    Avoid if

    • Someone seeking consistent quiet beyond specific adult zones
    • Those who prioritize fast Wi-Fi for work or streaming
    • Passengers sensitive to noise from above/below cabins
    • Guests with very specific mobility needs requiring smooth, uncrowded debarkation

    Choose Carnival Firenze if…

    Carnival Firenze is perfect for guests who appreciate a unique, immersive Italian-themed cruise experience, offering a blend of classic Carnival fun with a distinct cultural flair, lively social scenes, and a focus on culinary exploration, particularly on Mexico's Pacific coast.

    Best for

    • The Value-Conscious Foodie
    • The Social Party Seeker
    • The Family Vacationer
    • The Italian Culture Enthusiast

    Avoid if

    • Those seeking genuinely quiet relaxation in main adult areas
    • Guests sensitive to tighter public spaces and crowds
    • Swimmers who prefer large, uncrowded pools
    • Travelers who dislike 'kitsch' decor

    Overall Vibe

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon, launched in 2018, is a substantial vessel, stretching across 15 decks. It embodies a bold, modern, and sophisticated atmosphere, successfully blending these elements with Carnival's signature fun. As a "big ship" in the fleet, it offers a vibrant and high-energy environment, making excellent use of its outdoor spaces. From the innovative Dreamscape LED funnel in the atrium to the expansive wraparound promenade on Deck 5, the ship feels contemporary and dynamic, designed to cater to a diverse range of preferences while maintaining a lively spirit throughout.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze, a newer megaship built in 2020 and refurbished in 2024 for its "Fun Italian Style" conversion, sails with a distinct Italian theme. Across its 15 decks, it presents an immersive Florentine experience, evident in its baroque Piazza Duomo atrium and artful decor. While embracing a playful "kitsch" side, Firenze still delivers the core Carnival value and vibrant energy. This ship offers a unique "la dolce vita" journey, blending Italian elegance with lively entertainment, appealing to those seeking a cruise with a strong cultural personality.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Carnival Horizon

    Carrying up to 3,960 passengers and supported by a crew of 1,450, Carnival Horizon cultivates a bustling, family-friendly atmosphere. The ship is designed for high energy, with numerous activity hubs like the Dr. Seuss WaterWorks and SportSquare, ensuring a lively environment for all ages. While general areas are vibrant, quieter retreats like the Serenity Adult-Only Retreat on Deck 15 offer peaceful respites for guests aged 21 and over, demonstrating a thoughtful balance for different preferences. The smart elevator system generally manages crowd flow well, though debarkation can see some congestion.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze accommodates a slightly larger number of guests, with a capacity of 4,126 passengers, operating with an emphasis on a vibrant and social atmosphere. Its "Fun Italian Style" translates into a spirited environment, particularly noticeable in its entertainment venues and themed deck parties. While the ship is geared towards families with dedicated kids' clubs, public spaces can feel more intimate, leading to a more energetic, sometimes crowded, feel in popular areas. The Terrazza Moda area offers a semi-exclusive retreat for certain cabin guests aged 12 and older, providing a slightly more relaxed ambiance.

    Dining

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon offers a wide array of dining, blending complimentary favorites with enticing specialty options. Guests can enjoy three-course meals at the Meridian and Reflections main dining rooms, or casual fare at the expansive Lido Marketplace, which features diverse stations like Comfort Kitchen and a made-onboard burrata salad bar. Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina are popular free poolside choices. For an extra fee, experiences range from the intimate Chef's Table and vibrant Bonsai Teppanyaki to the upscale Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse and Italian family-style Cucina del Capitano, ensuring varied culinary adventures.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze leans into its Italian theme with its dining experiences. The complimentary Michelangelo and Medici Restaurants offer elegant three-course meals, with the former providing flexible "MyTime Dining." The Lido Marketplace is a bustling buffet with an Italian garden section, while unique free options include La Strada Grill for Italian street food and Il Mercato, an Italian market. Guy's Burger Joint even gets an Italian twist with specialty burgers. For a fee, Il Viaggio offers upscale Italian, Bonsai Teppanyaki provides interactive dining, and Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse remains a beloved choice, all contributing to a rich gastronomic journey.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Carnival Horizon

    Entertainment on Carnival Horizon is dynamic and diverse, catering to a wide audience. The Liquid Lounge hosts "Playlist Productions" shows with elaborate LED effects, alongside guest entertainers and game shows. For cinema lovers, there's a fee-based IMAX theater and the interactive Thrill Theater. Nightlife thrives with the Punchliner Comedy Club offering both family and adult shows, and various live music venues from the Atrium Bar's dance tunes to country rock at Guy's Pig & Anchor. Themed deck parties and a bustling casino further ensure evenings are filled with energy and options.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze's entertainment and nightlife are infused with an Italian flair, yet still deliver classic Carnival fun. The Teatro Rosso hosts engaging "Playlist Productions" shows and comedy acts for both family and adult audiences. Live music is a cornerstone, with an electric violin trio in the Atrium, singalongs at Piano Bar 88, and Latin sounds at Moda Lounge. Theme parties like "Festa Italiana" and "Masquerade" are prominent, alongside a lively casino and DJs in the Limelight Lounge. While the public spaces can feel tighter, this often translates into a more energetic and communal party atmosphere.

    Cabins & Suites

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon offers a substantial 1,987 cabins, catering to various preferences and budgets. Standard options include Interior (185-220 sq ft, some with obstructed views), Ocean View (185-220 sq ft), and Balcony staterooms (185 sq ft with 35 sq ft balconies). Unique offerings include Deluxe Ocean View cabins with two bathrooms and Cove Balconies closer to the waterline. Suites like the Grand Suite (345 sq ft with 85 sq ft balcony) and Ocean Suite (275 sq ft with 65 sq ft balcony) provide added space and perks. Specialty cabins, such as Havana (12+ access to Havana pool) and Family Harbor (lounge access, two bathrooms in suites), cater to specific traveler needs.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze features 2,063 staterooms, many accommodating 3-4 passengers, with an interior design reflecting Florentine patterns and wood grain. Standard cabins range from Interior (153-175 sq ft) to Ocean View (200-265 sq ft) and Balcony (185+ sq ft). A standout feature is the "Terrazza" category, which includes Premium Vista Balcony, Premium Balcony, Aft-View Extended Balcony, Cabana, and Interior staterooms. These Terrazza guests, aged 12 and over, enjoy exclusive access to the Terrazza Moda private deck with dedicated lounging, whirlpools, and entertainment. Suites offer enhanced space, mini walk-in closets, whirlpool tubs, and the Terrazza perks.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon maintains Carnival's reputation for friendly, attentive service, with a dedicated stateroom attendant for every room. The onboard style is modern and sophisticated, incorporating bold design elements like the Dreamscape LED funnel. Suite guests receive elevated perks, including priority check-in and boarding, preferential dining assignments, and complimentary laundry service. While the ship's size can lead to busy public areas, the crew strives to deliver a personalized experience, from custom cocktails at Alchemy Bar to interactive dining at Bonsai Teppanyaki, contributing to an overall fun and well-managed cruise.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze delivers a service experience that aligns with Carnival's "Fun Ship" ethos, infused with Italian hospitality. The onboard style is distinct, featuring Florentine-inspired decor that blends classic elegance with a touch of playful kitsch, as seen in the Piazza Duomo atrium. Terrazza stateroom guests enjoy exclusive amenities and a dedicated lounge, enhancing a sense of personalized service. While the crew count isn't specified, the ship maintains a lively atmosphere where staff actively engage with guests, from entertaining chefs at Bonsai Teppanyaki to mixologists at Moda Bar, ensuring a spirited and memorable journey.

    Best Itineraries

    Carnival Horizon

    Carnival Horizon is well-suited for itineraries that emphasize sun-drenched destinations and a variety of shore excursions, given its extensive outdoor activities and family-friendly focus. Its design, with multiple pools, a waterpark, and the SkyRide, makes it ideal for cruises with ample sea days or port calls in warm climates where these features can be fully enjoyed. The ship's diverse dining and entertainment options also mean it thrives on sailings that allow guests to explore everything onboard, whether it's a Caribbean adventure or another popular warm-weather route.

    Carnival Firenze

    Carnival Firenze is uniquely positioned for itineraries along Mexico's Pacific coast from Long Beach, catering to guests seeking a "Fun Italian Style" experience with a south-of-the-border twist. Its thematic design elements and specialized dining, like Tomodoro (Mexican-Italian fusion), perfectly complement voyages exploring Mexican ports. The Terrazza staterooms and their exclusive deck access enhance the experience for those who appreciate a more culturally immersive and slightly more secluded onboard environment, making it an excellent choice for those desiring a distinctive blend of Italian charm and West Coast cruising.

    What reviewers say

    Carnival Horizon

    4/5

    Carnival Horizon is a bold, beautiful ship brimming with activities, dining, and bars, offering a sophisticated yet fun Carnival experience. It's an excellent choice for families seeking a value-packed vacation with endless options for all ages.

    Carnival Firenze

    4.5/5

    Not everyone likes change, and on our inaugural sailing from Long Beach, we heard grousing from some Carnival faithful that Carnival Firenze strayed too far from the Fun Ship formula. We disagree. Behind the Italian trappings, we found a cruise ship that still delivered Carnival value and vibe, as well as tasty food and nightlife -- la dolce vita, indeed.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Carnival Horizon

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Carnival Firenze

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons