Ship Comparison
Carnival Miracle vs Carnival Encounter
Carnival Miracle offers classic Carnival fun with a comfortable, less crowded feel, while Carnival Encounter provides a lively, adventure-packed experience with diverse dining, perfect for families and social travelers.
The verdict
The Carnival Miracle, a Spirit-class ship, shines with its well-designed layout and high passenger-to-space ratio, creating a comfortable and friendly atmosphere. Its 2020 refurbishment brought popular Carnival amenities like Guy’s Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina, alongside its signature fantasy-themed interiors. It's a solid choice for those who appreciate a traditional Carnival experience without feeling overwhelmed by crowds, offering a good balance of relaxation and lively entertainment. The Carnival Encounter, while joining the Carnival fleet in 2025 and having an older hull, is poised to be a vibrant, family-friendly option sailing from Brisbane. It boasts an impressive array of activities like the Edge Adventure Park and multiple pools, complemented by diverse complimentary dining options such as Angelo’s and Dragon Lady. While some cabin interiors may reflect its older origins, the ship focuses on delivering a fun, active, and social holiday for all ages, with exclusive perks for Byron Beach Club suite guests.
Choose Carnival Miracle if…
For those who appreciate a classic Carnival experience with a comfortable, mid-sized ship feel, offering a blend of relaxation and lively activities, and a good passenger-to-space ratio.
Best for
- Cruisers who enjoy a classic Carnival "fun ship" experience in a mid-sized setting.
- Guests who appreciate a good passenger-to-space ratio and less crowded common areas.
- Families seeking a variety of activities and dedicated kids' clubs without feeling overwhelmed.
- Adults looking for dedicated adult-only retreats like Serenity.
- Those who enjoy diverse entertainment, from comedy to live music and a lively casino.
Avoid if
- Light sleepers, due to potential noise from public areas near some cabins.
- Guests on longer cruises who desire extensive dining variety beyond the standard options.
- Travelers expecting the absolute latest innovations found on Carnival's newest, largest ships.
- Those who prefer a very quiet, subdued cruise experience throughout the entire ship.
Choose Carnival Encounter if…
Ideal for families, couples, and groups seeking an active, fun-filled cruise with diverse complimentary dining and adventure-focused entertainment, sailing from Brisbane.
Best for
- Families and groups seeking an active, adventure-filled cruise experience with features like Edge Adventure Park.
- Guests departing from Brisbane looking for year-round South Pacific or Australian coastal itineraries.
- Foodies who appreciate diverse complimentary dining options, including Italian and Asian specialty restaurants.
- Suite guests desiring exclusive perks and access to a private pool deck at the Byron Beach Club.
- Social travelers and partygoers who enjoy lively nightlife and multiple pool areas.
Avoid if
- Travelers who prefer brand-new, modern cabin interiors and decor.
- Guests expecting an all-inclusive experience, as many beverages and premium amenities incur extra charges.
- Light sleepers, as aft cabins may experience engine vibration and some areas are lively.
- Cruisers seeking a traditional, quiet, or highly luxurious cruise experience.
Overall Vibe
Carnival Miracle
The Carnival Miracle, launched in 2004 and refreshed in 2020, carries 2,124 guests across 12 decks, offering an upbeat yet comfortable atmosphere. Its Spirit-class design provides a generous passenger-to-space ratio, making it feel less crowded than some larger ships. The interior design leans into a fantastical, almost whimsical theme, with venues like the Phantom Lounge and Dr. Frankenstein's Lab, creating a distinctive, immersive environment. It's a ship that embraces Carnival's "fun" ethos while maintaining a relaxed, friendly ambiance suitable for all ages.
Carnival Encounter
Joining the Carnival fleet in 2025, Carnival Encounter is a mid-sized vessel accommodating 3,000 guests across 17 decks. Despite its older origins, it projects a lively, party-oriented, and family-friendly vibe, designed for both active fun and laid-back relaxation. The ship aims to provide a comprehensive holiday experience with diverse interests in mind, from adventure activities at Edge Adventure Park to the exclusive Byron Beach Club. Its focus is on a balance of exhilaration and chill, all within an approachable and affordable setting.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Carnival Miracle
With a capacity for 2,124 passengers and a dedicated crew of 934, the Carnival Miracle maintains a friendly and comfortable atmosphere that often feels less crowded, offering a good passenger-to-space ratio. The vibe is upbeat and fun-focused, appealing to a mix of ages seeking a relaxed pace during the day with plenty of activities available from morning until late evening. Guests can easily find quiet corners or join in the lively pool deck events, depending on their mood.
Carnival Encounter
The Carnival Encounter, hosting up to 3,000 guests with a crew of 1,100, is designed for a lively, family-friendly, and party-oriented experience. Its ambiance is laidback and approachable, welcoming couples, families, and groups of friends. While activity-rich, particularly with the Edge Adventure Park and multiple pools, it also provides adult-only retreats like The Oasis for those seeking tranquility amidst the fun. The ship's overall atmosphere encourages social interaction and high energy, reflecting Carnival's signature style.
Dining
Carnival Miracle
Dining on Carnival Miracle offers a comfortable mix of included and specialty options. Guests can enjoy traditional three-course dinners at the Bacchus and Ariadne dining rooms, or opt for the more casual Lido Marketplace, which can be bustling at peak times. Popular complimentary choices include Guy’s Burger Joint for renowned poolside burgers and BlueIguana Cantina for fresh, customizable Mexican bites. For a more refined experience, Nick & Nora's Steakhouse provides doting service and gourmet cuts for an additional charge, while The Chef's Table offers an exclusive, multi-course culinary journey.
Carnival Encounter
Carnival Encounter provides a diverse culinary landscape with several complimentary specialty venues. Guests can savor modern Australian classics at The Waterfront, authentic Italian at Angelo’s, and East Asian flavors at Dragon Lady, all included in the fare. The Pantry offers a popular food court style buffet with ocean views. For an elevated experience, Luke's Bar & Grill by celebrity chef Luke Mangan and The Chef’s Table offer for-a-fee gourmet options, emphasizing presentation and unique dishes.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Carnival Miracle
The Carnival Miracle keeps guests entertained from dawn to night with a robust schedule. The Phantom Main Show Lounge hosts Playlist Productions and comedy, while the Mad Hatter's Ball Lounge offers varied events and standup. For nightlife, Mr. Lucky's Casino provides gaming, the Alchemy Bar crafts sophisticated cocktails, Sam's Piano Bar invites sing-alongs, and Dr. Frankenstein's Lab Dance Club keeps the party going for those 18 and older, often peaking before midnight.
Carnival Encounter
Carnival Encounter boasts a dynamic entertainment lineup, including dazzling Playlist Productions in the Marquee Theatre and the adults-only Black Circus with its burlesque and comedy acts. Thrill-seekers can explore the Edge Adventure Park with ziplining and a bridge walk during the day. As evening descends, the Altitude Nightclub caters to partygoers, while the Casino offers gaming. Live music, piano bar sessions, and Dive-In Movies under the stars complete the varied options for all preferences.
Cabins & Suites
Carnival Miracle
Carnival Miracle offers 1,062 cabins, with 64% featuring balconies, providing ample choice for sea views. Standard cabins are a comfortable 185 square feet. Suite options include Junior, Ocean, Vista, and Grand Suites, each offering additional space and perks like priority services, pillow-top mattresses, and bathrobes. Vista Suites are notable for their wraparound balconies, while Ocean Suites feature a walk-in closet and tub. Some Deck 5 balcony rooms have obstructed views.
Carnival Encounter
The Carnival Encounter features 1,298 cabins across seven decks, with over half offering balconies. Standard balcony rooms are 16 square meters, while Ocean Suites provide 21 square meters and a shower-over-bath. A unique offering is the Byron Beach Club suite category, ranging from Ocean to Presidential Suites, which include exclusive access to the Byron Beach Club with its private pool deck and dedicated staff. While clean and well-maintained, the cabins reflect the ship's older origins and may appear somewhat dated.
Service & Onboard Style
Carnival Miracle
The service on Carnival Miracle is consistently noted for being friendly and efficient, contributing to a comfortable journey. The crew of 934 is well-versed in creating a welcoming atmosphere, particularly in the main Bacchus Dining Room where waiters often engage in upbeat dance routines, adding a touch of fun to dinner. The ship's overall style, characterized by its fantasy-themed interiors and the iconic red-domed Atrium, is distinctly Carnival, aiming for an engaging and unpretentious environment that fosters a sense of enjoyment.
Carnival Encounter
Carnival Encounter, with its 1,100 crew members, delivers a laidback and welcoming service style, particularly highlighted by the dedicated staff within the exclusive Byron Beach Club. The ship's ethos is centered on providing a blended holiday experience, meaning service aims to balance energetic fun with moments of relaxation. While cabins may show their age, the overall onboard style is geared towards a modern, active, and social cruise, with a focus on diverse activities and dining.
Best Itineraries
Carnival Miracle
Carnival Miracle is well-suited for itineraries that benefit from its comfortable, mid-sized design and a variety of onboard activities, making it ideal for cruises to destinations like the Caribbean or Mexico. Its solid deck layout and generous space ratio enhance enjoyment on sea days, while the retractable roof over the Ulysses pool ensures all-weather usability, perfect for diverse climates. The ship's array of dining and entertainment options ensures a lively experience throughout the journey.
Carnival Encounter
Sailing year-round from Brisbane, Carnival Encounter is perfectly positioned for exploring the South Pacific and Australian coastal destinations. Its extensive family-friendly features, including the Edge Adventure Park and multiple pools, make it a strong choice for families looking for active holidays in warmer climates. The diverse complimentary dining options and child-free retreats also cater to couples and groups seeking varied experiences within a relaxed, social atmosphere.
What reviewers say
Carnival Miracle
4/5Carnival Miracle is a comfortable, mid-sized ship offering an upbeat environment with activities from dawn till night, making it a good choice for cruisers of all ages. While appealing to Carnival regulars, it may feel short on diverse dining options for longer voyages.
Carnival Encounter
4/5Carnival Encounter offers an affordable and enjoyable cruise experience for all ages, despite its older origins. It's a crowd-pleaser with a laidback vibe, making it a great choice for budget-conscious travelers seeking fun.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Carnival Miracle
Carnival Encounter
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B

