Carnival Elation

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Cruise Line

    Carnival Freedom

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Carnival Elation vs Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Elation offers classic charm and value for a relaxed, uncrowded escape, while Carnival Freedom delivers a livelier, upgraded experience for multi-generational fun.

    The verdict

    Carnival Elation, a cherished Fantasy-class vessel, is perfect for cruisers seeking a classic, intimate, and value-packed experience with a friendly crew and a comfortable pace. Her smaller size and retro charm create a relaxed atmosphere, ideal for families and those who appreciate traditional cruising without the mega-ship bustle. Carnival Freedom, a larger Conquest-class ship, shines with its extensive Fun Ship 2.0 upgrades, offering a vibrant, modern, and activity-rich environment that caters exceptionally well to multigenerational families and social travelers looking for abundant dining and entertainment options.

    Choose Carnival Elation if…

    Carnival Elation is ideal for families and nostalgic cruisers who prefer a smaller, more intimate ship experience with a focus on value, classic fun, and an uncrowded atmosphere.

    Best for

    • Families seeking a budget-friendly trip
    • Cruisers who prefer smaller, less crowded ships
    • Those looking for a classic, unpretentious cruise experience
    • Travelers prioritizing value and a relaxed pace

    Avoid if

    • Guests desiring cutting-edge technology and modern design
    • Travelers who prefer a wide array of upscale specialty dining
    • Those sensitive to potential noise from public areas in certain cabins
    • Anyone seeking a vast, bustling mega-ship experience

    Choose Carnival Freedom if…

    Carnival Freedom is perfect for multigenerational families and social travelers seeking a lively, value-oriented cruise with modern amenities, diverse dining, and abundant entertainment options.

    Best for

    • Multigenerational families with diverse interests
    • Social travelers who enjoy lively nightlife and varied entertainment
    • Foodies seeking abundant and highly-rated complimentary dining
    • Guests looking for a balance of relaxation and active fun

    Avoid if

    • Cruisers sensitive to noise in cabins near public areas
    • Those who prefer a very quiet, intimate ship environment
    • Travelers who dislike crowded pools on sea days
    • Guests expecting consistently gourmet buffet quality across all offerings

    Overall Vibe

    Carnival Elation

    A classic experience from its 1998 build, refurbished in 2017, the Carnival Elation maintains a charming, uncrowded feel. As a Fantasy-class ship across its 15 decks, she evokes a sense of retro fun with a blend of 1970s colors and geometric patterns, alongside some Vegas-style decor. This vessel is about delivering a traditional cruise experience at a good value, where ease of navigation and a familiar atmosphere take precedence over the latest mega-ship innovations. It’s for those who appreciate a relaxed pace and a comfortable, no-frills journey.

    Carnival Freedom

    Launched in 2007 and last refurbished in 2019, Carnival Freedom offers a more contemporary, yet still value-oriented, experience. As a mid-sized Conquest-class ship spanning 14 decks, she accommodates 2,974 passengers. The vibe here is lively and designed for multigenerational families, showcasing successful Fun Ship 2.0 upgrades that brought fresh concepts and enhanced dining. While some older spaces retain their original flair, the overall feel is one of well-executed fun and a dynamic atmosphere, offering a broader array of modern activities and venues.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Carnival Elation

    With a capacity for 2,190 passengers and a crew of 920, Carnival Elation provides a more intimate and less crowded environment. The atmosphere is distinctly family-friendly, lively, and casual, embodying a classic cruise experience. Guests often describe it as unpretentious, making it easy to settle in and find your rhythm. The smaller scale fosters a relaxed social setting, where you might encounter the same friendly faces throughout your voyage, contributing to a comfortable, community feel that many cruisers cherish.

    Carnival Freedom

    Catering to a larger crowd of 2,974 passengers with 1,160 crew members, Carnival Freedom thrives on a lively and energetic, multigenerational atmosphere. The ship is designed for fun-for-all-ages, ensuring there are ample opportunities for both families and adults to enjoy themselves. While it's a larger vessel, the strategic layout and diverse venues mean that while there's always something happening, you can still find spaces for relaxation. The overall ambiance is vibrant, with a focus on engaging activities and socializing across various age groups.

    Dining

    Carnival Elation

    Dining on Carnival Elation offers a solid range of included options. Guests can enjoy traditional assigned-time dinners at Inspiration Restaurant or flexible "Your Time Dining" at Imagination Restaurant, both offering rotating menus and lively waiter entertainment. Casual bites are plentiful at Tiffany's Lido Buffet, open almost constantly with various stations, including 24/7 soft-serve at Swirls and desserts at The Sweet Spot. For quick, flavorful meals, Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina are poolside favorites, alongside Carnival Deli and Pizza Pirate, the latter also open 24 hours. For an extra fee, The Chef's Table offers an exclusive gourmet experience, and Bonsai Sushi Express provides a la carte sushi.

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Freedom provides an extensive and highly-rated complimentary dining scene. The main dining rooms, Posh and Chic, offer traditional and flexible dining, including a sit-down breakfast and the popular (extra fee) Green Eggs and Ham character breakfast. The sprawling Lido Marketplace features a variety of stations, from the Comfort Kitchen to a Mongolian Wok, plus 24-hour pizza and soft-serve. Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina are standout poolside venues for fresh, made-to-order options. For specialty experiences, guests can indulge at the upscale Steakhouse, the intimate Chef's Table, or enjoy a la carte options at the Seafood Shack and Bonsai Sushi Express, or specialty coffees at the Viennese Cafe.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Carnival Elation

    Entertainment on Carnival Elation leans into classic cruise fun with a touch of retro charm. The Mikado Main Show Lounge hosts Playlist Productions with various music-themed shows, while The Punchliner Comedy Club offers both family-friendly and adult-only performances in the Limelight Lounge. Live music can be found across several venues, including the Atrium and Duke's Piano Bar. For those seeking thrills, the Casablanca Casino provides slots and table games. During the day, WaterWorks water park, mini-golf, and a video arcade keep all ages engaged.

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Freedom boasts a diverse and energetic entertainment lineup, enhanced by its Fun Ship 2.0 upgrades. The Victoriana Theater showcases four distinct Playlist Productions shows, while the International Lounge hosts the popular Punchliner Comedy Club with family and adult sets. Nightlife options are varied, from the lively 70s Nightclub and various themed Lido parties to specialized bars like Alchemy Bar for handcrafted cocktails, RedFrog Pub for a casual vibe, and Scott's Piano Bar for sing-alongs. Daytime fun includes the WaterWorks water park, a mini-golf course with ancient civilization themes, and "Dive In" movies at the Seaside Theater.

    Cabins & Suites

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Elation offers generally spacious and comfortable cabins, featuring two twin beds convertible to a king, ample storage, and basic bathrooms with showers. Interior cabins, including unique Porthole options, are 185 sq ft and can accommodate up to five guests. Ocean View staterooms also provide 185 sq ft with a large picture window. Balcony staterooms offer 220 total sq ft, with a 35 sq ft private outdoor space. Suites, such as Junior, Grand, and the expansive Grand Vista Suite (410 sq ft with a 62 sq ft balcony), provide more room and VIP amenities including priority services and premium bath products. Guests should note potential noise on decks 7 and 9, and obstructed views in some Deck 11 Junior Suites.

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Freedom's cabins, while similarly styled, offer a broader range of options and some enhanced features following its 2019 refurbishment. Standard interior cabins are 185 sq ft, with Ocean View and Balcony categories also being 185 sq ft internally, but balcony sizes vary up to 75 sq ft for wraparounds. Unique options include Interior with Picture Window (Walkway View) and Scenic Ocean View with floor-to-ceiling windows. The 42 suites, including Junior, Ocean, Grand, and the spacious Captain’s Suites (up to five guests with two full bathrooms), come with elevated amenities like Elemis bath products and priority services. Light sleepers should consider cabins on the Riviera Deck (Deck 1) due to potential noise from public areas on decks 2, 6, and 8.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Carnival Elation

    Carnival Elation prides herself on a friendly and attentive crew, a hallmark of the Carnival experience. The ship's classic Fantasy-class design, while older, contributes to a more intimate setting where crew members can offer a more Personalized touch. Dedicated stateroom attendants ensure comfort and convenience, upholding the line's commitment to guest satisfaction. The overall style is unpretentious and focused on creating a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere where guests feel genuinely welcomed and cared for throughout their journey.

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Freedom maintains a high standard of service, with a crew of 1,160 dedicated to ensuring a lively and comfortable experience for its 2,974 passengers. The ship’s onboard style, enhanced by its 2019 refurbishment, balances modern "Fun Ship 2.0" concepts with Carnival’s signature fun-loving ethos. Guests can expect a dedicated room steward and generally efficient service across the board. The focus is on facilitating a dynamic and engaging vacation, where crew interaction contributes significantly to the energetic and family-friendly atmosphere.

    Best Itineraries

    Carnival Elation

    While specific itineraries aren't detailed in the payload, Carnival Elation, as a smaller, classic Fantasy-class ship, is often ideal for shorter, value-focused cruises to popular destinations. Her size allows for access to a broader range of ports, making her a versatile choice for quick getaways or those looking to explore regional waters without committing to longer voyages. Guests seeking a traditional cruise experience with a focus on port visits and a more manageable ship size will find her appealing for flexible, engaging routes.

    Carnival Freedom

    Carnival Freedom, a mid-sized Conquest-class vessel, typically offers a wider variety of itineraries, often including longer voyages to diverse destinations, leveraging its larger capacity and broader onboard offerings. Her more extensive amenities, including enhanced dining and entertainment, make her suitable for guests who value both destination exploration and a robust shipboard experience. Families and those seeking a comprehensive cruise vacation with plenty of sea day activities will appreciate her flexibility for varied and engaging routes.

    What reviewers say

    Carnival Elation

    4/5

    Carnival Elation, though an older Fantasy-class ship, offers a charming, uncrowded experience with a strong focus on family fun and value. Its recent upgrades and dedicated crew ensure a good time for those seeking a classic cruise without the mega-ship scale.

    Carnival Freedom

    4.5/5

    Carnival Freedom offers tremendous value with a fun-for-all-ages atmosphere, making it a great choice for multigenerational families. While some spaces could use refinement, its fresh concepts and extensive complimentary dining ensure a good time onboard.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Carnival Elation

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Carnival Freedom

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons