Brilliance of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Icon of the Seas

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Brilliance of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas

    For a classic, intimate cruise experience with stunning views, Brilliance of the Seas shines; for unparalleled family adventure and innovative thrills, Icon of the Seas is the new standard.

    The verdict

    Choosing between Brilliance of the Seas and Icon of the Seas really comes down to the kind of cruise experience you're seeking. Brilliance offers a more traditional, midsize ship feel, emphasizing relaxation, scenic vistas, and a comfortable, less frenetic pace. It's a wonderful choice for those who appreciate classic cruising, engaging conversations, and a more intimate atmosphere. Icon, on the other hand, is a groundbreaking mega-ship designed as a destination in itself, packed with innovative thrills, diverse neighborhoods, and an extraordinary array of activities perfect for multi-generational families and those who thrive on constant excitement. It’s about scale: Brilliance offers a delightful escape, while Icon delivers an immersive, high-energy resort at sea.

    Choose Brilliance of the Seas if…

    Travelers who appreciate a classic, comfortable cruise experience with an emphasis on stunning ocean views, easy navigation, and a more relaxed pace. It's also well-suited for social adults and families during off-peak seasons who enjoy a mix of engaging activities and quiet corners.

    Best for

    • Travelers seeking a classic, comfortable cruise with panoramic ocean views.
    • Guests who prefer a midsize ship that is easy to navigate and generally uncongested.
    • Adults and couples looking for a relaxed yet social atmosphere with live music and engaging lounges.
    • Families traveling during off-peak seasons who appreciate dedicated youth programs and a mix of activities.
    • Value-conscious foodies who enjoy good quality complimentary dining and appealing specialty options.

    Avoid if

    • Guests sensitive to smoke, as the Casino Royale and sometimes other areas can have a smoky odor.
    • Families expecting a mega-ship's extensive waterparks and thrill rides.
    • Travelers seeking cutting-edge, high-tech entertainment and nightlife.
    • Those looking for ultra-modern cabin designs or expansive, innovative family suites.

    Choose Icon of the Seas if…

    Families and groups seeking an action-packed, resort-style vacation with an incredible array of innovative thrills, diverse dining, and dedicated spaces for all ages. It's for those who want the ship to be the primary destination and are ready for a vibrant, high-energy experience.

    Best for

    • Families and multi-generational groups seeking an action-packed, resort-style vacation.
    • Thrill-seekers eager to experience the largest waterpark at sea and innovative rides like Crown's Edge.
    • Guests who prioritize diverse dining options, including unique food halls and specialty restaurants.
    • Social and entertainment enthusiasts looking for vibrant nightlife and impressive theatrical productions.
    • Travelers wanting a ship that is a destination in itself, especially for Caribbean itineraries including Perfect Day at CocoCay.

    Avoid if

    • Guests preferring a quieter, more intimate cruise experience without large crowds.
    • Budget-conscious travelers, as the ship comes with a higher price tag and many premium experiences have additional costs.
    • Those sensitive to constant high energy and a bustling atmosphere.
    • Travelers seeking traditional, classic cruise ship decor and fewer modern distractions.

    Overall Vibe

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Brilliance of the Seas, launched in 2002 and last refurbished in 2018, embodies the comfortable, midsize Radiance-class experience. Its design thoughtfully incorporates glass, with a stunning nine-story central atrium and outside-facing elevators, ensuring passengers are always connected to the ocean views. This ship maintains a classic cruise feeling, offering a blend of lively public spaces and serene retreats. It's a vessel that feels easy to navigate, with a relaxed flow that invites guests to settle in and enjoy the journey rather than just the destinations. The atmosphere is generally uncongested, even during busier times, which is a hallmark of its design.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas, launched in 2023, is a groundbreaking mega-ship designed as a floating family resort. As the world's largest ship, it features eight distinct neighborhoods, five of which are entirely new concepts. The vibe is one of unparalleled choice, innovation, and high-energy family fun, with a full-time resident golden retriever, Rover, adding a unique touch. From the kinetic art of The Pearl to the tranquil Overlook within the AquaDome, this vessel is a destination in itself. It promises a vibrant, resort-like experience where every family member, from toddlers to grandparents, can find their own slice of vacation paradise across its 20 decks.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Brilliance of the Seas

    With a passenger capacity of 2,501 and a dedicated crew of 848, Brilliance of the Seas fosters a comfortable, easy-to-navigate atmosphere. The ship generally avoids feeling overly crowded, allowing for a relaxed pace throughout its 12 decks. During peak seasons, it attracts families with children, who enjoy the dedicated youth programs and activities like the rock climbing wall. However, outside these times, it appeals more to adults and couples looking for a social yet unhurried experience, often featuring live music in lounges and engaging conversation spots, making it a versatile choice for different demographics.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas, a mega-ship accommodating up to 5,610 passengers with a crew of 2,350, is designed for a bustling, vibrant atmosphere. Its eight distinct neighborhoods cleverly manage the large crowd, creating diverse zones for different moods and activities. The ship excels in providing a multi-generational family environment, with areas like Surfside specifically catering to young children and their parents, and numerous pools and thrill rides for older kids and adults. While offering plenty of space, the overall energy is high, reflecting its focus on action-packed and immersive experiences for all onboard.

    Dining

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Brilliance of the Seas offers a solid selection of dining options for its size. The complimentary Minstrel Dining Room provides a traditional, elegant experience with daily rotating menus, while the Windjammer buffet is a reliable choice for quick, varied meals with themed stations. For specialty dining, guests can savor prime cuts at Chops Grille, rustic Italian flavors at Giovanni's Table, or delicate Asian dishes at Izumi, all for an additional fee. The casual Park Café and Café Latte-tudes provide lighter fare and coffee. The ship also offers a Chef's Table for an intimate, gourmet experience and room service for convenience.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas takes dining variety to a new level with over 40 options. Complimentary venues include the expansive Dining Room, the efficient Windjammer Marketplace with diverse stations, and the innovative AquaDome Market food hall. Families will appreciate Surfside Eatery and Surfside Bites, tailored for younger palates, while Pearl Cafe offers 24-hour grab-and-go. Specialty options abound, such as the upscale Empire Supper Club, the lively Izumi Hibachi & Sushi, Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar, and Hooked Seafood. The Celebration Table provides a Personalized private dining experience, ensuring every culinary preference is met with flair.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Brilliance of the Seas offers a diverse array of entertainment that leans into classic cruise traditions. The Pacifica Theatre hosts Broadway-inspired shows with a live orchestra, while the Centrum dazzles with aerial acrobatics. For active fun, there's a rock climbing wall and mini-golf course. Nightlife centers around social lounges like the nautical-themed Schooner Bar with its piano sing-alongs, the elegant Viking Crown Lounge offering panoramic views and dancing, and the Starquest Nightclub with its revolving bar and DJ. The Casino Royale provides gaming excitement, and themed parties like the '70s Disco Party' add to the lively atmosphere.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas delivers a revolutionary entertainment lineup with cutting-edge venues. The AquaTheater features gravity-defying shows like 'Aqua Action!' and 'Pirates vs. Mermaids,' while Absolute Zero boasts the largest ice arena at sea for spectacular ice shows. Thrill-seekers can brave the Category 6 Waterpark with six slides, including Storm Surge and Pressure Drop, or test their courage on Crown's Edge. Nightlife is vibrant with Dueling Pianos, Spotlight Karaoke, The Attic comedy club, and live music at Lou’s Jazz n’ Blues and Music Hall. The Hideaway features the first suspended infinity pool at sea, creating a unique beach club vibe.

    Cabins & Suites

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Brilliance of the Seas offers 1,557 staterooms, including Interior, Oceanview, Balcony, and Suite categories. Standard cabins, like the 170 sq. ft. Ocean View and Interior options, provide comfortable retreats, while Deluxe and Superior Balcony staterooms offer private outdoor space. Families might appreciate the Ultra Spacious Ocean View (265 sq. ft.) with bunk beds for up to six guests. Suites, ranging from Junior Suites (299 sq. ft.) to the expansive Royal Suite (952 sq. ft. with a 283 sq. ft. balcony), offer enhanced space and amenities. Grand Suite and higher categories include concierge service, priority boarding, and luxury bathrobes.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas boasts 2,805 cabins across 28 subcategories, with over 80% designed for three or more guests. The ship introduces innovative options like the Infinite Ocean View Balcony, where a window drops down to create an open-air space. For families, the Surfside Family Suite and the incredible three-level Ultimate Family Townhouse, complete with a slide and game table, are standout choices. Suites are tiered into Sea, Sky, and Star classes, offering escalating perks. Star Tier suites, including the Royal Loft Suite (up to 2,088 sq. ft.), provide a Royal Genie, complimentary specialty dining, and beverage packages, redefining luxury at sea.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Brilliance of the Seas

    On Brilliance of the Seas, the service is generally attentive, with a crew of 848 dedicated to a more intimate guest experience. The onboard style is classic and comfortable, featuring a nine-story glass atrium that creates an open, airy feel. While the decor might feel a bit more traditional, the ship prides itself on well-maintained public venues and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Concierge services are a notable perk for suite guests, offering Personalized assistance. The overall style is one of relaxed elegance, where guests can enjoy a high level of comfort and genuine hospitality without feeling overwhelmed by crowds.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas, with its vast crew of 2,350 serving up to 5,610 guests, prioritizes a high-energy, Personalized resort-style service. The ship's style is contemporary and innovative, with distinct themed neighborhoods and cutting-edge design elements like the kinetic art sphere, The Pearl. Suite guests in the Star Tier receive the exclusive Royal Genie service, providing a truly bespoke experience. The commitment to family fun and diverse offerings means service is geared towards facilitating a seamless, action-packed vacation. While a large ship, the thoughtful layout and dedicated staff ensure a smooth flow and responsive service across its many attractions.

    Best Itineraries

    Brilliance of the Seas

    Brilliance of the Seas is a versatile ship, offering a wide range of itineraries that appeal to different tastes. It sails to various destinations, including 3 and 4-night Bahamas Getaways, which are popular for shorter escapes. For longer voyages, it offers 7-night cruises to the Western Caribbean, Southern Caribbean, Eastern Caribbean, Greek Isles, Italy & Croatia, and Greece & Croatia. It also undertakes longer Transatlantic sailings, such as the 15-night Spain & Bermuda or Spain & Portugal routes. Its midsize nature makes it suitable for exploring diverse ports, from lively Caribbean islands to historic Mediterranean cities.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas primarily focuses on Caribbean itineraries, maximizing the enjoyment of its extensive onboard features and the exclusive Perfect Day at CocoCay. Its typical offerings include 7-night cruises to the Eastern Caribbean & Perfect Day and Western Caribbean & Perfect Day. These itineraries are designed to complement the ship's resort-like experience, providing a balance of thrilling days at sea and calls at popular, vibrant ports. The emphasis is on delivering a comprehensive vacation where the ship itself is a major highlight, making it ideal for those seeking a destination-rich cruise experience in the Caribbean.

    What reviewers say

    Brilliance of the Seas

    4/5

    This comfortable, midsize ship is a good choice for theme cruises or short itineraries. Its design emphasizes stunning views and easy navigation, making for a pleasant experience.

    Icon of the Seas

    4.5/5

    Innovation and fun are found at every turn on the biggest ship in the world, delivering on its promise of family thrills and incredible choice. This ship offers an exceptional experience for families or groups traveling together who want a ship that is the destination.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Brilliance of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Icon of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B