Allure of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Allure of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Mariner of the Seas

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Allure of the Seas vs Mariner of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas offers a grand, immersive resort-at-sea experience, while Mariner of the Seas delivers an action-packed, value-focused getaway for shorter cruises.

    The verdict

    If you're seeking a vast, vibrant, and bustling floating city with an endless array of activities and entertainment for all ages, Allure of the Seas is an excellent choice. It promises a diverse and immersive vacation, though it's wise to budget for specialty dining and some popular activities. Mariner of the Seas, on the other hand, is a fantastic option for those desiring an energetic, family-friendly escape, especially for shorter Caribbean itineraries. It offers a strong lineup of thrills and dining without the overwhelming scale of its larger counterpart, making it a great value.

    Choose Allure of the Seas if…

    Allure of the Seas is ideal for family adventure seekers, active thrill-seekers, social and entertainment enthusiasts, gourmet explorers, and those who appreciate a relaxed urbanite vibe amidst a grand setting.

    Best for

    • Families seeking diverse activities and entertainment for all ages, from toddlers to teens.
    • Active individuals and thrill-seekers looking for surf simulators, zip-lining, and rock climbing.
    • Social guests who enjoy bustling promenades, lively bars, and Broadway-style shows.
    • Gourmet explorers interested in a wide range of complimentary and specialty dining options.
    • Those who appreciate a 'floating city' experience with distinct themed 'neighborhoods'.

    Avoid if

    • You prefer a quiet, intimate cruise experience with fewer crowds.
    • You are on a strict budget, as specialty dining and many activities incur additional costs.
    • You dislike large ships and prefer smaller, more traditional vessels.
    • You seek extensive, uninterrupted sunbathing in adults-only areas on sea days (Solarium can be crowded).

    Choose Mariner of the Seas if…

    Mariner of the Seas is perfect for thrill-seeking families, social weekend warriors, value-conscious foodies, and sunseekers looking for an unwinding escape with plenty of action.

    Best for

    • Families looking for an activity-packed short Caribbean getaway.
    • Social travelers and weekend warriors seeking lively bars, nightlife, and a bustling casino.
    • Value-conscious foodies who appreciate solid complimentary dining and enticing specialty options.
    • Those interested in a mix of Caribbean sun and European cultural itineraries.
    • Guests who enjoy signature Royal Caribbean thrills like FlowRider, waterslides, and Sky Pad.

    Avoid if

    • You prefer modern cabin decor and amenities, as some rooms are noted as dated.
    • You are sensitive to smoke, as smoking is permitted in the Casino Royale.
    • You expect consistent, exciting buffet options for dinner (Windjammer quality dips in the evening).
    • You are looking for a completely serene adults-only pool experience, as the Solarium may have limited direct sun exposure.

    Overall Vibe

    Allure of the Seas

    A true behemoth, Allure of the Seas, an Oasis-class vessel launched in 2009 and refurbished in 2015, spans an impressive 15 decks with a capacity for 5,492 passengers. It's designed as a vibrant, floating city, offering an unparalleled diversity of experiences across its unique 'neighborhoods.' The ship embodies a grand, resort-at-sea feel, perfect for those who thrive on constant activity and exploration, seeking a dynamic and immersive vacation rather than a quiet escape.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas, a Voyager Class ship launched in 2003 and last refreshed in 2012, offers a more intimate yet still action-packed experience across its 14 decks with a capacity for 3,344 passengers. While smaller than Allure, it delivers a high-energy, value-focused vacation, particularly appealing for shorter getaways. It strikes a balance between lively activities and comfortable spaces, creating an accessible and fun-filled atmosphere without the overwhelming scale of a mega-ship.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Allure of the Seas

    With a substantial capacity for 5,492 passengers and a dedicated crew of 2,384, Allure of the Seas cultivates a bustling, high-energy atmosphere. It's a magnet for families, active couples, and diverse groups, all seeking a fun-filled experience. While vibrant, certain areas like the Royal Promenade during parades or the main pool deck on sea days can feel quite crowded, requiring some navigation to find quieter moments, but the ship rarely feels overwhelmingly packed thanks to its sheer size.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas, with 3,344 passengers and a crew of 1,200, fosters a lively, family-friendly vibe that feels more contained than larger ships. It attracts those looking for an affordable, action-packed short Caribbean escape. While popular spots like the main pool deck can be energetic, the ship generally manages crowds well, offering a more approachable and less overwhelming social environment, especially during its shorter itineraries.

    Dining

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas boasts an extensive culinary landscape across its many venues. Complimentary options range from the globally inspired Main Dining Room and 24-hour Cafe Promenade to casual spots like Sorrento's Pizzeria and the Boardwalk Dog House. For a splurge, guests can explore South American flavors at Mason Jar℠, elegant tasting menus at 150 Central Park, or Japanese delights at Izumi Hibachi & Sushi. Suite guests also enjoy exclusive access to Coastal Kitchen for Mediterranean-inspired dishes.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas offers a solid array of dining, balancing included choices with enticing specialty venues. Guests can enjoy the elegant Main Dining Room or the bustling Windjammer Marketplace for diverse buffet options, though the buffet tends to be less exciting for dinner. For a fee, Jamie's Italian by Jamie Oliver provides Tuscan-inspired dishes, while Chops Grille℠ serves classic American steakhouse fare. The Bamboo Room offers unique Polynesian cocktails and light bites, and Playmakers℠ Sports Bar & Arcade provides classic bar grub.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Allure of the Seas

    Entertainment on Allure of the Seas is a spectacle, from Broadway's *Mamma Mia!* and acrobatic *Blue Planet* shows in the Amber Theater to the high-diving *OceanAria* at the AquaTheater. Thrill-seekers have the Zip Line, Ultimate Abyss℠ slide, FlowRider®, and rock climbing walls. Nightlife thrives with diverse bars like the unique Rising Tide Bar and the lively Dazzles, plus themed parties, karaoke at On Air Club, and a bustling Casino Royale℠, ensuring constant activity.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas packs a punch with its entertainment, featuring the FlowRider® surf simulator, The Perfect Storm℠ waterslides, the Sky Pad virtual reality bungee trampoline, and rock climbing walls. The Royal Theater hosts original productions and game shows, while Studio B offers ice skating and *Ice Under The Big Top*. For evening fun, guests can enjoy live Latin music at Boleros, piano sing-alongs at Schooner Bar, the energetic Playmakers℠ Sports Bar & Arcade, or test their wits in the Royal Escape Room℠: The Observatorium.

    Cabins & Suites

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas offers 2,859 cabins, including 711 larger options and 46 accessible staterooms. Highlights include multi-level Royal Loft Suites and Star Loft Suites, plus various AquaTheater Suites with expansive balconies and ocean views. While standard cabins are functional with convertible twin-to-king beds and ample storage, some interior-facing balconies may experience noise, and electrical outlets are limited to the vanity area, which can be a minor inconvenience.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas provides 1,674 cabins, ranging from cozy interiors to luxurious suites. While cabins are comfortable, the decor is noted as somewhat dated with '90s-era prints and light oak furnishings. Suite options like the Royal Suite and Owner’s Suite offer enhanced space and perks, including Concierge Lounge access. Promenade View Interior rooms offer a view of the Royal Promenade but can be subject to noise, and interior rooms are generally considered cramped and windowless.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Allure of the Seas

    The service on Allure of the Seas is generally attentive, with a crew of 2,384 dedicated to a Personalized experience. Suite guests benefit from perks like Personalized Royal Genie Service for Star Class and Concierge Service for Sky Class, enhancing their journey with exclusive access and amenities like Coastal Kitchen. The ship seamlessly integrates digital services via interactive cabin TVs for bookings and account management, alongside touch-screen 'wayfinders' for easy navigation.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas maintains Royal Caribbean’s reputation for friendly service with its 1,200-person crew. Suite guests enjoy access to the Concierge Lounge for complimentary continental breakfast and evening cocktails, along with priority boarding and departure. While Wi-Fi is available and generally faster than older ships, it can be expensive, and Guest Services lines tend to be long during peak embarkation and disembarkation, suggesting a need for patience during these times.

    Best Itineraries

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas primarily sails to the Eastern and Western Caribbean, with many itineraries featuring the private destination Perfect Day at CocoCay. These cruises are typically 6 to 8 nights, focusing on sun-drenched adventures and island exploration. Guests can look forward to a mix of relaxation and high-octane activities, both at sea and ashore, offering a comprehensive Caribbean experience.

    Mariner of the Seas

    Mariner of the Seas focuses on shorter, action-packed Caribbean getaways, often sailing from Orlando, making it ideal for quick escapes. It also offers a diverse range of European itineraries, including cruises to Spain & Portugal and the Norwegian Fjords. This variety provides opportunities for scenic beauty and cultural immersion beyond the typical Caribbean sun, catering to different travel preferences.

    What reviewers say

    Allure of the Seas

    5/5

    If you want a fun-filled cruise with plentiful activities, you can't beat Allure of the Seas. It truly caters to every type of cruiser, offering a diverse range of experiences.

    Mariner of the Seas

    4.5/5

    Mariner of the Seas is an affordable Caribbean cruise option with just enough action to make your short Caribbean vacation one to remember. Activity-filled, weekend-friendly itineraries and great food make an ideal family-friendly sailing.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Allure of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Mariner of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons