Allure of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Allure of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas

    Royal Caribbean International

    Icon of the Seas

    vs

    Ship Comparison

    Allure of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas

    For a seasoned cruiser seeking diverse activities and established charm, Allure of the Seas delivers; for families craving the newest, most innovative, and ultimate resort-at-sea experience, Icon of the Seas is the unparalleled choice.

    The verdict

    Choosing between Allure of the Seas and Icon of the Seas truly depends on your cruise priorities. Allure, an esteemed Oasis-class vessel, offers a proven track record of vibrant, family-friendly fun with a wide array of activities and dining options, all wrapped in a classic Royal Caribbean experience that has been refined over years. Its neighborhood concept, while older, still provides excellent variety and distinct zones for different moods. Icon of the Seas, as the newest and largest in the fleet, pushes the boundaries of family entertainment and innovation. It's designed as a floating resort, offering groundbreaking thrills, novel dining concepts, and dedicated spaces catering to multi-generational families. While Allure provides a fantastic experience with familiar favorites, Icon is for those who want to be at the forefront of cruise innovation, ready to explore new concepts and high-energy adventures at every turn.

    Choose Allure of the Seas if…

    Travelers who appreciate a well-established, lively ship with a vast array of activities, diverse dining, and a proven track record for family fun and entertainment, without necessarily needing the absolute newest innovations.

    Best for

    • Families seeking a wide range of proven activities and entertainment.
    • Active individuals and thrill-seekers who enjoy rock climbing, surfing, and zip-lining.
    • Social and entertainment enthusiasts looking for Broadway shows, ice skating, and diverse nightlife.
    • Guests who appreciate a cruise with distinct themed neighborhoods and zones.

    Avoid if

    • Travelers who prefer smaller, more intimate cruise ships.
    • Budget-conscious guests wary of potential upselling for specialty dining and activities.
    • Those seeking the very newest and most innovative ship features.
    • Guests sensitive to crowds in popular areas during peak times.

    Choose Icon of the Seas if…

    Families and multi-generational groups seeking the cutting-edge of cruise ship innovation, high-adrenaline thrills, and a resort-at-sea experience with dedicated neighborhoods catering to every age group and interest.

    Best for

    • Multi-generational families looking for the ultimate resort-at-sea experience.
    • Thrill-seekers craving the largest waterpark at sea and innovative adventure rides.
    • Guests who prioritize new, cutting-edge ship designs and features.
    • Families wanting dedicated, immersive neighborhoods for children and adults alike.

    Avoid if

    • Cruisers preferring a quieter, more traditional cruise experience.
    • Budget-conscious travelers, as the newest innovations often come with a premium price.
    • Those prone to seasickness, as being on higher decks of a large ship can be felt more.
    • Guests who dislike large crowds, despite the ship's crowd management efforts.

    Overall Vibe

    Allure of the Seas

    The Allure of the Seas, launched in 2009 and refurbished in 2015, embodies the quintessential Oasis-class spirit with its expansive design across 15 decks. It radiates a vibrant, fun-filled energy, renowned for its seven distinct neighborhoods like the peaceful Central Park and the lively Boardwalk. This ship delivers a rich tapestry of experiences, from world-class entertainment to diverse dining, offering a balanced blend of relaxation and adventure that has matured gracefully over the years. It’s a ship that confidently offers something for everyone, making it a reliable choice for a dynamic holiday at sea.

    Icon of the Seas

    The Icon of the Seas, a new class launched in 2023 with 20 decks, immediately sets itself apart as the ultimate floating family resort. Its vibe is unequivocally centered on groundbreaking innovation and high-energy thrills, designed to offer multiple memorable experiences daily. With eight distinct neighborhoods, five of which are entirely new, Icon is a destination in itself. Its design, powered by LNG, emphasizes a forward-thinking approach, creating an environment that feels fresh, modern, and dedicated to delivering the "best family holiday in the world" with unparalleled choices for every member of the crew.

    Atmosphere & Crowd

    Allure of the Seas

    With a passenger capacity of 5,492 and a crew of 2,384, Allure of the Seas maintains a lively yet manageable atmosphere. The ship's innovative neighborhood concept helps disperse crowds, allowing active couples and families alike to find their preferred pace, whether it’s the bustling Royal Promenade or the quieter Solarium. While popular areas like the pool deck and Windjammer Marketplace can get busy during peak times, the sheer size and thoughtful layout prevent it from feeling overwhelmingly crowded. It's a ship that hums with activity without losing its welcoming feel.

    Icon of the Seas

    The Icon of the Seas, accommodating 5,610 passengers with a crew of 2,350, is designed to feel like a vibrant, sprawling family resort. Its eight distinct neighborhoods are key to managing its large capacity, ensuring that while the ship is bustling, guests can always find a suitable space. From the dedicated Surfside area for young families to the tranquil Overlook lounge, the ship offers diverse zones that cater to varied moods and activities. The atmosphere is consistently energetic and inclusive, fostering a sense of shared adventure and fun for multi-generational groups without feeling chaotic.

    Dining

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas provides a comprehensive culinary journey, featuring numerous complimentary options like the Main Dining Room (American Icon, Silk, The Grande), 24-hour Cafe Promenade, Sorrento's Pizzeria, and the casual Park Cafe. For those seeking variety, specialty venues such as Chops Grille for steaks, Izumi Hibachi & Sushi, and the exquisite 150 Central Park offer elevated experiences. The ship consistently delivers good quality and service across its diverse range, ensuring every palate finds something delightful, from South American flavors at Mason Jar to the Brazilian Churrascaria at Samba Grill.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas boasts an impressive "40 ways to dine and drink," introducing new concepts like the AquaDome Market, the fleet's first food hall, and Pier 7 for all-day California-inspired brunch. Complimentary options include the expansive Windjammer Marketplace, Pearl Cafe, and family-focused Surfside Eatery. Specialty dining is a highlight, with an enhanced Chops Grille featuring a butcher's display, Giovanni's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar, and the exclusive Empire Supper Club for an eight-course experience. While complimentary options are good, the specialty venues truly elevate the gastronomic experience, catering to every craving.

    Entertainment & Nightlife

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas shines with its diverse entertainment, offering Broadway productions like *Mamma Mia!* in the Amber Theater, gravity-defying acrobatics at the AquaTheater's *OceanAria*, and dazzling ice shows in Studio B. Nightlife thrives with venues like Dazzles Nightclub, the lively Schooner Bar, and Comedy Live. Unique features like the Rising Tide Bar, which literally moves between decks, and adrenaline-pumping activities like the Zip Line and FlowRider surf simulators, ensure there’s always something captivating and active happening around the ship for all ages.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas redefines entertainment with its innovative lineup. The Royal Theater hosts Broadway's *The Wizard of Oz*, while the AquaTheater presents *Aqua Action!* with robotic arms and a 55-foot water curtain, alongside family-friendly *Pirates vs. Mermaids*. Absolute Zero is the largest ice arena at sea, showcasing spectacular ice shows. Nightlife is vibrant with new venues like Dueling Pianos, Spotlight Karaoke, The Attic comedy club, and Lou's Jazz n' Blues. Thrill-seekers can also challenge Crown's Edge, a part-skywalk, part-zipline ride 154 feet above the sea, or brave Category 6, the largest waterpark at sea.

    Cabins & Suites

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas offers 2,859 cabins, with a majority designed for flexibility, featuring twin beds that convert to a Royal King. Standard cabins are well-appointed with interactive flat-screen TVs and ample storage. The ship also includes 711 large cabins and 46 wheelchair-accessible options. Suites are a significant draw, with categories like the two-story Royal Loft Suite, Owner's Panoramic Suite, and AquaTheater Suites offering impressive space and views. Guests in Grand Suites and above enjoy Sky Class or Star Class perks, including access to Coastal Kitchen and concierge services.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas features 2,805 cabins, with over 80% accommodating three or more guests across 28 subcategories, 14 of which are new. Cabins are designed with a modern, subdued palette and practical amenities like mini-coolers and numerous charging outlets. The ship introduces innovative options like the Ultimate Family Townhouse, a multi-level suite with a slide and private backyard, and Icon Loft Suites. Suite guests benefit from a tiered system (Sea, Sky, Star Class), with Star Class receiving Royal Genie service, complimentary specialty dining, and access to the exclusive two-level Suite Neighborhood and The Grove sundeck.

    Service & Onboard Style

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas maintains Royal Caribbean's reputation for attentive service, with dedicated stateroom attendants ensuring comfort. The onboard style is classic Oasis-class, characterized by its distinct neighborhoods, each offering a unique ambiance, from the lush tranquility of Central Park to the carnival-like fun of the Boardwalk. For suite guests, the Sky Class and Star Class amenities elevate the experience with personalized concierge service, priority boarding, and exclusive access to venues like Coastal Kitchen, ensuring a refined journey for those seeking extra pampering and convenience.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas emphasizes a personalized and seamless experience, bolstered by its innovative design and a crew of 2,350. A unique touch is the presence of Rover, the Chief Dog Officer, adding a charming, home-like feel. The service is enhanced through its tiered suite program, with Sky and Star Class guests receiving priority boarding, internet access, and concierge service, while Star Class enjoys the ultimate Royal Genie service. The ship's style is a bold, modern interpretation of a family resort, with each of its eight neighborhoods thoughtfully designed to provide distinct, high-quality environments and services.

    Best Itineraries

    Allure of the Seas

    Allure of the Seas primarily sails to the Caribbean, offering a broad range of itineraries from 3 to 8 nights. These include diverse routes to the Western, Eastern, and Southern Caribbean, often featuring stops at Royal Caribbean's private island, Perfect Day at CocoCay. It's an ideal choice for cruisers looking for classic Caribbean island hopping combined with ample onboard activity and entertainment, suitable for various trip durations and preferences, ensuring a sun-drenched escape with plenty to explore both at sea and ashore.

    Icon of the Seas

    Icon of the Seas focuses its sailings exclusively on the Caribbean, with every itinerary featuring a stop at Royal Caribbean's acclaimed private island, Perfect Day at CocoCay. Guests can choose from 6, 7, 8, or 9-night cruises exploring both Eastern and Western Caribbean destinations. This focus underscores its identity as a destination-rich vessel, where the ship's offerings are complemented by the ultimate beach day experience on CocoCay. Itineraries are crafted for those who desire a comprehensive, high-energy Caribbean adventure, blending onboard thrills with exclusive island excursions.

    What reviewers say

    Allure of the Seas

    5/5

    If you want a fun-filled cruise with plentiful activities, you can't beat Allure of the Seas. It truly caters to every type of cruiser, offering a diverse range of experiences.

    Icon of the Seas

    4.5/5

    Innovation and fun are found at every turn on the biggest ship in the world, delivering on its promise of family thrills and incredible choice. This ship offers an exceptional experience for families or groups traveling together who want a ship that is the destination.

    Itineraries to compare

    Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.

    Allure of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Icon of the Seas

    No upcoming itineraries listed. Ask our concierge to source private inventory →

    Read our guides

    In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.

    Compare different ships

    Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.

    Ship A

    Ship B

    More comparisons