Ship Comparison
Oasis of the Seas vs Star of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas offers a vibrant, established mega-ship experience, while the brand new Star of the Seas elevates the family resort-at-sea concept with innovative features and guaranteed private island stops.
The verdict
Choosing between Oasis of the Seas and Star of the Seas truly depends on your preference for an established, recently modernized giant versus a cutting-edge, purpose-built family resort. Oasis, having been built in 2009 and refurbished in 2019, has a proven track record for delivering a bustling, active vacation across its 15 decks. Star of the Seas, launching in 2025, represents the next generation of mega-ships, boasting 20 decks and a fresh, whimsical tropical design with many new concepts. Both ships are incredibly family-friendly and packed with activities, but Star of the Seas offers a more integrated, curated family experience with its dedicated Surfside neighborhood and guaranteed visits to Perfect Day at CocoCay on every sailing.
Choose Oasis of the Seas if…
The Oasis of the Seas is ideal for families and active cruisers who appreciate a wide array of activities, diverse dining, and robust entertainment options on an established, well-loved mega-ship. It suits those who enjoy a lively, energetic atmosphere and don't mind a bustling environment with plenty of options to explore.
Best for
- Families with active kids and teens seeking diverse activities.
- Cruisers who enjoy a bustling, energetic atmosphere.
- Guests looking for a wide variety of dining and entertainment options.
- Those who appreciate an established, recently updated mega-ship experience.
Avoid if
- You prefer a quiet, intimate cruise experience.
- You dislike large crowds and long lines for popular attractions.
- You prioritize consistent gourmet dining across all complimentary venues.
- You are prone to seasickness and prefer lower, midship cabins away from noise.
Choose Star of the Seas if…
The Star of the Seas is perfect for families and first-time cruisers seeking the absolute latest in cruise innovation, with a strong emphasis on a resort-like, whimsically tropical experience. It caters to those who desire cutting-edge thrills, extensive family-focused zones, and guaranteed private island adventures on every itinerary.
Best for
- Families seeking the newest and most innovative cruise ship features.
- Guests who want a guaranteed private island experience on every sailing.
- Thrill-seekers looking for the largest waterpark at sea and unique attractions.
- Foodies interested in diverse, upgraded dining concepts, including food halls.
Avoid if
- You prefer smaller, more intimate cruise ships.
- You are on a strict budget, as many premium experiences are extra.
- You dislike being around young children constantly, especially in Surfside cabins.
- You are sensitive to noise, particularly in cabins near the AquaDome or casino.
Overall Vibe
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas, launched in 2009 and revitalized in 2019, carries a distinct aura of being a pioneering mega-ship that has truly stood the test of time. Weighing 226,838 gross tons and spanning 15 decks, she exudes an energetic and innovative spirit, having introduced the revolutionary 'neighborhood' concept at sea. The atmosphere is bustling and active, appealing to those who thrive on constant engagement and a dynamic environment. It's a ship that feels grand and established, yet continuously refreshed, offering a comprehensive holiday experience for active cruisers and families looking for a lively escape.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas, debuting in 2025 as a new Icon-class vessel, is set to redefine the family resort-at-sea experience. With 20 decks, she is designed to be one of the world’s largest cruise ships, presenting a comprehensive, resort-like feel from the moment you step aboard. The vibe is fresh, whimsically tropical, and focused on delivering a cohesive, entertaining experience for everyone, from the youngest cruisers to adults. This ship builds upon Royal Caribbean's legacy with notable upgrades and variations, promising a state-of-the-art and immersive vacation.
Atmosphere & Crowd
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas is a high-energy vessel, typically filled with active families and groups who appreciate a constant buzz. Carrying up to 6,780 passengers and a crew of 2,394, the ship maintains a lively atmosphere throughout its many public spaces. While this creates a vibrant environment, it also means popular attractions and shows can be crowded, especially on sea days. Guests often describe the ship as bustling and energetic, making it an ideal choice for those who enjoy a social and dynamic cruise experience rather than a quiet retreat.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas is crafted to be a vibrant, family-friendly resort, designed to accommodate up to 7,600 passengers across its 20 decks. The atmosphere is characterized as colorful and whimsically tropical, aiming to entertain a broad spectrum of guests from kids to adults. With its expansive new neighborhoods, the ship intends to spread out the crowds, though popular areas will naturally draw many. It’s built for those who thrive in a lively setting, offering a continuous flow of activities and social opportunities for families and first-time cruisers.
Dining
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas offers a substantial array of dining, with 11 complimentary options and 11 specialty venues. The Main Dining Room is known for being noisy but friendly, while the Windjammer Marketplace can feel hectic at peak times. Highlights include the Mediterranean-inspired Solarium Bistro and the casual Park Café, praised for its roast beef sandwiches. For a fee, guests can indulge in Izumi Hibachi & Sushi, the upscale 150 Central Park, or the popular Chops Grille. Johnny Rockets is complimentary for breakfast but charges for lunch and dinner, and Portside BBQ is a favorite for its 'best barbecue at sea' reputation.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas elevates the culinary journey with 23 dining options, featuring new concepts and enhanced favorites. The three-story Dining Room provides an elegant setting, while the Pearl Cafe is a notable 24/7 spot for coffee and snacks. A standout is the AquaDome Market, the fleet's first food hall, offering diverse, made-to-order international dishes that are a significant improvement in quality. Specialty options include the 1930s Chicago-themed Lincoln Park Supper Club, Chops Grille with a new butcher’s display, and Hooked Seafood. Pier 7 offers all-day brunch, and Surfside Eatery caters specifically to families with younger children.
Entertainment & Nightlife
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas is a hub of entertainment, featuring Broadway's 'Cats' in the Royal Theatre and mesmerizing AquaTheater shows like 'Aqua80' with Olympic-caliber divers. Thrill-seekers can brave the Ultimate Abyss dry slide, The Perfect Storm waterslides, FlowRider surf simulators, a zip line, and rock climbing walls. Nightlife is diverse, from the lively Music Hall and Latin rhythms at Boleros to the tech-forward Bionic Bar and intimate piano singalongs at Schooner Bar. Spotlight Karaoke offers both main stage and private room experiences, ensuring there's something for every evening mood.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas promises a new scale of entertainment and nightlife with innovative venues. The Royal Theater hosts 'Back to the Future: The Musical,' and Absolute Zero is the largest ice arena at sea for dazzling ice shows. Thrill Island boasts the Category 6 Waterpark, Crown's Edge skywalk, and Adrenaline Peak rock climbing. The AquaDome offers immersive shows with a 55-foot waterfall. For adults, Dueling Pianos and Lou’s Jazz 'n Blues offer live music, while The Attic provides comedy. The Hideaway features a suspended infinity pool with beach club vibes, and Swim & Tonic is the fleet's largest swim-up bar.
Cabins & Suites
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas offers 2,801 cabins, including 18 large suites, across its 15 decks. Guests can choose from various categories, including Ocean View Balcony, Central Park View Balcony, and spacious suites like the Royal Loft Suite. Suite guests enjoy perks like access to Coastal Kitchen and a dedicated sun deck. While deck plans are generally well-designed, some staterooms may experience noise from venues above or below, with decks 10, 11, and 12 recommended for light sleepers. Connecting and accessible cabins are available to accommodate different family needs.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas features 2,805 cabins across 20 decks, with approximately 70% boasting balconies and 28 distinct room categories. All cabins accommodate at least three guests, starting with a 156 sq. ft. Interior room, and include a convertible king bed. The ship introduces innovative options like the three-story Ultimate Family Townhouse, complete with a slide and hot tub, and Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony cabins with split bathrooms and bunk alcoves. Suite guests benefit from a tiered perk system (Sea, Sky, Star), offering exclusive access to Coastal Kitchen, The Grove Sun Deck, and Personalized Royal Genie service for Star Tier guests.
Service & Onboard Style
Oasis of the Seas
Onboard Oasis of the Seas, the service is generally perceived as friendly and attentive, with a notable mention of singing wait staff in the Main Dining Room contributing to a lively atmosphere. The ship's style is characterized by its energetic and innovative design, divided into distinct neighborhoods that help manage the flow of its 6,780 passengers. Suite guests in Sky Class enjoy concierge service, while Star Class guests receive Personalized Royal Genie service, ensuring a tailored experience amidst the ship's bustling environment.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas is designed with a keen focus on a comprehensive, resort-like experience, emphasizing a modern, whimsically tropical style. While specific crew details are forthcoming, the ship is expected to maintain Royal Caribbean's standard of service, with a strong emphasis on family-friendly engagement. Sky Tier suite guests will receive concierge service and priority access, while the top-tier Star Class guests will benefit from Personalized Royal Genie service. The overall onboard style aims for a vibrant, engaging, and memorable vacation for all, with a focus on seamless experiences for families.
Best Itineraries
Oasis of the Seas
Oasis of the Seas primarily sails to the Caribbean, offering a variety of itineraries including 3, 4, and 7-night Bahamas & Perfect Day cruises, as well as 6 and 7-night Western Caribbean voyages. For those seeking longer adventures, there are 9-night Eastern Caribbean and 8-night Southern Caribbean options. She also undertakes repositioning cruises, such as the 9-night journey from Cape Liberty to Fort Lauderdale, providing diverse routes for guests to explore the warm waters of the Caribbean.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas is poised to offer a focused array of Caribbean itineraries, with every sailing including a stop at the acclaimed Perfect Day at CocoCay. Guests can choose from 7-night Eastern Caribbean & Perfect Day cruises or 7-night Western Caribbean & Perfect Day voyages, departing from Port Canaveral, Florida. This consistent inclusion of the private island experience is a key feature, ensuring guests can enjoy its extensive amenities, from thrilling waterslides to relaxing beaches, on every single trip.
What reviewers say
Oasis of the Seas
4.5/5One of the largest ships in the world, Oasis of the Seas makes an impression even before you board; the mega-ship looms above its counterparts. It has been enthusiastically embraced as one of Royal Caribbean's most beloved vessels, offering a dizzying amount of activities across its manageable neighborhoods.
Star of the Seas
Star of the Seas, Royal Caribbean's second Icon-class vessel, debuts in August 2025 as one of the world's largest cruise ships, offering a comprehensive, family-friendly resort-like experience. It expands on the Oasis Class concept with extensive dining, activities, and cabin options, featuring notable upgrades and variations from its sister ship, Icon of the Seas.
Itineraries to compare
Pick an itinerary on either ship to see all available departure dates.
Oasis of the Seas
Star of the Seas
Read our guides
In-depth guides on the ships and cruise lines in this comparison.
Compare different ships
Swap either side to generate a new side-by-side comparison.
Ship A
Ship B